BMW 525i overheating
BMW 525i overheating
Author
Discussion

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Thursday 5th July 2012
quotequote all
My newly- bought BMW 525i has overheated.
Today's drive home from work was particularly congested thanks to Frankie Valli and the four seasons. I became conscious that the car smelled hot, but the gauge was reading at the 12 O'clock position, just as it should be. I wasn't far from home so I finished my journey and popped the bonnet with the engine running, just in time to watch the expansion tank overflow. All the while the gauge was reading normal and I have no warning lights.
There are no other symptoms, no mis-fires, no water in oil or visa versa. I haven't carried out any further investigation yet so I don't know whether I have a plastic water pump impeller problem, a viscous fan problem, a secondary fan problem or a thermostat issue.
The way I see it, the normal gauge reading is a major curve ball.
Thanks in advance for any help

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Thursday 5th July 2012
quotequote all
As you were in traffic when it was getting hot I suggest the viscous fan coupling may be failing, to test this roll up a paper or something soft and try stopping the fan, if it stops easy, so easy you can stop it with your finges you need a new one.
Also you could have a circulation problem, water pump impellers maybe?
Try the fan first and report back.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Friday 6th July 2012
quotequote all
I notice in your profile it's a 1996, so probably an E34? With the E39 it's necessary to replace the entire cooling. System as it ages, not sure on the E34.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 6th July 2012
quotequote all
The fan/newspaper thing is a misnomer really. It should only shred a newspaper when engaged, and it only engages when it's good and hot. If the coupling looks old, black and 'orrible, just fit a new one. They last about 10 years and 100k, sometimes more, often less. A good one will briefly engage from cold on start up - it'll make a distinctive 'whoooooosh' and then die down after a few seconds. When cold the fan should have some drag - if it just spins with zero resistance, it's shagged.
If it's an old E34 you'll still have a plastic impeller pump in there - they started with those around 1994/5. Again, if it looks grotty and original, invest 30 quid in a new one. KWP Circoli pumps from a factors are good enough. If the stat failed closed, the thing would have boiled its bks off in no time. E34 rads lasted longer than the later ones but it's more than old enough to be 'bowed' out at the bottom.

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Friday 6th July 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys,
It is indeed an E34, with the same M50 engine that went into earlier E39s.
I'll be working on the car tomorrow, my theory is that:
-I checked the coolant level a couple of days before the overheating episode. As it turns out I didn't tighten the expansion tank cap enough, so the system couldn't pressurise and boiled at a lower temperature than you'd usually expect.
-The boiling episode has introduced air into the system
-With the system re-bled (at 1am on a dark, unattended 'Shell' forecourt), the car's temperature can be controlled with the heater but it'll heat up if the heater is switched off- So the thermostat is suspect.
-My fan clutch isn't working too well. It spins in a limp-wristed, barely connected way regardless of engine temp. I can stop it by hand with the engine hot after a 10 minute journey.

I'll be flushing the cooling system, replacing the thermostat and checking the water pump tomorrow. Might go the whole hog and replace the fan coupling too because it does not push air as it should when the engine is hot.

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Saturday 7th July 2012
quotequote all
Good man! Change that coupling first, sounds like its had it!

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Saturday 7th July 2012
quotequote all
Just taking a tea break. The news is mixed!
It all stripped down fine but the more I stripped it, the more I thought "this has been replaced recently". The 'stat looked a bit dodgy, wasn't completely shut, but it did open in boiling water so it hadn't failed completely. The water pump looks newish and has a metal impeller. There was evidence of leaking around the 'stat housing and it had been fitted with sealant, so was probably re-used. I got a new one. It's going back together fine but as everything looked pretty recent, I'm worried I've got a cracked head or a gasket issue. Will update this thread once it's running and bled!
For today I'm re-fitting the old fan/coupling. If I don't have a terminal engine problem I will replace it!

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
the car's temperature can be controlled with the heater but it'll heat up if the heater is switched off.



-My fan clutch isn't working too well. It spins in a limp-wristed, barely connected way
Errr, the problem is kind of staring you in the face...........

Continue to drive it with a shagged fan clutch, and you will have a cracked head.

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
iSore, I agree with you that the coupling ultimately needs replacing, but I don't think the fan clutch is the only problem. A car overheating but 'coolable' using the heater is also a classic thermostat symptom. The car was overheating the other night while cruising, so there is clearly no hot water circulating the rad. The fan does push air, The car has an electronic secondary fan and it can be cooled using the heater. I was loath to spend £70 on a fan coupling when the car could already be scrap. However, the car appears to be cured- bled up very easy indeed and once it was settled I spent a good 20 minutes in the garage trying to make it overheat, which it wouldn't. Gauge bang on Center, bottom hose stayed cold until the crucial 92 degrees at which point it quickly started circulating hot water to the radiator. The car sounds right too. Fingers crossed! The fan coupling will be replaced once I'm satisfied my engine isn't toast.
It's a pleasure to work on, all the work yesterday went off without a hitch. The 16-year old hoses even seem to have plenty of life left. Nothing seized or rusted. Lovely!

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
The car was overheating the other night while cruising
In your first post, the car was overheating in traffic.

A car that's coolable with the heater is more like a blocked radiator. You've already established that the stat opens. Now you need to see what it's like on the open road at speed.

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
In your first post, the car was overheating in traffic.
Yes, hence this little explanation:

HustleRussell said:
...my theory is that:
-I checked the coolant level a couple of days before the overheating episode. As it turns out I didn't tighten the expansion tank cap enough, so the system couldn't pressurise and boiled at a lower temperature than you'd usually expect.
-The boiling episode has introduced air into the system
When it was air-locked, it quickly overheated with normal cruising no matter what I did. Once bled, it was possible to cool it using the heater.

iSore said:
A car that's coolable with the heater is more like a blocked radiator. You've already established that the stat opens. Now you need to see what it's like on the open road at speed.
Blocked radiator/sticking thermostat- one and the same. Both would cause little or no flow through the radiator. Since I have removed a dodgy-looking 'stat and replaced it with new, and now the car appears to be 100% fine, I must deduce that although the 'stat opened up in a saucepan full of boiling water, it must have been slow to open or opening too late.

I drove the car to work this morning and it heated up much quicker than usual, but once the dial got to the mid-point, it stayed rock solid for the rest of the journey. I have repeatedly re-bled the radiator but I have never had any more air come out of the bleed screw. I reckon it's fixed, and since I don't seem to have combustion gasses getting into the coolant, the engine is proably fine. Now I can happily spend £70 on a new fan coupling!

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Tuesday 10th July 2012
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
Blocked radiator/sticking thermostat- one and the same.
A sticking thermostat would lead to the car getting very hot very quickly. A blocked rad (i.e the bottom silted up) would lead the car only getting hot at speed.

Doesn't matter a toss either way, your thing lives again.