Can you trust iDrive service monitors?
Can you trust iDrive service monitors?
Author
Discussion

S Works

Original Poster:

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
I've had my E92 335 for 18months now and I love it. It's getting to the point where a few bits n bobs need attention, and after a recent brake fluid change my local indie is advising that:

- vac pipes are perished, recommend replacement
- fr & r pads are low

On the former I'll take a look at MOT time and probably get these replaced as a preventative measure. At 56k it seems about the time that many need this done (per other posts).

On the pads, a cursory check through the wheels looks like they've still got meat in them. iDrive says 47k mls left in the rears, 11k on the fronts. My question is, can you *trust* iDrive on this. I guess the pad sensors are calibrated relatively smartly, and my eye tells me they should still have life left in them.

The car gets mainly town use with 1 or 2 longer trips (100mls +) each month.

I'm not one to scrimp on my vehicles, but I also don't believe in pointless replacement. Unfortunately I don't have a trolley jack to check them myself.

spindizzy

19 posts

183 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
I have a 2007 335i manual with 105k on it now and the iDrive says I've still got 50k on the front pads and 30k on the rears ! That seems like an unholy amount of miles for a set of pads but when I changed over from winter to summer wheels/tyres in March I took a good look and there certainly seemed to be plenty of pad material visible. The other thing to remember is that the discs get worn quicker these days due to the non-asbestos pad materials used so you might be up for discs AND pads. I didn't check my disc thickness in March but I have a micrometer and will do so in November. Can't complain about the brakes but the failed turbos, injectors and HPFP were obviously designed by someone in another department !

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
I would say it's the Indy you can't trust trying to pull a fast one on pads.If they have meat in them then carry on,it's easy to visually check them.
Due to this I would also be wanting to have the perished pipes pointed out to me too.

S Works

Original Poster:

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
That's my fear, Panda. It's a 335d btw. Vac pipes are a known issue, but I'm going to take a look and form a view myself this weekend vs what I can see from pics on the net, then ask them to point these things out when it goes for mot (due imminently). To be fair to them they've only noted pads are low, not actually suggested replacement... yet.

bulldog5046

1,495 posts

209 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
I think its a standard message they tell every BMW owner their pads are low. both myself and my manager were told it every time our cars went in for a service!

S Works

Original Poster:

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Well I went and checked the pads tonight. Approx 5-8mm left by my reckoning, both axles appear fine. Certainly not anywhere near as low as I've run previous cars. They'll be staying on for a while longer then. As for the vac hose, I can see there's some fluid leaking under the engine cover but I didn't have time to take it off, so I'll ask them to remove it and show me what needs replacing, then give me a quote at the time.