Just how good is the F10 535d M sport
Just how good is the F10 535d M sport
Author
Discussion

smokey145

Original Poster:

616 posts

181 months

Saturday 30th June 2012
quotequote all
As the title really. Looking at replacing my M6 coupe in a year or so and these look very tempting.

Owners, how are you finding them? Anyone else made the similar jump?

pits

6,704 posts

221 months

Sunday 1st July 2012
quotequote all
I would imagine it would be a million times better than the 525D M sport I had the pleasure of driving, in which case it will be utterly fking amazing, the F10s are epic cars, if I had the cash one would be sat on my drive right now, they are the perfect progression from the E34, they are everything the E39 and E60 should have been, IE like an E34 but better, not complete barges.

Helicopter123

8,831 posts

187 months

Sunday 1st July 2012
quotequote all
Its a fantastically complete car, but not a bundle of fun IMO

It's also no better than a 520d M sport stuck in traffic.


Chr1sch

2,592 posts

224 months

Sunday 1st July 2012
quotequote all
Helicopter123 said:
It's also no better than a 520d M sport stuck in traffic.

My god you sound like my Dad, in which case you should love the new 1 litre focus

Helicopter123

8,831 posts

187 months

Sunday 1st July 2012
quotequote all
Chr1sch said:
Helicopter123 said:
It's also no better than a 520d M sport stuck in traffic.

My god you sound like my Dad, in which case you should love the new 1 litre focus
I've not driven the Focus yet so can't comment ;-)

Are you saying a £50k 5 series is more fun than a £30k 5 series is traffic?

Neil.D

2,878 posts

237 months

Sunday 1st July 2012
quotequote all
Is an M5 more fun in a traffic jam? No, it's probably worse than a 520d.

In a 520d, you're still in a 520d when you leave the traffic. That would make me miserable.

The 535d is an excellent real world car.

As a machine it can't be faulted.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Almost as good as the 535i M Sport apparently wink

Also, all F10's are more fun than a 520d in traffic because the tedious thrum of the 4 cylinder hatchback engine offers negative fun.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
They are alright cars but they have been dumbed down a lot this generation, so much so I think they have lost that BMW sparkle.
Sure they appeal to more of the people more of the time, but for those few who used to buy a BMW for a reason they might be disappointed.
I was.


gaz1234

5,233 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
bit of a come down from an M! Shame

bennyboydurham

1,617 posts

205 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Passed a broken down M6 near Ripon the other day. The driver looked forlorn as it was being winched onto a flatbed AA wagon.

They're not known for being the last word in reliability are they?

Oh and on topic, I drove a 530d F10 and it felt very grown up, almost 7 Series like in the way it handled itself. I'd imagine the 535 is very good indeed.

smokey145

Original Poster:

616 posts

181 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
They are alright cars but they have been dumbed down a lot this generation, so much so I think they have lost that BMW sparkle.
Sure they appeal to more of the people more of the time, but for those few who used to buy a BMW for a reason they might be disappointed.
I was.
So how does it compare with the E60 535 msport?

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
smokey145 said:
So how does it compare with the E60 535 msport?
Better looking, better made, better interior, better plastics, better engine, better iDrive.

sp222

203 posts

180 months

Tuesday 10th July 2012
quotequote all
I just got an F11 530d touring (I had an E61 previously)

initial impressions are that the interior is a great improvement - it wasn't bad before, but the F11 build quality for the interior seems much better. the i-drive system is also better - navigation particularly is really good.

Drive wise - the 530d has pretty decent performance so I would imagine that the 535d is pretty close to all you could want from one of these types of cars 95% of the time.

Mine doesn't have adaptive drive but I've been fairly happy with the feel, and the damping is much better that the E61. The only negative I would say is that the steering is a little less analogue in feel so you feel very slightly disconnected from the action, although I obviously haven't had a chance yet to try different tyres, which may make a difference.

The gearbox is very good in auto mode, but I'm not quite used to it yet in manual mode - 8 speeds means it's a little harder to judge if you should be in 3rd or 4th for some corners etc.

Lastly - refinement is a big step on from before and inside it's much quieter.

cerb4.5lee

45,313 posts

211 months

Tuesday 10th July 2012
quotequote all
Neil.D said:
Is an M5 more fun in a traffic jam? No, it's probably worse than a 520d.

In a 520d, you're still in a 520d when you leave the traffic. That would make me miserable.

.
I have a 520d & it makes me very miserable, so much so I would rather set fire to it than use the throttle in it!!

I would much sooner have an m5 any day of the week, provided someone was paying for the fuel!

The 520d has one of the most hateful engines ever made imho.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 10th July 2012
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
I have a 520d & it makes me very miserable, so much so I would rather set fire to it than use the throttle in it!!

I would much sooner have an m5 any day of the week, provided someone was paying for the fuel!

The 520d has one of the most hateful engines ever made imho.
You are so wrong. It has loads of torque (TORQUE WINS RACES BHP SELLS CARS) and you can't tell its a diesel and the power delivery is amazing and you can't hear the engine!

cerb4.5lee

45,313 posts

211 months

Tuesday 10th July 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
cerb4.5lee said:
I have a 520d & it makes me very miserable, so much so I would rather set fire to it than use the throttle in it!!

I would much sooner have an m5 any day of the week, provided someone was paying for the fuel!

The 520d has one of the most hateful engines ever made imho.
You are so wrong. It has loads of torque (TORQUE WINS RACES BHP SELLS CARS) and you can't tell its a diesel and the power delivery is amazing and you can't hear the engine!
hehe

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all
smokey145 said:
gizlaroc said:
They are alright cars but they have been dumbed down a lot this generation, so much so I think they have lost that BMW sparkle.
Sure they appeal to more of the people more of the time, but for those few who used to buy a BMW for a reason they might be disappointed.
I was.
So how does it compare with the E60 535 msport?
The E60 still had a rawness to it, it still felt very BMW, and when you pressed on it shrunk around you.
The F10 just doesn't feel that BMW, it feels like a big, comfy, mile munching luxury car, but it has lost any sense of rawness at all, and there is no real feedback any more. Put your foot down and press on and it no longer shrinks like the E60 does, it still feels like a big car.
I can see that BMW are going for the comfort thing, but if I wanted comfort I would buy a Merc, and I did.
But I buy my BMWs as I want it to be focused, and the new ones simply aren't, so thee really is little point any more.
Don't get me wrong, still great cars, and I would own another one, and if I had only one car I would like it a lot, but there used to be a massive gap between the 5 series, E Class and the A6, but there isn't anymore. Now it comes down to which one you prefer the styling of and interior more than anything else.


I actually think the A6 is the best of the German 3 in this sector at the moment, I was seriously impressed with it, not something I ever thought I would say. It felt more nimble and the steering was better, and it was more comfy than our 5 series and my E350cdi, which is doing well for Audi, as they used to be crashy and wollowy at the same time, a technical acheivment for sure, but not one to be proud of.
But the new A6 3.0tdi Quattro was an immense bit of kit.

The F10 for me is as good as the rest, but it is no longer ahead like previous 5 series have been, and that is a shame.

cerb4.5lee

45,313 posts

211 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
The E60 still had a rawness to it, it still felt very BMW, and when you pressed on it shrunk around you.
The F10 just doesn't feel that BMW, it feels like a big, comfy, mile munching luxury car, but it has lost any sense of rawness at all, and there is no real feedback any more. Put your foot down and press on and it no longer shrinks like the E60 does, it still feels like a big car.
I can see that BMW are going for the comfort thing, but if I wanted comfort I would buy a Merc, and I did.
But I buy my BMWs as I want it to be focused, and the new ones simply aren't, so thee really is little point any more.
Don't get me wrong, still great cars, and I would own another one, and if I had only one car I would like it a lot, but there used to be a massive gap between the 5 series, E Class and the A6, but there isn't anymore. Now it comes down to which one you prefer the styling of and interior more than anything else.


I actually think the A6 is the best of the German 3 in this sector at the moment, I was seriously impressed with it, not something I ever thought I would say. It felt more nimble and the steering was better, and it was more comfy than our 5 series and my E350cdi, which is doing well for Audi, as they used to be crashy and wollowy at the same time, a technical acheivment for sure, but not one to be proud of.
But the new A6 3.0tdi Quattro was an immense bit of kit.

The F10 for me is as good as the rest, but it is no longer ahead like previous 5 series have been, and that is a shame.
A very well put post thanks, i enjoyed reading it, i keep looking at the F10 & hankering over one.