3 Series coupe d
3 Series coupe d
Author
Discussion

imuir

Original Poster:

391 posts

315 months

Friday 22nd June 2012
quotequote all
Looking to buy either a Mercedes CLK 320 CDI sport or a BMW Coupe, want diesel auto, impressed with 320d economy but worried the 4 pot may be a bit rough, 325d looks like a good compromise on performance and economy, 335d performance looks great, does the mpg of these 3 liter engines differ that much ? , thanks.

phumy

5,829 posts

268 months

Friday 22nd June 2012
quotequote all
imuir said:
Looking to buy either a Mercedes CLK 320 CDI sport or a BMW Coupe, want diesel auto, impressed with 320d economy but worried the 4 pot may be a bit rough, 325d looks like a good compromise on performance and economy, 335d performance looks great, does the mpg of these 3 liter engines differ that much ? , thanks.
I get 38mpg on the motorway and about 34mpg around town from my 335d, best i have had sticking to 75mph is 48mpg, from Bristol to Heathrow, but its difficult to stay at that speed wink

vinnie83

3,367 posts

224 months

Friday 22nd June 2012
quotequote all
I am averaging 42mpg over the last 8 months and ~15k miles in my 320d coupe (manual). This is about 75% motorway driving.

I wasn't keen on the 325d as it is not very much more powerful than the 320d and the fuel economy noticeably worse.

The 320d engine is smooth, drive one and decide for yourself. I have owned a 535d (the pre-LCI) so I can comment on the smoothness of the 4 pot vs 6 cylinder. Needless to say, the 6 is far smoother and sounds much better, but I would be surprised if you find that the 4 pot is a problem in that area.

ETA:

The ex has a CLK 220cdi sport, 2006 and I have a 57 plate 320d.

In case you're interested in a comparison - the steering on the BMW is far lighter and nicer to use. The BMW has a far keener and sportier engine. The interior quality on the BMW is far superior to the MB.

However, the MB is far more comfortable, and given the choice, I would rather take the MB for a very long journey than the BMW. But the MB is not a very sporting drive, whereas the BMW continues to impress me in how well it handles for the type of car it is.

The fuel economy on the MB's is, on paper, much worse than the BMW's. Her 220cdi (auto) is averaging 32mpg, although it is 75% town driving vs. my 42mpg (manual car, 75% motorway).

The interior of the BMW just looks so much more modern, and the plastics just seem far better in quality.

The standard stereo in the BMW is far better than the MB (in the coupe you get professional stereo as std) and also the BMW has bi-xenons as standard on the coupe, whereas the MB doesn't.

Hope that is of some use!

Edited by vinnie83 on Friday 22 June 12:52

imuir

Original Poster:

391 posts

315 months

Friday 22nd June 2012
quotequote all
Thanks I need to drive the 320d, get the feeling the mb will be a fair bit less involving to drive, looked at chipping and a big increase in bhp in the 325d can be had

Drek

609 posts

196 months

Friday 22nd June 2012
quotequote all
Recent 3.3k round trip in Yerp got me 34.6 avg mpg from 335d. Not bad considering I was hoofing it sausage side at 140+ for some time!

georgiansoccer

10 posts

208 months

Friday 22nd June 2012
quotequote all
why not get a 330d as opposed to a 325?
Same mpg plug 245bhp seems the perfect compromise between 325 and 335

rassi

2,518 posts

282 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
Please do a search for "Mercedes" and "rust" before you entertain the idea of a MB. And yes, get a 330d or 335d.

imuir

Original Poster:

391 posts

315 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
2009 CLK should be ok but now I'm keen on a 335d as performance and economy look so good, have about 16 k so should find something

Tea Pot One

1,870 posts

259 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
I had a 320d (177) auto and now have a 330d LCI (245) auto .... I got on average 40mpg out of my 320d and get 37mpg from the 330d for the same use - so not really much in it for me !

I find the 330d at 6 to 60 far quicker than the 320d (177) which was 8 to 60. That said, the 320d is very capable and smooth. Yes the 3L lump is very refined but, as has been mentioned, do not discount the 320d - for a 2L it is very refined .... and having had both I do not understand people who say the 4 pot is rubbish ... in my experience it was really smooth and quiet - just not as nice as the 3L.


imuir

Original Poster:

391 posts

315 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
If its only a few mpg difference I think I prefer the 6 pot.
Is SAT NAV and comms pack a must have ?

Edited by imuir on Sunday 24th June 05:24

vinnie83

3,367 posts

224 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
imuir said:
If its only a few mpg difference I think I prefer the 6 pot.
Is SAT NAV and comms pack a must have ?

Edited by imuir on Sunday 24th June 05:24
You'll be lucky to find a 3 series with a sat nav.

More likely in the 335d, but IIRC you have to have I-drive to have satnav and that was a very expensive option.

imuir

Original Poster:

391 posts

315 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Is I-drive a must have on a 335d ?. I have seen a few without it and I prefer the look of the dash without it.

vinnie83

3,367 posts

224 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
imuir said:
Is I-drive a must have on a 335d ?. I have seen a few without it and I prefer the look of the dash without it.
If you can get it, then do. You get some nice features in the I-drive.

Unfortunately, not many of the lower end 3 series cars were specced with them, so it's very rare. But if you're going the 335d route, then you should be able to find one with.