New E89 Z4 N20 Engine Whine
New E89 Z4 N20 Engine Whine
Author
Discussion

chester65

Original Poster:

8 posts

173 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
Picked up a new 2.0 SDrive a few weeks back and loving it, however I'm finding when starting from cold the engine tends too whine a fair bit and subsides once warmed up. The whine increases and decreases with revs when stationary either in gear or in neutral but you can't hear it once on the move. Doing some googling it can be a common trait on some BMWs but to me it doesn't sound right. Anyone with experience of these engines. Think it will be a visit to the dealer. Some pics from collection day.













Cheers.

Situation

25 posts

173 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
Could this be due to the turbo spool in this new engine.

Lovely colour by the way.

chester65

Original Poster:

8 posts

173 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
Situation said:
Could this be due to the turbo spool in this new engine.

Lovely colour by the way.
Cheers for the reply, it does it when idling so not sure if it's turbo spool. I've been told it could be this but just seems quite noisy when cold if it is.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
chester65 said:
Cheers for the reply, it does it when idling so not sure if it's turbo spool. I've been told it could be this but just seems quite noisy when cold if it is.
The 2.0 Z4 has a turbo? Didn't know that.

The 35si I drove in Munich at BMW HQ had a whine on start up too. Went away after about 5 minutes, to be replaced by the clonking/ping/clang/wallop of the double clutch auto gearbox hehe

chester65

Original Poster:

8 posts

173 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
The 2.0 Z4 has a turbo? Didn't know that.

The 35si I drove in Munich at BMW HQ had a whine on start up too. Went away after about 5 minutes, to be replaced by the clonking/ping/clang/wallop of the double clutch auto gearbox hehe
Yes BMWs new 2.0l engines use a twin scroll turbo, I have heard 35i engines can whine a little but not heard of the 2.0l doing this.

V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
chester65 said:
Cheers for the reply, it does it when idling so not sure if it's turbo spool. I've been told it could be this but just seems quite noisy when cold if it is.
The 2.0 Z4 has a turbo? Didn't know that.

The 35si I drove in Munich at BMW HQ had a whine on start up too. Went away after about 5 minutes, to be replaced by the clonking/ping/clang/wallop of the double clutch auto gearbox hehe
If you mean 35iS mine does neither. Super silky smooth and goes like stink.

OP doesn't sound right at all. Have you tried it with the aircon off?

Fuel pump can whine if faulty to.

Edited by V8A*ndy on Saturday 9th June 23:01

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
V8A*ndy said:
If you mean 35iS mine does neither. Super silky smooth and goes like stink.

OP doesn't sound right at all. Have you tried it with the aircon off?
Went link stink too, but, various noises and gearbox rumbling at max power, then around the mountains I could hear pinking/clanging and very odd noises with the roof down at low speed. 45k km's of hard abuse no doubt. Think it had BMW performance exhaust pack too cloud9