Advice needed - problems with BMW Dealer
Discussion
Hi All,
I own a 57 plate 325i E93.
- A couple of months ago the roof started creaking so I booked it into my local BMW dealer who ended up adjusting the roof.
- The creak was fixed, but it started leaking when it rained.
- I took it back the next week and they adjusted the roof again and water tested it. The next day it rained and water continued to get into the car at quite an alarming rate.
- So it went back to the dealer and they decided this time that the seals needed to be replaced. They did about 50% of the fee on "goodwill" and charged me £300 to replace the back seals.
4 weeks later:
- The leak is still fixed, but it doesn't look like the seal has been fitted properly. It's pealing away on one side and the glue/resin is bulging and spreading on the chassis.
- During the hot weather last week, some of the glue was baked onto the chassis. I wiped it off with some kitchen paper and water and noticed that it was pulling some of the paintwork off and leaving tiny scratches.
- I took it back to the dealer last week to show them the problem and was greeted by their floor manager. He was very defensive and aggressive and claimed that these problems are normal because of the "hot weather". He said that they should never have done it on goodwill because their claim was rejected by BMW (I'm not surprised, why should BMW pay for this mess?!). He was reluctant to take the car back in and accused me of lying about the origin of the scratches.
- I spoke to the service manager and we ended up having a bit of an argument, mainly because he was advised by the floor manager the the scratches couldn't possible have originated from the glue (despite the problems with the seal being so obvious). I managed to get them to agree to take the car in on Wednesday this week.
I'd like to make sure I'm prepared for another confrontation by being aware of my rights.
Hhow would you guys handle this situation? Are there any regulatory bodies that I could escalate my case to if it's not dealt with this week? Should I write to BMW?
Many thanks.
I own a 57 plate 325i E93.
- A couple of months ago the roof started creaking so I booked it into my local BMW dealer who ended up adjusting the roof.
- The creak was fixed, but it started leaking when it rained.
- I took it back the next week and they adjusted the roof again and water tested it. The next day it rained and water continued to get into the car at quite an alarming rate.
- So it went back to the dealer and they decided this time that the seals needed to be replaced. They did about 50% of the fee on "goodwill" and charged me £300 to replace the back seals.
4 weeks later:
- The leak is still fixed, but it doesn't look like the seal has been fitted properly. It's pealing away on one side and the glue/resin is bulging and spreading on the chassis.
- During the hot weather last week, some of the glue was baked onto the chassis. I wiped it off with some kitchen paper and water and noticed that it was pulling some of the paintwork off and leaving tiny scratches.
- I took it back to the dealer last week to show them the problem and was greeted by their floor manager. He was very defensive and aggressive and claimed that these problems are normal because of the "hot weather". He said that they should never have done it on goodwill because their claim was rejected by BMW (I'm not surprised, why should BMW pay for this mess?!). He was reluctant to take the car back in and accused me of lying about the origin of the scratches.
- I spoke to the service manager and we ended up having a bit of an argument, mainly because he was advised by the floor manager the the scratches couldn't possible have originated from the glue (despite the problems with the seal being so obvious). I managed to get them to agree to take the car in on Wednesday this week.
I'd like to make sure I'm prepared for another confrontation by being aware of my rights.
Hhow would you guys handle this situation? Are there any regulatory bodies that I could escalate my case to if it's not dealt with this week? Should I write to BMW?
Many thanks.
Depends how far you want to go. I caught a dealer trying to charge me for work they hadn't done, and the service manager attempted to get a bit 'bolshie'. I advised that if he didn't put it up on the ramp it was going through the window at high speed, it went on the ramp and i pointed out you can't change brake pads without taking the wheel off....an Alpina wheel....which the key for the locking cap had been in my pocket all along. Take it to BMW UK, lots of pics will help.
Go directly to the Dealer Principal and inform him of everything that has happened with your roof and insist he deals with it, bypass the service manager /garage you re dealing with completely unless authorised by the Dealer Principa to take your car in for repair . There have been problems with the rubber seals on the metal folding roofs on the early convertibles resulting in leaks and creaking roofs, this has absolutely bugger all to do with the weather as your service manager states . Strong adhesive glue Can remove paint , all it takes is the clear lacquer to be penetrated and paint damage will occur eventually . Have heard of this problem before and the owner went through a lot of hassle with the roof and ended up rejecting the car as not fit for purpose and getting a full refund/replacement car . Further enquiries and inspections revealed that the roof was actually twisted /distorted hence the leaking replacement seals etc . Hope you get on with it ok .
Well it's started badly so far.
This morning I noticed that the rubber seal that connects the rear side window to the front window had split and come loose, so I asked them to replace it (Nothing to do with any of the issues I've described above, so I fully expected to pay).
Just had a call back to say that the seal cannot be purchased seperately so they'll have to charge me for a new back window plus the labour for fitting it. After a goodwill discount I'm looking at £300.
I've told them not to do the work and I'll ome back to them after I've done a bit of research.
This morning I noticed that the rubber seal that connects the rear side window to the front window had split and come loose, so I asked them to replace it (Nothing to do with any of the issues I've described above, so I fully expected to pay).
Just had a call back to say that the seal cannot be purchased seperately so they'll have to charge me for a new back window plus the labour for fitting it. After a goodwill discount I'm looking at £300.
I've told them not to do the work and I'll ome back to them after I've done a bit of research.
Thats a horrendous story.I noticed you diplomaticaly did not name the{helpful} dealer? I have a great independant who i can whole heartedly recommend depending on where you are location wise,.I have an extended warranty with a certain company and my indi was great working in conjunction with them with my claim for a hood motor and all parts required to repair the malfunction on my zed4.PM me if you want further details.
You can check out the part situation for yourself on www.realoem.com
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


