Help me price this lot up please - (get creative) - E46 bits
Discussion
Dear all,
Following a puncture this morning and a few niggles around failing components and understeer, even in the rain when trying to oversteer - I need a refresh.
I want your advice on which brands to use, who should fit the bits, also whether any of these bits could "wait" - ie prioritisation.
-New shock absorbers and springs front and back(am open to suggestions of different brands - have heard good things about Koni FSD and Eibach)
-New wishbones and polybushed "lollipops" - I know Powerflex may be too stiff and ruin the ride but this is a potential mistake I want to make for myself
-New ARB bushes and drop links front and back
-4 new tyres (225/45/17)(Or instead of 17" tyres, some 18" BBS CH replicas and tyres)
-Rear trailing arm bushes (powerflex again or maybe M3 ones)
-Service due in 5k miles
If you guys could advise me on my choices and suggest good places to find the kit above I'd be most obliged. Furthermore, if you can advise a good mechanic to fit all of the bits in the Bristol or Wiltshire area that'd be great.
Have a good Friday,
Fred.
Following a puncture this morning and a few niggles around failing components and understeer, even in the rain when trying to oversteer - I need a refresh.
I want your advice on which brands to use, who should fit the bits, also whether any of these bits could "wait" - ie prioritisation.
-New shock absorbers and springs front and back(am open to suggestions of different brands - have heard good things about Koni FSD and Eibach)
-New wishbones and polybushed "lollipops" - I know Powerflex may be too stiff and ruin the ride but this is a potential mistake I want to make for myself
-New ARB bushes and drop links front and back
-4 new tyres (225/45/17)(Or instead of 17" tyres, some 18" BBS CH replicas and tyres)
-Rear trailing arm bushes (powerflex again or maybe M3 ones)
-Service due in 5k miles
If you guys could advise me on my choices and suggest good places to find the kit above I'd be most obliged. Furthermore, if you can advise a good mechanic to fit all of the bits in the Bristol or Wiltshire area that'd be great.
Have a good Friday,
Fred.
On the recommendation of somebody on here, I used Phoenix Motorsport in Surrey to supply the PowerFlex bushes for my E36. I spoke to Gerry on the phone and found him incredibly helpful and full of good advice and recommendations.
http://www.phoenixmotorsport.co.uk/
I didn't find the PowerFlex bushes dramatically affected the ride quality of the car to be honest (and I'm definitely not a fan of overly hard or jiggly suspension) but they do massively improve the precision and stability of the drive.
In terms of the ride harshness, I think that changing between the stock 17" wheels and my winter 16" wheels makes more of a difference than changing to the aftermarket bushes did.
http://www.phoenixmotorsport.co.uk/
I didn't find the PowerFlex bushes dramatically affected the ride quality of the car to be honest (and I'm definitely not a fan of overly hard or jiggly suspension) but they do massively improve the precision and stability of the drive.
In terms of the ride harshness, I think that changing between the stock 17" wheels and my winter 16" wheels makes more of a difference than changing to the aftermarket bushes did.
coombsfh said:
What exactly did you have done to your car by these guys/on these guys advice?
I had them supply front lollipops and wishbone rear bushes, front and rear ARB bushes, and rear trailing arm bushes. I also rented the RTAB removal tool from them which made life much easier!I didn't strictly need the front lollipop brackets, but I was on a tight schedule and didn't want hassle if removal of the old bushes was tricky. Besides, my dad also has an E36 so we can prefit new bushes for him in my old lollipop brackets ahead of time which will make life easier down the line.
I did the front and rear ARB droplinks at the same time seeing as I was already in there - I used Lemfoerder replacements from EuroCarParts because people seemed to suggest they are the same as OEM but significantly less costly.
ETA: I did my own installation, firstly because I was interested to have a go and secondly because I can afford to have my car off the road for a few days if I screw up, but it was actually fairly straightforward - especially with the special tool for the RTABs. But I'm fairly certain Phoenix offer the fitting service too if you'd rather delegate it

Edited by bababa on Friday 22 June 12:06
bababa said:
I had them supply front lollipops and wishbone rear bushes, front and rear ARB bushes, and rear trailing arm bushes. I also rented the RTAB removal tool from them which made life much easier!
I didn't strictly need the front lollipop brackets, but I was on a tight schedule and didn't want hassle if removal of the old bushes was tricky. Besides, my dad also has an E36 so we can prefit new bushes for him in my old lollipop brackets ahead of time which will make life easier down the line.
I did the front and rear ARB droplinks at the same time seeing as I was already in there - I used Lemfoerder replacements from EuroCarParts because people seemed to suggest they are the same as OEM but significantly less costly.
ETA: I did my own installation, firstly because I was interested to have a go and secondly because I can afford to have my car off the road for a few days if I screw up, but it was actually fairly straightforward - especially with the special tool for the RTABs. But I'm fairly certain Phoenix offer the fitting service too if you'd rather delegate it
I have most of the tools but not all and I don't have the time for it to be off the road nor do I have the necessary finesse to work on a modern car...I didn't strictly need the front lollipop brackets, but I was on a tight schedule and didn't want hassle if removal of the old bushes was tricky. Besides, my dad also has an E36 so we can prefit new bushes for him in my old lollipop brackets ahead of time which will make life easier down the line.
I did the front and rear ARB droplinks at the same time seeing as I was already in there - I used Lemfoerder replacements from EuroCarParts because people seemed to suggest they are the same as OEM but significantly less costly.
ETA: I did my own installation, firstly because I was interested to have a go and secondly because I can afford to have my car off the road for a few days if I screw up, but it was actually fairly straightforward - especially with the special tool for the RTABs. But I'm fairly certain Phoenix offer the fitting service too if you'd rather delegate it

Edited by bababa on Friday 22 June 12:06
I just replaced the ARB droplinks & bushes both ends of my E39. Also had new front wishbones. I used Powerflex front thrust bushes & ARB bushes. New Continental SportContacts as well
The car is much tidier now and much more precise. It's a little firmer in some ways and you can feel each wheel "walking" over the standard UK crap road surfaces at low speeds but it's not a retrograde step. Took about six hours to fit that lot plus rear pads and new track rod end rubber boots
I'd do that lot and leave the springs & damper for a second round. You may not need to do them. I'd always do bushes before shocks
My local BMW specialist sees hundreds of E39 and E46 models. Lollipop bushes don't last long - they have one customer where they replace them on almost every service. My new BMW E39 Thrust Bushes lasted about 18 months hence going to Powerflex
Nick Froome
The car is much tidier now and much more precise. It's a little firmer in some ways and you can feel each wheel "walking" over the standard UK crap road surfaces at low speeds but it's not a retrograde step. Took about six hours to fit that lot plus rear pads and new track rod end rubber boots
I'd do that lot and leave the springs & damper for a second round. You may not need to do them. I'd always do bushes before shocks
My local BMW specialist sees hundreds of E39 and E46 models. Lollipop bushes don't last long - they have one customer where they replace them on almost every service. My new BMW E39 Thrust Bushes lasted about 18 months hence going to Powerflex
Nick Froome
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


