Car now NOT covered on BMW Warranty
Car now NOT covered on BMW Warranty
Author
Discussion

evolution666

Original Poster:

310 posts

266 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
OK, keeping it simple... has anyone had a similar dealing here?

A family member has purchased a car from a landrover dealer down south. The car is under 3 yr old, and was still covered on warranty. Bought subject to condition being good and it all appeared to be.

Car has a noise coming from the rood above 50mph so back to the local dealer it went. They get a phone call the next day to explain that, yes we agree theres a problem, but sorry, the car has appeared to have a repair as there is overspray in certain areas and as there is no record of a BMW repair agent carrying out the work, therefore not covered on your warranty. Oh, and by the way that will be £450 please for work carried out so far.

As it stands, the car is with the inspecting dealer as he, at the moment has refused to pay the inspection bill and therefore, they are keeping a hold of the car.

is there a chance of simply handing this car back or is this going to be an absolute mine field?

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
First question is - what did the advert say? If the LR dealer said the car was under warranty, end of, it's an easy win.

Second question however is even if there's no explicit representation, you might have a good argument that the car is not of satisfactory quality under the Sale of Goods Act. Did your mate buy as a private purchaser for full retail money (or close to?)

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
I believe BMW waranty is negated if sold by a trader not of the BMW network? Read the small print. And if the noise is a result of the accident, or repair carried out, i think they have fair argument.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
I believe BMW waranty is negated if sold by a trader not of the BMW network? Read the small print. And if the noise is a result of the accident, or repair carried out, i think they have fair argument.
Used car warranty ends if the car is resold but this car is under three years old, so it'd be under the new car warranty. I do think that BMW has a point - but that doesn't mean that the seller gets to wash his hands of it automatically.

evolution666

Original Poster:

310 posts

266 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
i believe this car was sourced through BMW's central stock and just happened to be sat at the LR dealer as it was traded in for a new vehicle. Im sumizing here but i take it this LR dealer has a BMW franchise, will confirm this tomorrow with them though.

Car has full BMW history (clearly a bit more too), under 3 yrs old and had a deposit placed on the vehicle pending a viewing to confirm its condition once it was brought up north. Then the balance was paid. Car drove away, fault found, thaken to norther bmw dealer and the rest i have in OP.


there is no hint at the moment that the car has been somewhere other than bmw for servicing. what looks to have happened, that the car for what ever reason has been repaired somewhere other than BMW as the roof has mech has been accesed and they say, it wasnt BMW, as it would have shown in there records???

question is, can a francised dealer, sell an accident damaged car, knowingly or unknowingly, sell it with a manufactures warranty to a customer, only to find out that the car has been reparied else where then void the warranty in a space of time that proves beyond reasonable doubt that the car was sold to him, damaged. And then expect no come back or have any responsibility to right the situation.

i will say the intention is to get as far away from this car as possible now as neither of them now want to own the vehicle any longer and if poss, wash there hands of this altogether

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
evolution666 said:
i believe this car was sourced through BMW's central stock and just happened to be sat at the LR dealer as it was traded in for a new vehicle. Im sumizing here but i take it this LR dealer has a BMW franchise, will confirm this tomorrow with them though.
What do you mean by "BMW central stock"?

Many franchised dealers won't sell off-franchise used cars at all, so pulling one in from somewhere else to sell from the LR forecourt seems most unlikely.

It'll surely have simply been traded in against a LR of some sort.

Edited by Deva Link on Thursday 21st June 10:00

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
What do you mean by "BMW central stock"?

Many franchised dealers won't sell off-franchise used cars at all, so pulling one in from somewhere else to sell from the LR forecourt seems most unlikely.

It'll surely have simply been traded in against a LR of some sort.

Edited by Deva Link on Thursday 21st June 10:00
Exactly this. It hasn't come from 'BMW Central stock' and for the purposes of this thread hasn't been sold by a 'franchised dealer' in the same way it would have been had you bought it as a BMW Approved Used Car.

It is not against the law to fix your car if you damage it. You don't need to declare it to anyone and nobody has ripped anyone off by selling a second hand car which has previously had some damage repaired. Its a car - they get damaged, people repair them. It's only more complex when the car has previously been written off which I would imagine isnt the case here.

You cannot blame BMW for not wishing to warrant a faulty part which has been worked on by somebody completely seperate. Any comeback you may have should be against the dealer who sold you the car as under the Sale of Goods Act they are the only people 'in the frame' for the issues you are having.

They've not done anything wrong by selling a car that somebody has repaired - I doubt they even knew - but depending on the fault and when you bought the car they may be responsible for fixing it.

Robsti

12,241 posts

237 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Speak to the selling dealer!

evolution666

Original Poster:

310 posts

266 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
evolution666 said:
i believe this car was sourced through BMW's central stock and just happened to be sat at the LR dealer as it was traded in for a new vehicle.
Central stock, by this i mean it was found on the BMW AUC site (so i believe).

The car as stated above was traded in against a new Evoque. So was at the LR dealer, and not bought in at all. This is the info i have so far, unfortunately all i have so far is that the BMW dealer up here has now agreed to give the car back with out the fee being paid. it also has a report of the repair needed to put it right, and is now with the LR dealer who sold the car awaiting there reply

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
evolution666 said:
Central stock, by this i mean it was found on the BMW AUC site (so i believe).
What? Why would an LR dealer buy cars from the AUC site? This makes absolutely no sense at all.

evolution666 said:
The car as stated above was traded in against a new Evoque.
So nothing to do with BMW AUC!

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
I think what the OP is saying (and this still doesn't make much sense) is that ...

i. they found the car on the BMW AUC site, but
ii. when they inquired about it, they found that it was still with the LR dealer in the same group as the BMW dealer that had it, so
iii. they bought it from the LR dealer, under unclear contractual terms.

Maybe they even bought from the BMW franchise but the BMW dealer never took it into their own stock as such.

evolution666

Original Poster:

310 posts

266 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
I think what the OP is saying (and this still doesn't make much sense) is that ...

i. they found the car on the BMW AUC site, but
ii. when they inquired about it, they found that it was still with the LR dealer in the same group as the BMW dealer that had it, so
iii. they bought it from the LR dealer, under unclear contractual terms.

Maybe they even bought from the BMW franchise but the BMW dealer never took it into their own stock as such.
thats how i understand it to be, the said LR dealer also appears to have a bmw dearlersip as well, i have deliberately left out the dealer name for obvious reasons, a well known dealer none the less.

i am fully aware that a car can be damaged and repaired with out the BMW network knowing about it, but if they sell a car on knowingly or not that has been damaged, are they liable for the repairs of this, what further warranty implications will it have (ie can they now use this to get out of any further warranty claims), or does it simply come back down to buyer beware?

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
evolution666 said:
thats how i understand it to be, the said LR dealer also appears to have a bmw dearlersip as well, i have deliberately left out the dealer name for obvious reasons, a well known dealer none the less.

i am fully aware that a car can be damaged and repaired with out the BMW network knowing about it, but if they sell a car on knowingly or not that has been damaged, are they liable for the repairs of this, what further warranty implications will it have (ie can they now use this to get out of any further warranty claims), or does it simply come back down to buyer beware?
1. Are they liable for the repairs?

It depends... Sale of Goods Act implies three main terms, that cannot be overruled by any contract, as long as the contract is between a business seller and a private purchaser:

i. that the goods are as described (i.e., it's a 520d Sport Touring and not an SE or whatever);
ii. that they are fit for purpose (i.e., it's a car and you can drive it around); and
iii. that they are of satisfactory quality (i.e., it isn't broken, badly repaired, and lasts reasonably long, given the age, price paid, kind of seller, etc.)

So if the car was described as being under manufacturer or another warranty, then the seller's warranty has to hold, or they have to compensate for the lack of stated manufacturer warranty - but that doesn't mean that you can hold the manufacturer to the warranty just because the seller said it had one.

If the car has been badly repaired and this has an effect on wind noise then, given that it was a recent car from a franchise dealer, it is very unlikely to be deemed by a Court that it is of satisfactory quality unless the car substantially below the retail price for other similar cars (price is taken into account when determining what satisfactory quality means). Even then the Court will look at the whole picture and won't necessarily say that a £10k car bought for £9k and needing £1k of repairs is of satisfactory quality.

Unfortunately, this isn't a simple question of the dealer 'must not' do something and they'll go along with it - it's a contract dispute and ultimately paying up must be at least an expected cost of business, at worst the easier option.

AOK

2,301 posts

197 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
For arguments sake lets say you bought the car off Sytner (they have both Land Rover and BMW dealerships). If you bought it off the Land Rover dealer, get the repairs done at a Sytner BMW rather than at a non-Sytner place you are at now. The only thing is you need to cover the £450 the current service centre are after for the works / diagnosis completed thus far. But as everyone says, speak to the selling dealer.. they might even cover this charge if everything is legit

evolution666

Original Poster:

310 posts

266 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
thanks CYMR0

thats kind of what i was looking for. They bought this car, and probably could have got one cheaper privately, but tried to avoid such woes as this by buying the car from who they did. such as life.

As said, this report has now been sent to the LR dealer i believe and so the waiting game begins. this was an exercise to try and get some info for them coming back. knowing car dealers, there not going to come out first time and offer what everyone wants are they. after all, someones going to get lumbered with the repair of a car here. Forwarned is fore armed


thanks for the info