E46 buying advice
E46 buying advice
Author
Discussion

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Tuesday 19th June 2012
quotequote all
I'm currently looking into an E46 and was wondering if those with more knowledge than me can give me some advice on which model to go for. the main problem is that I'm not sure which engine to go for. It's between the 320 (which I believe is a 2.2),325,330 and 330d. I know the mpg is similar in all the petrols but insurance will be less for the smaller engines I expect, is there any other difference between these engines/cars that I shoud be aware of? Tempted by the 330d which should give better fuel economy but not sure what the performance is like or what peoples opinion is regarding it's reliability?
I would be looking to spend £4k - £5k and ideally want 02 or later on sub 100k miles. Any advice appreciated. Thanks

Mr-B

5,141 posts

225 months

Tuesday 19th June 2012
quotequote all
I have a 330d and the performance is pretty good, just over 7 seconds to sixty and in gear acceleration is rapid. I did get a remap on mine to take power up to around 230bhp (mild by some standards) the power delivery now is very pleasing wink and fuel economy hasn't suffered. I do a lot of short journeys and always get 37mpg, it's better on a motorway run obviously.

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Tuesday 19th June 2012
quotequote all
Mr-B said:
I have a 330d and the performance is pretty good, just over 7 seconds to sixty and in gear acceleration is rapid. I did get a remap on mine to take power up to around 230bhp (mild by some standards) the power delivery now is very pleasing wink and fuel economy hasn't suffered. I do a lot of short journeys and always get 37mpg, it's better on a motorway run obviously.
Thanks Mr B that's very helpful. Have you found yours to be reliable?

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Tuesday 19th June 2012
quotequote all
bluetone said:
thanks Bluetone. some great links there. More for when I've purchased the car though. I couldn't see much on which to actually buy. It's mainly the reliability of the diesel vs the petrol I'm not sure about. Do you have any experience or knowledge on this? Thanks

Mr-B

5,141 posts

225 months

Tuesday 19th June 2012
quotequote all
hephillips said:
Thanks Mr B that's very helpful. Have you found yours to be reliable?
Yes-ish. Nothing major (he touches wood) although I am not now doing many miles as I am working from home. It has got through recent MOT's without much needing doing (broken rear spring was the last item (only about £70 to fix) Rear parking sensors not working (common problem) rear LED light cluster not fully working, small oil leak (gasket I think). Just niggles really but overall very happy and economy/power compromise is very nice.

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
We used to have a 320i auto and it was the thirstiest out of all the 3's I've lived with (330d auto, manual e36 328i & 318ti). Lucky to get 27mpg. In its favour, was very quiet, smooth and refined, more so than e46 328 I was using for a couple of weeks.

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
vsonix said:
We used to have a 320i auto and it was the thirstiest out of all the 3's I've lived with (330d auto, manual e36 328i & 318ti). Lucky to get 27mpg. In its favour, was very quiet, smooth and refined, more so than e46 328 I was using for a couple of weeks.
Thanks that's interesting. From what I've found out so far it seems the 330i or 330d are the ones to go for. The 330d will be more economical but they seem to be rarer and more expensive, hence wiping out the benefits of the additional aconomy. Looks like I'm leaning towards the 330i...

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Bump. Does anyone else have any advice on this? What sort of mpg would I be looking at for a manual 330i? Thanks

rpm1969

91 posts

192 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
I've got a 2002 330Ci coupe with 136k on the clock. I currently average 32mpg, but I do 110 miles each day on motorways. Driving very gently and using cruise control as much as possible I've managed 35mpg from a tank on that commute. When I had my previous job which was just 18 miles per day on local roads with some longer runs thrown in at weekends, I was averaging something like 27mpg.

When I did my research it that this engine has a good reputation for reliability. Known issues are high oil consumption and the need to replace thermostat, water pump and radiator at some point (I've done two of those). I don't know enough about the diesels to comment.

dooosuk

464 posts

256 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
I get similar (indicated) mpg as the above poster with my 330ci sport.

Around 400-430miles per tank on a motorway run.

Around 330miles per tanks on my commute.

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
hephillips said:
I would be looking to spend £4k - £5k and ideally want 02 or later on sub 100k miles. Any advice appreciated. Thanks
How many miles do you plan to do per year?

Unless 20k plus, at that age I would buy petrol, the best you can affort, ideally 330i. The engine is great (M54) reliable and none of the expensive problems older diesels. IMHO the older these cars get the more they become an 'enthusiast' purchase, so when you sell the top spec (engine and trim) will hold value better, relatively.

Don't fixate on under 100k miles, look instead for well maintained. If you go for a petrol make sure key things have been done - cooling system overhaul, rocker cover gasket.

CypherP

4,459 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
I've owned 2 E46 325cis and a 330ci, all of which have been sound cars, with great engines and each one doing a daily 60 mile commute on the M4.

I'm getting around 33-34mpg from my current 325ci (auto) and regard that to be bloody good. Differences between both 325 and 330 aren't incredibly noticeable and will both do around the same economy on reasonable trips. Question for you though, with regard to your original post - how old are you, if insurance may play a part in your decision? I'm 27 and haven't paid anything over £400FC for the last 3 or 4 years. They're really not all that expensive to insure in my experience, so I'd do some comparisons first.

You don't want to rule out a 330 over a 320 and then find that it was only a hundred quid more, for instance.

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
CypherP said:
I've owned 2 E46 325cis and a 330ci, all of which have been sound cars, with great engines and each one doing a daily 60 mile commute on the M4.

I'm getting around 33-34mpg from my current 325ci (auto) and regard that to be bloody good. Differences between both 325 and 330 aren't incredibly noticeable and will both do around the same economy on reasonable trips. Question for you though, with regard to your original post - how old are you, if insurance may play a part in your decision? I'm 27 and haven't paid anything over £400FC for the last 3 or 4 years. They're really not all that expensive to insure in my experience, so I'd do some comparisons first.

You don't want to rule out a 330 over a 320 and then find that it was only a hundred quid more, for instance.
Thanks Cypher. I'm 29 and have done some comparisons since my original post and was surprised at how little the difference was between the different cars, expeciailly as I'm specifically looking for one with the sport spec.

So did you find similar mpg between the 325 and 330? Where they both auto's? I was hoping to get a maual as thought this may get me a few extra mpg. I know you don't buy these cars for economy but every little helps and I'll be doing circa 20k miles a year I expect.

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
eastsider said:
How many miles do you plan to do per year?

Unless 20k plus, at that age I would buy petrol, the best you can affort, ideally 330i. The engine is great (M54) reliable and none of the expensive problems older diesels. IMHO the older these cars get the more they become an 'enthusiast' purchase, so when you sell the top spec (engine and trim) will hold value better, relatively.

Don't fixate on under 100k miles, look instead for well maintained. If you go for a petrol make sure key things have been done - cooling system overhaul, rocker cover gasket.
Thanks Eastsider really helpful post. I'll keep you're comments in mind. Definately leaning towards the 330 ci sport. I've heard a few ppl mention the cooling system so will keep my eyes open for recent work done on that as sounds like it will need doing at some point. Is it a big job?

blippo1984

358 posts

177 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
Approx 35 mpg as a motorway muncher, including the little bits when you drop off the motorway into destination.

Might sell mine though as I find it hard to squeeze all 6'2" in.

CypherP

4,459 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
hephillips said:
CypherP said:
I've owned 2 E46 325cis and a 330ci, all of which have been sound cars, with great engines and each one doing a daily 60 mile commute on the M4.

I'm getting around 33-34mpg from my current 325ci (auto) and regard that to be bloody good. Differences between both 325 and 330 aren't incredibly noticeable and will both do around the same economy on reasonable trips. Question for you though, with regard to your original post - how old are you, if insurance may play a part in your decision? I'm 27 and haven't paid anything over £400FC for the last 3 or 4 years. They're really not all that expensive to insure in my experience, so I'd do some comparisons first.

You don't want to rule out a 330 over a 320 and then find that it was only a hundred quid more, for instance.
Thanks Cypher. I'm 29 and have done some comparisons since my original post and was surprised at how little the difference was between the different cars, expeciailly as I'm specifically looking for one with the sport spec.

So did you find similar mpg between the 325 and 330? Where they both auto's? I was hoping to get a maual as thought this may get me a few extra mpg. I know you don't buy these cars for economy but every little helps and I'll be doing circa 20k miles a year I expect.
Glad you've taken some time to compare quotes on both, as from my experience, there really isn't much in it!

To give you an idea, I bought my first 325ci M sport at 22, a manual with 74k and on regular motorway trips was seeing around 35-36mpg, with around 21-22 on town and residentual drives. That was followed by a 330ci M sport auto 2 years later, a facelift model with 69k miles, which doing the same trips gave around 3-4 mpg lower than the previous 2.5 manual. I now have a 325ci M sport auto with 94k on the clock, which is giving 31-32 mpg on motorways most of the time.

Considering some of them can be had for a steal at the moment, i'd say it is a sensible buy if you're planning on keeping it for a couple of years at least. All I will say is don't expect it to be worth as much as you pay for it in a couple of years, unless you manage to grab yourself a real gem.

Be weary of accident damage/repairs to the quarter panels/arches and give them a good check over both inside and out. My current one is the second of the three I have owned that is succumbing to rust around the arch lining and paint bubbling on the outside, which seems to be from a pretty poor quality prime and paint job before I bought it.

If you haven't had one before, be aware of the slightly crashy ride in the M Sport specs and both front and rear bushes/CV boots perishing. Only other minor bugbear that I will mention is the sodding strip of alcantara roof lining over each door that after time (and intense sunlight) will just give up the ghost and start to dangle down like some limp piece of celery. Bloody annoying and have tried time and time again with a number of industrial strength adhesives and have only worked for a limited time before having to reapply!

On the whole, absolute joys to own, which is why I'm on my third now. Decide realistically which model you want and what will suit you. I've settled for the 325, as the engine is just a smooth as the 330ci, enough power for me with the trips I'm doing and the auto box coupled with the motorway trips has actually further improved my throttle balance and gaining those extra couple of mpgs where possible.

Apologies for the long response, but having owned a few now, its always nice to point out the obvious as an owner to people interested. If this is a first E46, my money would be on a 330ci M sport. For very little extra, you get some more power, a lovely raspy exhaust note, all the toys (excluding sat nav, depending on how much you spend) and an absolutely cracking planted car. You may even get lucky and find a Clubsport for a bit extra.

hephillips

Original Poster:

121 posts

174 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
Thanks Cypher that's all really helpful. I think I will try and go for a 330i manual but if the right 325 comes up I won't discount it. Whats the difference between the clubsport and sport by the way?

CypherP

4,459 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
Very little in all fairness. Sound deadening and carpets etc are all a little thinner, shaving a small amount of weight off. Most of them have the 18" Clubsport alloys (although there are some with standard MV/MV2s from the pre/postfacelift 325/330s) and has a different (larger) boot spoiler and black splitters on the front bumper.

Interiors will be more or less identical, depending on spec. There really isn't a great deal in it. They do look good and considered one to replace my first 325ci, but couldn't find one within my budget that I was happy with.

This is an example of the exterior differences:

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
hephillips said:
Thanks Cypher that's all really helpful. I think I will try and go for a 330i manual but if the right 325 comes up I won't discount it. Whats the difference between the clubsport and sport by the way?
Make sure you drive both. Prior to test driving I had no preference either way - so I drove a 525i and a 530i and there was a significant performance difference between the two. I bought the 530i.