BMW 525d M Sport Touring 2011 (3.0L) - Stop / Start Traffic
BMW 525d M Sport Touring 2011 (3.0L) - Stop / Start Traffic
Author
Discussion

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

I have the automatic sport gearbox and just wondering what is best to do in start / stop traffic.

The options:

1. Stop-neutral-handbrake on
2. Stop-leave in drive-handbrake on
3. Stop-auto handbrake

I dont really trust / like the auto handbrake.

My current preference is to stop-neutral-apply handbrake.

Whats your thoughts?

G

Tea Pot One

1,870 posts

259 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
2.

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
Interesting you say option 2. Does that not strain the transmission?

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
in answer to your 3 options; none of them!
if the traffic is really stop/start, just pop it into neutral and hold it on the foot brake. If the stops are longer, then pop into neutral and apply hand brake.
Always putting the auto into neutral when stopped will help with economy and the drivetrain, but then i have been told by my dealer that it's totally unnecessary. Of course, the highway code would say if in neutral you have to apply the hand brake, but OMG that would get really annoying!!

anyhow, i thought the F10/11 had auto stop/start??

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
il sole said:
in answer to your 3 options; none of them!
if the traffic is really stop/start, just pop it into neutral and hold it on the foot brake. If the stops are longer, then pop into neutral and apply hand brake.
Always putting the auto into neutral when stopped will help with economy and the drivetrain, but then i have been told by my dealer that it's totally unnecessary. Of course, the highway code would say if in neutral you have to apply the hand brake, but OMG that would get really annoying!!

anyhow, i thought the F10/11 had auto stop/start??
Good to know that putting the auto into neutral when stopped will help with economy and the drivetrain. Why would you possibly ignore savings on economy and especially the drive train.

Was the person at the dealer a mechanic who has serviced hundreds / thousands BMWs? If it was a salesperson I would hardly go believing them. Did they give a reason to why its unnecessary?

Bugger the highway code. If I paid attention to that I would still be sitting on a sofa practicing feeding the wheel with a dinner plate!

My car is the F11 and I thought it had auto stop / start? But it doesnt seem to do it? How do I verify that the car has it and how do I enable it?

Vic_S

230 posts

272 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
gordonhunter said:
Good to know that putting the auto into neutral when stopped will help with economy and the drivetrain.
I didn't think that was true - what does the owners manual say?

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Thursday 26th July 2012
quotequote all
Vic_S said:
gordonhunter said:
Good to know that putting the auto into neutral when stopped will help with economy and the drivetrain.
I didn't think that was true - what does the owners manual say?
I would certainly think that by design this has been considered and when stopped the drivetrain will fully dis-engage so as not to wear out the transmission, use excess fuel, pull on the brakes etc. It would have been silly not to and so I reckon you must just be able to leave it in drive.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 26th July 2012
quotequote all
Only the late 2011 cars have stop start.

TX1

3,018 posts

214 months

Thursday 26th July 2012
quotequote all
As this is the first auto I have owned I also wondered about this.
So when at lights and I know its a longish stop I slip it in neutral with my foot on the brake and when its a short stop I just leave it in drive with foot on the brake.

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Only the late 2011 cars have stop start.
My car doesn't have auto stop start - I think its an April 2011 model so probably just before they introduced stop / start or provided it as standard.

I think auto start / stop can become quite annoying especially in start stop traffic where the jolt of starting the car can just become tiring after a while.

As far as I know it can be disabled but am glad my car doesnt have it and you often here of other drivers just disabling it.

And surely there is more where and tear to the car stopping and starting all the time so in the long run it doesnt seem to be a good idea.

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
TX1 said:
As this is the first auto I have owned I also wondered about this.
So when at lights and I know its a longish stop I slip it in neutral with my foot on the brake and when its a short stop I just leave it in drive with foot on the brake.
I guess you would get a definitive answer from a BMW trained mechanic.

scz4

2,856 posts

272 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
On a related note, I would love to know if there is a way to permanently disable the stop start function.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
They say not to put it in neutral, the car will do all that when it comes to a stop.
Just put your foot on the brake.

Wills2

29,938 posts

206 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
Just engage the auto-hold function, if you don't like that (neither do I) just pull up and stop/hold on the brakes then lift off when the traffic moves?

Not sure why you want to fanny about with putting it in neutral...


Edited by Wills2 on Friday 27th July 18:49