So, will there be an M5 touring ?
So, will there be an M5 touring ?
Author
Discussion

toppstuff

Original Poster:

13,698 posts

278 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
I find it surprising that AMG has this market all to itself. Audi no doubt will be along with a new S6 and RS6 Avant as well.

So why no new M5 Touring?

If you want a car to pin the Labradors against the rear window when accelerating, it's a shame that BMW don't offer the M5.

Will there be a new M5 touring?

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
They say no. Sales were poor last time.

sinizter

3,348 posts

217 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Hope there will be one this time.

Cheib

25,482 posts

206 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
Zod said:
They say no. Sales were poor last time.
I think the last car was a bit too hardcore to appeal to the estate market. This one with a much better gearbox and engine combo for those wanting to be lazy (i.e. shove it in auto and let the torque do the work) would appeal more I think.

I can't see them doing it especially with the saloon seemingly struggling.

toppstuff

Original Poster:

13,698 posts

278 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
Cheib said:
Zod said:
They say no. Sales were poor last time.
I think the last car was a bit too hardcore to appeal to the estate market. This one with a much better gearbox and engine combo for those wanting to be lazy (i.e. shove it in auto and let the torque do the work) would appeal more I think.

I can't see them doing it especially with the saloon seemingly struggling.
There does seem to be plenty of unsold M5's around. Every dealer seems to have one or two knocking around they are keen to move on..

And yet, Mercedes seem to do quite well selling mad AMG estates. I suspect they sell more estates than saloons.

So what is BMW doing differently?

I may or may not be a typical sample, but I would always pick the estate over the saloon. I would be surprised if there are'nt more like me.

DennisCooper

1,340 posts

202 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
Hi,

As mentioned previously, there's lots of 'internet' based demand, but almost 100% of it somehow evaporates when it comes time for those 'wanting' one being able to put the money up for one! The E34 M5 Touring was the first one, and demand was low so that there wasn't an E39 M5 Touring. BMW dipped their toe in once more with the E61 M5 Touring and again sales were low.

The reason I suspect AMG estates sell is that most of the 'actual' owners of these cars don't actually know or care about the power on hand i.e, they're not really enthusiasts - they just happen to have bigger bank balances be it provided by the company they work for or personally.

It's no real surprise to see the F10 M5 not selling so well in the UK so far, times are tough and the cost of petrol in the UK is amongst the highest in the world. There is more to it of course, but those two factors are probably the biggest elements.

It would be great if an F11 M5 is made, for now we just have to speculate and turn to Alpina and their version if a fast Touring is wanted.

Cheers, Dennis!


toppstuff

Original Poster:

13,698 posts

278 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
DennisCooper said:
Hi,


The reason I suspect AMG estates sell is that most of the 'actual' owners of these cars don't actually know or care about the power on hand i.e, they're not really enthusiasts - they just happen to have bigger bank balances be it provided by the company they work for or personally.
Nah, I don't buy that at all. The notion that AMG 63 E Class , or C class estate buyers are not enthusiasts compared to BMW buyers does not stack up at all.

And what about Audi? The RS4 and RS6 cars down the years have always sold MORE estates than saloons.

BMW have got this wrong.

And they are'nt marketing the cars well, either.

Mr E

23,105 posts

290 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
I'm sure Alpina will build something suitable for those with interest (and the bank balance to match).

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
toppstuff said:
Nah, I don't buy that at all. The notion that AMG 63 E Class , or C class estate buyers are not enthusiasts compared to BMW buyers does not stack up at all.

And what about Audi? The RS4 and RS6 cars down the years have always sold MORE estates than saloons.

BMW have got this wrong.

And they are'nt marketing the cars well, either.
I can only refer to my own experiences but I have not met an owner of an AMG (or Audi RS) who is not an enthusiast.

Cheib

25,482 posts

206 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
I just think the fact AMG cars are full auto and low down grunt cars makes a difference....estates are almost exclusively going to be bought by families so as well as the enthusiast owner the non enthusiast partner may have a say. The way an AMG drives will be preferred by those drivers. Audi obviously offers 4WD which again is a massive selling point.

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
Cheib said:
Audi obviously offers 4WD which again is a massive selling point.
i'd be willing to bet that most audi quattro cars are sold for other reasons than because they're 4WD.

toppstuff

Original Poster:

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
i'd be willing to bet that most audi quattro cars are sold for other reasons than because they're 4WD.
I'm not sure about that. Our here in the sticks Quattros are popular with the country cottage set precisely because they have 4WD. BMW continually miss a trick with this market. Apparently people in continental Europe like 4WD but we Brits ( one of their most important markets ) are not worth BMW including when they engineer 4WD for their new cars.

Audi see fit to engineer their Quattros for RHD and LHD at the design stage, but BMW can't be arsed. Its like the way the last 5 series had the windscreen wipers configured for LHD because they could not be bothered to engineer a RHD version. Cheapskate rubbish and a very cynical view of the UK customer IMO.

I love BMW's and I have owned 7 of them over the years. But some aspects of their attitude to the UK market really irks me.



E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
toppstuff said:
E38Ross said:
i'd be willing to bet that most audi quattro cars are sold for other reasons than because they're 4WD.
I'm not sure about that. Our here in the sticks Quattros are popular with the country cottage set precisely because they have 4WD. BMW continually miss a trick with this market. Apparently people in continental Europe like 4WD but we Brits ( one of their most important markets ) are not worth BMW including when they engineer 4WD for their new cars.

Audi see fit to engineer their Quattros for RHD and LHD at the design stage, but BMW can't be arsed. Its like the way the last 5 series had the windscreen wipers configured for LHD because they could not be bothered to engineer a RHD version. Cheapskate rubbish and a very cynical view of the UK customer IMO.

I love BMW's and I have owned 7 of them over the years. But some aspects of their attitude to the UK market really irks me.
BMW have sold 4WD cars here in the past, but they didn't sell well compared to their RWD counterparts....at all. i understand that "out in the sticks" maybe....but that's not the majority of the UK. most people i know with Audis with quattro bought it more because it's an audi, not because they wanted 4WD. BMW and Merc sales are just as good as (if not better in BMWs case) Audi sales.....

no-one moans at merc for not doing a 4WD C-class for instance.

toppstuff

Original Poster:

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
BMW have sold 4WD cars here in the past, but they didn't sell well compared to their RWD counterparts....at all. i understand that "out in the sticks" maybe....but that's not the majority of the UK. most people i know with Audis with quattro bought it more because it's an audi, not because they wanted 4WD. BMW and Merc sales are just as good as (if not better in BMWs case) Audi sales.....

no-one moans at merc for not doing a 4WD C-class for instance.
Thats the point. All the Audi drivers I know have them because of Quattro !

I think the problem is the way BMW market them. People do not associate BMW tourings with 4WD utility, simply because BMW choose not to offer them or to market them properly.

Same with the Merc C and E class. They are'nt that popular with country types.

Audi Quattro A3/A4/A6's with a couple of spaniels in the back clog up the local Waitrose car pack in this neck of the woods. The really rich ones drive Skoda Octavia Scouts. smile

JPJ

422 posts

280 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
Certainly the E61 came out far too late in my opinion - the initial surge for M5's had to be sated with the saloon, and people probably didn't want to wait. There has to be a market for M5 Tourings as seen with the fast Audi and Mercedes estate models.

Cheib

25,482 posts

206 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
toppstuff said:
E38Ross said:
BMW have sold 4WD cars here in the past, but they didn't sell well compared to their RWD counterparts....at all. i understand that "out in the sticks" maybe....but that's not the majority of the UK. most people i know with Audis with quattro bought it more because it's an audi, not because they wanted 4WD. BMW and Merc sales are just as good as (if not better in BMWs case) Audi sales.....

no-one moans at merc for not doing a 4WD C-class for instance.
Thats the point. All the Audi drivers I know have them because of Quattro !

I think the problem is the way BMW market them. People do not associate BMW tourings with 4WD utility, simply because BMW choose not to offer them or to market them properly.

Same with the Merc C and E class. They are'nt that popular with country types.

Audi Quattro A3/A4/A6's with a couple of spaniels in the back clog up the local Waitrose car pack in this neck of the woods. The really rich ones drive Skoda Octavia Scouts. smile
Yes. I even know people who commute into London every day from the likes of Kent and Bucks who now have 4wd cars because of the last couple of winters. You don't need to be stranded for hours on end many times to make you switch to 4WD the next time you buy a car.

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
Cheib said:
Yes. I even know people who commute into London every day from the likes of Kent and Bucks who now have 4wd cars because of the last couple of winters. You don't need to be stranded for hours on end many times to make you switch to 4WD the next time you buy a car.
funny, considering my mates Audi RS4 was described by him as "the worst car in the snow he's ever driven".

tyres are a very important factor most people don't think twice about.

Robsti

12,241 posts

237 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
Cheib said:
Yes. I even know people who commute into London every day from the likes of Kent and Bucks who now have 4wd cars because of the last couple of winters. You don't need to be stranded for hours on end many times to make you switch to 4WD the next time you buy a car.
funny, considering my mates Audi RS4 was described by him as "the worst car in the snow he's ever driven".

tyres are a very important factor most people don't think twice about.
He's obviously never driven a BMW in the snow then! wink

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
Robsti said:
He's obviously never driven a BMW in the snow then! wink
he has actually, but it had winter tyres on it wink

Cheib

25,482 posts

206 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
Cheib said:
Yes. I even know people who commute into London every day from the likes of Kent and Bucks who now have 4wd cars because of the last couple of winters. You don't need to be stranded for hours on end many times to make you switch to 4WD the next time you buy a car.
funny, considering my mates Audi RS4 was described by him as "the worst car in the snow he's ever driven".

tyres are a very important factor most people don't think twice about.
Completely. My X5 with it's 315 section tyres doesn't go anywhere when it's cold..........