Discussion
Morning all! I have had my E39 540ia ‘99 converted to LPG
V8 sacrileg!. Despite being a gas guzzler the V8 does not have Variable Displacement technology (cylinder bank shut down) for when it cruise. So I'm looking into installing 2 LPG voltage operated solenoid valves, one to each selected LPG inlet pipe to the 2 cylinders. The idea is that I will be able to close these 2 valves electronically when cursing so that no LPG will enter the 2 corresponding cylinders. Potentially saving 25% of fuel.
Does this sound like it’s something achievable or will the ECU not be expecting such a change and so it’ll misfire itself to a pile of nuts and bolts?
V8 sacrileg!. Despite being a gas guzzler the V8 does not have Variable Displacement technology (cylinder bank shut down) for when it cruise. So I'm looking into installing 2 LPG voltage operated solenoid valves, one to each selected LPG inlet pipe to the 2 cylinders. The idea is that I will be able to close these 2 valves electronically when cursing so that no LPG will enter the 2 corresponding cylinders. Potentially saving 25% of fuel. Does this sound like it’s something achievable or will the ECU not be expecting such a change and so it’ll misfire itself to a pile of nuts and bolts?
It'll run exactly like an engine misfiring on the starved cylinders i.e. nastily.
And you'll save no significant fuel - the dead cylinders are still doing all the compression work and have the same pumping losses as before, the energy for which has to come from the ones which are still running. (Real cylinder activation tends to unhook the valve gear to limit this, so the dead cylinders are alternately compressing and expanding teh same air 'spring')
Sorry! If it were that easy, it would be common.
And you'll save no significant fuel - the dead cylinders are still doing all the compression work and have the same pumping losses as before, the energy for which has to come from the ones which are still running. (Real cylinder activation tends to unhook the valve gear to limit this, so the dead cylinders are alternately compressing and expanding teh same air 'spring')
Sorry! If it were that easy, it would be common.
Huff said:
It'll run exactly like an engine misfiring on the starved cylinders i.e. nastily.
And you'll save no significant fuel - the dead cylinders are still doing all the compression work and have the same pumping losses as before, the energy for which has to come from the ones which are still running. (Real cylinder activation tends to unhook the valve gear to limit this, so the dead cylinders are alternately compressing and expanding teh same air 'spring')
Sorry! If it were that easy, it would be common.
Unless you have a way of opening the exhaust valves on the compression stroke as well....And you'll save no significant fuel - the dead cylinders are still doing all the compression work and have the same pumping losses as before, the energy for which has to come from the ones which are still running. (Real cylinder activation tends to unhook the valve gear to limit this, so the dead cylinders are alternately compressing and expanding teh same air 'spring')
Sorry! If it were that easy, it would be common.
Huff said:
It'll run exactly like an engine misfiring on the starved cylinders i.e. nastily.
And you'll save no significant fuel - the dead cylinders are still doing all the compression work and have the same pumping losses as before, the energy for which has to come from the ones which are still running. (Real cylinder activation tends to unhook the valve gear to limit this, so the dead cylinders are alternately compressing and expanding teh same air 'spring')
Sorry! If it were that easy, it would be common.
Thanks Huff, I though the same as the engine is still moving never the less. And you'll save no significant fuel - the dead cylinders are still doing all the compression work and have the same pumping losses as before, the energy for which has to come from the ones which are still running. (Real cylinder activation tends to unhook the valve gear to limit this, so the dead cylinders are alternately compressing and expanding teh same air 'spring')
Sorry! If it were that easy, it would be common.
Thanks guys, I understand what your saying about the misfire. I have tried a couple things:
1- disconnect the cable to one and then two coil packs randomly. missfire is there, but at the touch, my v8 is still smoother than any 4-cylinder iv had. and as i increase revs, the misfire and judder is smoothened out.
2- disconnected different coil packs to see if the missfire jugger worsens or improves....it does both. so by carefully selecting which 2 cylinder LPG pipes to close, the judder can be minimised.
before i take a blade to my gas lines..is there any other advice i could benefit from???
thanks in advance.
1- disconnect the cable to one and then two coil packs randomly. missfire is there, but at the touch, my v8 is still smoother than any 4-cylinder iv had. and as i increase revs, the misfire and judder is smoothened out.
2- disconnected different coil packs to see if the missfire jugger worsens or improves....it does both. so by carefully selecting which 2 cylinder LPG pipes to close, the judder can be minimised.
before i take a blade to my gas lines..is there any other advice i could benefit from???
thanks in advance.
when you're driving the fresh air from the dead cylinders will dilute the exhaust gas causing the o2 sensors to signal a too lean condition and the remaining cylinders will run far too rich, and you'll get loads of fuel trim and misfire codes and it'll eventually go into limp mode. that plus the pumping losses from the misfiring cylinders and you'll use more fuel, not less. I'd imagine running with some cylinders not firing will cause ring seating issues through time. For more mpg on lpg do a decat, get more ignition advance mapped in and if you're really up for it skim the heads for more compression.
ChinE39540 said:
Thanks guys, I understand what your saying about the misfire. I have tried a couple things:
1- disconnect the cable to one and then two coil packs randomly. missfire is there, but at the touch, my v8 is still smoother than any 4-cylinder iv had. and as i increase revs, the misfire and judder is smoothened out.
2- disconnected different coil packs to see if the missfire jugger worsens or improves....it does both. so by carefully selecting which 2 cylinder LPG pipes to close, the judder can be minimised.
before i take a blade to my gas lines..is there any other advice i could benefit from???
thanks in advance.
dont do this. just leave it alone.1- disconnect the cable to one and then two coil packs randomly. missfire is there, but at the touch, my v8 is still smoother than any 4-cylinder iv had. and as i increase revs, the misfire and judder is smoothened out.
2- disconnected different coil packs to see if the missfire jugger worsens or improves....it does both. so by carefully selecting which 2 cylinder LPG pipes to close, the judder can be minimised.
before i take a blade to my gas lines..is there any other advice i could benefit from???
thanks in advance.

Next question....
My computer is now way out in calculating mpg. It shows 13L/100km instead of a truer reading of around 19L/100km.
I have unlocked the computer tests, and one test allows you to recalibrate the range, and mpg.
Any advice on how to do this? It gives you a range of 1-999. I think its set at 999 at the moment for petrol.
My computer is now way out in calculating mpg. It shows 13L/100km instead of a truer reading of around 19L/100km.
I have unlocked the computer tests, and one test allows you to recalibrate the range, and mpg.
Any advice on how to do this? It gives you a range of 1-999. I think its set at 999 at the moment for petrol.
ChinE39540 said:
before i take a blade to my gas lines..is there any other advice i could benefit from???
Yes, do a bit of Googling on cylinder deactivation. Yanks call it displacement on demand and it invaribly involves hardware.Ironically the yanks tend to remove it on anything they are trying to tune.
So you want a six cylinder petrol Five that's more economical than the V8? If only they ever built such a thing... 
Sell it, buy a diesel. Or an LPG'd six pot at least. You've already LPGd it, further gains will be pretty marginal, even without factoring in the cost in time and effort to achieve them.

Sell it, buy a diesel. Or an LPG'd six pot at least. You've already LPGd it, further gains will be pretty marginal, even without factoring in the cost in time and effort to achieve them.
Thanks a lot for the advice guys!!
To all you lpg drivers... What kind of mpg are you getting after the conversion? Compaired to pre-con.
Mine has dropped from 18mpg on petrol to 12mpg on gas. My 70litre gass tank only ever takes 44litres max from empty before the lpg pump starts juddering
To all you lpg drivers... What kind of mpg are you getting after the conversion? Compaired to pre-con.
Mine has dropped from 18mpg on petrol to 12mpg on gas. My 70litre gass tank only ever takes 44litres max from empty before the lpg pump starts juddering
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




