The new 1 series - BMW have lost the plot
The new 1 series - BMW have lost the plot
Author
Discussion

dasherdiablo1

Original Poster:

4,503 posts

252 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
My car is in for a new turbo and my local BMW dealership have given me a 116i in 5door guise.

What can I say?? Rubbish. Utter rubbish. I had a 120d in the old shape which I have always preferred and don't understand the design concept of the new one; it is just messy from the oversized clumsy front grille to the out of proportion rear lights. The door handles look wrong and there is no flow along the sides, everything including the aerial looks untidy and bolted on.

But...and this is a big but; the interior is much much worse. The centre console is terrible - I will take a photo and post because words fail me. The stereo and climate controls look so cheap and tacky, the cloth seats and door cards are very poor quality; to be honest if I didn't know i am sitting in a BMW I would say it was a something very cheap from the far east.

I love BMW- I have had 7 in the last 10 years but this is a real let down - especially when the first courtesy car we were given was a 320d in auto with leather which felt so solid and drove really well considering the small engine.

If this is the new type of BMW standard we have to look forward to then i think the daily driver may well become an Audi!

rumple

15,418 posts

182 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
Yes they look unbelievably st, but I think BMW lost the plot about ten years ago.

will-w

256 posts

232 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
You need to drive one with M-Sport suspension and with at least "Sport" trim to appreciate it wink

The M-Sport bumpers really finish it off quite well smile


(Sorry for image quality)

aryastark

170 posts

180 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
Hated the looks at first, but the new 1 series is really starting to grow on me. 1 series with m sport spec and 3 doors will imo look very nice. It's also definitely a car that looks better in the flesh.

cerb4.5lee

45,292 posts

211 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I think the M sport kit certainly improves the look of it, but i would imagine its better behind the wheel rather than looking at it from the outside.

Pugland53

574 posts

201 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
aryastark said:
Hated the looks at first, but the new 1 series is really starting to grow on me. 1 series with m sport spec and 3 doors will imo look very nice. It's also definitely a car that looks better in the flesh.
I have to agree, I didn't like them at first but I quite like them now. In fact an Estoril M Sport could well be Mrs Pugs next car :-)

Bodo

12,625 posts

297 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I do as well dislike the styling of the new 1er, the exterior, interior, the M styling kit. The old 1er is equally worse. I still had one and drove it for three years. It was great to use and drove very well. If I wanted a car for the styling, I'd go with a Jaguar E-type, but that would cost a LOT more than 0.36€/km.

The 1er is a bit like living in an ugly house in a nice neighbourhood hehe

northandy

3,540 posts

252 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
OP what car do you have currently? A 116 courtesy car i imagine is in very basic trim, and probably doesnt compare to your current car.

I have a new f20 118d m sport, its ideal for my 35k a year mileage, interior is leagues ahead of my last car (120d coupe m sport)

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
Bodo said:
I do as well dislike the styling of the new 1er, the exterior, interior, the M styling kit. The old 1er is equally worse. I still had one and drove it for three years. It was great to use and drove very well. If I wanted a car for the styling, I'd go with a Jaguar E-type, but that would cost a LOT more than 0.36€/km.

The 1er is a bit like living in an ugly house in a nice neighbourhood hehe
Same thinking my 120d 5 door auto ED ,never look back after I park it.

Yet it does a lot very well ,just the right size ,engine a peach etc etc.



V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I've had a 116d Sport loaner for the last week and the verdict is.......


It's a cracker!

I really like it. The Piano black bits are horrid inside but the rest of it isn't bad at all and it drives great. Very chuckable and the steering wheel is really nice in the hand.

Managed 61mpg with the eco pro mode over 200 miles but it was terrible driving it with zero throttle response.

Sport mode much better (for a derv).

astirling

419 posts

203 months

Sunday 10th June 2012
quotequote all
I think it looks ok with the M sport kit, hopefully it'll grow on my over time. It had better, seeing as I have an M135i on order!

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
I reckon it'll improve after a facelift. They usually do.
The most irksome features are the overlarge headlamp cluster and the kinked plastic slats in the kidney grilles. I can imagine the aftermarket tuners will be quick to rectify this. I passed by the local stealership for some door card clips the other day and saw only one 'nice' new 1 series - 'nice' because the colour and wheel spec really made the best of what is... at best a 'challenging' front end.

gangzoom

9,006 posts

246 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
will-w said:
You need to drive one with M-Sport suspension and with at least "Sport" trim to appreciate it wink

The M-Sport bumpers really finish it off quite well smile


(Sorry for image quality)
Saw one in real life recently...just as ugly as in the picture(sorry), if it wasn't for the BMW badge looks like something Hyundai or Kia would make...though the latest Korean cars actually look much better than anything BMW has come out with recently.

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
When I see the 1-series from the rear in traffic I think "actually, that's not too bad really." It's the front end that lets the side down, badly.

Edited by 900T-R on Monday 11th June 08:31

zygalski

7,759 posts

176 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
will-w said:
You need to drive one with M-Sport suspension and with at least "Sport" trim to appreciate it wink

The M-Sport bumpers really finish it off quite well smile


(Sorry for image quality)
That's a fugster alright vomit

Roop

6,018 posts

315 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
gangzoom said:
Saw one in real life recently...just as ugly as in the picture(sorry), if it wasn't for the BMW badge looks like something Hyundai or Kia would make...though the latest Korean cars actually look much better than anything BMW has come out with recently.
Agree. You have got to be a bit desperate to choose one of these. The interior is woeful feeling far cheaper than my three year old Focus. Front end looks a dead halibut. They drive well though. Can't see why toy wouldn't choose a Golf other than through lack of choice (company scheme) our badge .

rumple

15,418 posts

182 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
gangzoom said:
will-w said:
You need to drive one with M-Sport suspension and with at least "Sport" trim to appreciate it wink

The M-Sport bumpers really finish it off quite well smile


(Sorry for image quality)
Saw one in real life recently...just as ugly as in the picture(sorry), if it wasn't for the BMW badge looks like something Hyundai or Kia would make...though the latest Korean cars actually look much better than anything BMW has come out with recently.
I'm the same , each to his own but I think its dog ugly, and I've seen a few in the flesh.

Pugland53

574 posts

201 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
Roop said:
gangzoom said:
Saw one in real life recently...just as ugly as in the picture(sorry), if it wasn't for the BMW badge looks like something Hyundai or Kia would make...though the latest Korean cars actually look much better than anything BMW has come out with recently.
Agree. You have got to be a bit desperate to choose one of these. The interior is woeful feeling far cheaper than my three year old Focus. Front end looks a dead halibut. They drive well though. Can't see why toy wouldn't choose a Golf other than through lack of choice (company scheme) our badge .
It's funny how people's opinions differ. I came into a 1 series from a 2010 Focus RS and I think the build quality is miles better than the Ford.
As for the Golf, good car but really bland imo, I doubt it would drive as well as a 1 series either....

Edited by Pugland53 on Monday 11th June 12:16

V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
Pugland53 said:
Roop said:
gangzoom said:
Saw one in real life recently...just as ugly as in the picture(sorry), if it wasn't for the BMW badge looks like something Hyundai or Kia would make...though the latest Korean cars actually look much better than anything BMW has come out with recently.
Agree. You have got to be a bit desperate to choose one of these. The interior is woeful feeling far cheaper than my three year old Focus. Front end looks a dead halibut. They drive well though. Can't see why toy wouldn't choose a Golf other than through lack of choice (company scheme) our badge .
It's funny how people's opinions differ. I came into a 1 series from a 2010 Focus RS and I think the build quality is miles better than the Ford.
As for the Golf, good car but really bland imo, I doubt it would drive as well as a 1 series either....

Edited by Pugland53 on Monday 11th June 12:16
Totally agree with you.

Build quality is vastly superior to a Ford Focus and the drive is excellent. Only real fault is that you have to drive it in a very unnatural manner to get decent MPG.

I managed 61mpg town, motorway and rural A roads (eco pro mode). When I did a stint in sport mode and driving in my more normal style this dropped to 47mpg.

Eco pro works but kills throttle response and makes you drive as if the car is about to stall. Not nice but good mpg.

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
will-w said:
You need to drive one with M-Sport suspension and with at least "Sport" trim to appreciate it wink

The M-Sport bumpers really finish it off quite well smile


(Sorry for image quality)