Discussion
Hi All,
I've decided it's time to have a little luxury in my life and after much discussion with the other half have opted for a new 520D (I say discussion - out of the E-Class, A6 and Lexus iS it was the one she liked the look of the most!). Can you give me some feedback on how good/bad it is? It'll be an auto - how is the mileage? Have BMW sorted out the problems with the paintwork (she was wanting a black one but I've heard they are the worst).
Thanks in advance.
I've decided it's time to have a little luxury in my life and after much discussion with the other half have opted for a new 520D (I say discussion - out of the E-Class, A6 and Lexus iS it was the one she liked the look of the most!). Can you give me some feedback on how good/bad it is? It'll be an auto - how is the mileage? Have BMW sorted out the problems with the paintwork (she was wanting a black one but I've heard they are the worst).
Thanks in advance.
Having been in a similar position we opted not to get one, we were after a 520d sport - lovely car, but until BMW sort their OBD stealing problem out or at least say they're working on a fix I just thought another marque would be a better buy. Plus having already had one BWM with ED the battery stopped working at 2.5 years old and BMW refuse to replace it saying that the vehicle has huge electrical demands, so £400 down there. Add the RFT's in with their extortionate cost and its now Audi all the way!!
I've had a 520d SE auto for about 18 months / 35k miles now. After having an E320cdi Merc for 5 + years.
I was worried about lack of performance in comparison , but it's quick enough for such a big car , currently 44 mpg but get more on a run.
Specced up with sport pack and adaptive lights. , biggest mistake was the wheels that came with the sp , what a set of buggers to clean , never get those again.
Good to drive and will sit at 90/95 all day no bother , longest drive was 720 miles in a day with ease.
Get the pre paid service plan thrown in on the deal .
Only fault I can remember is that the computer has always said the rear pads need changing in 2700 miles .
I was worried about lack of performance in comparison , but it's quick enough for such a big car , currently 44 mpg but get more on a run.
Specced up with sport pack and adaptive lights. , biggest mistake was the wheels that came with the sp , what a set of buggers to clean , never get those again.
Good to drive and will sit at 90/95 all day no bother , longest drive was 720 miles in a day with ease.
Get the pre paid service plan thrown in on the deal .
Only fault I can remember is that the computer has always said the rear pads need changing in 2700 miles .
Angelp said:
Thanks guys, some useful advice which may make me think twice. Can you explain what the OBD stealing problem is (I'm afraid I'm a little naive when it comes to these things).
Ta.
See the "New BMWs getting stolen with blank keys" thread in this forum. It is 50 pages long however. In short, once theives are into the car (various methods, smash window, drill locks, jammers) they plug a device into the OBD socket, code a blank key to the car (by copying the 'handshake' code off the ECU onto the key) and use that key to drive your car off. Takes less than 5 minutes in total. Massive security flaw due to lax software approch by BMW, BMW are in denial and taking a very arrogant position. Affects all cars with key that slots into dash and start/stop button, from around 2006/56 reg certainly until 2011. Not clear if latest models are affected ie F series, but certainly all E series are - E60 and E90 most commonly taken.Ta.
eastsider said:
See the "New BMWs getting stolen with blank keys" thread in this forum. It is 50 pages long however. In short, once theives are into the car (various methods, smash window, drill locks, jammers) they plug a device into the OBD socket, code a blank key to the car (by copying the 'handshake' code off the ECU onto the key) and use that key to drive your car off. Takes less than 5 minutes in total. Massive security flaw due to lax software approch by BMW, BMW are in denial and taking a very arrogant position. Affects all cars with key that slots into dash and start/stop button, from around 2006/56 reg certainly until 2011. Not clear if latest models are affected ie F series, but certainly all E series are - E60 and E90 most commonly taken.
Thanks eastsider. Does anyone know if the new models are affected?Angelp said:
I've decided it's time to have a little luxury in my life and after much discussion with the other half have opted for a new 520D (I say discussion - out of the E-Class, A6 and Lexus iS it was the one she liked the look of the most!). Can you give me some feedback on how good/bad it is? It'll be an auto - how is the mileage? Have BMW sorted out the problems with the paintwork (she was wanting a black one but I've heard they are the worst).
Thanks in advance.
So you've decided to have some luxury and let your other half pick the make, model and colour Thanks in advance.

A friend has a 520d Sport auto and is delighted with it. Having been inside it is a lovely place to be. Sprightly enough for a 2.0 heavyish diesel auto and cracking mpg.
Re the paint, I think it was something to do with the change to waterbased paints.
Probably best to go and have a look at a new car in black and let her see for herself.
If you behave she might even let you go with her

B17NNS said:
So you've decided to have some luxury and let your other half pick the make, model and colour 
A friend has a 520d Sport auto and is delighted with it. Having been inside it is a lovely place to be. Sprightly enough for a 2.0 heavyish diesel auto and cracking mpg.
Re the paint, I think it was something to do with the change to waterbased paints.
Probably best to go and have a look at a new car in black and let her see for herself.
If you behave she might even let you go with her
Anything for a quiet life!! Thank you - I'm off to do my housework!
A friend has a 520d Sport auto and is delighted with it. Having been inside it is a lovely place to be. Sprightly enough for a 2.0 heavyish diesel auto and cracking mpg.
Re the paint, I think it was something to do with the change to waterbased paints.
Probably best to go and have a look at a new car in black and let her see for herself.
If you behave she might even let you go with her

I've run my 520d SE for 14 months and 42k.
I like the car but I think the 2.0d engine isn't powerful enough it's fine up to 50mph but on the motorway IMHO it needs more shove, that said as a mile muncher it really is superb and wafts you along with a feeling of total isolation. (in a good way)
Not sure if you've looked at the options but VDC is recommended as are the comfort seats (pricey but well worth it)
As for the paint work mine is black and the paint marks badly, bird lime leaves etchings on the car etc....
I have recently been in both a 12 plate 320d and a 12 plate 520d, only for about an hour each so I don't know too much, but my thoughts are this: The engine is more suited to the 320d, it did feel somewhat breathless in the 5 Series although not vastly so. On paper it's as quick, if not quicker than my 13 year old petrol 5 series, but I just felt like it was somewhat lacking in grunt as mentioned above, especially low down, however this is a motorway cruiser. It is however a lovely engine, smooth, quiet and refined. I would opt for a more powerful diesel engine in the 5 Series if you can as it offers all the above plus the extra power, without a massive compromise in running costs. It's such a brilliant car, I doubt you would regret it.
Edited by sparks_E39 on Saturday 30th June 20:14
Edited by sparks_E39 on Saturday 30th June 20:15
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



