E46 Petrol Engines real world experience
E46 Petrol Engines real world experience
Author
Discussion

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

262 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
I am looking at getting an E46 cabriolet in the very near future and was wondering what the real world differences in performance and economy are between the 320 (2.2) 2.5 and 3.0 variations.

On autotrader it dosent really look as if the 3.0 is much worse on petrol but has much better performance.

My PH head says 3.0 and to the hell with it but their are more decent 2.2/5 ones around.

Any info much appreciated.

It will be used daily for an approx 15 mile commute of country lanes and a bit of town. I would like to average mid 20's if possible.

Thanks

rumple

15,426 posts

182 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
330 will fit the bill nicely, for the same running costs is have the 330 anyday, its a no brainer really.

Luca Brasi

885 posts

205 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
3.0 all the way. They are brilliant engines.

gf15

1,040 posts

297 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
We have had a 2002 330i convertible for close to 3 years now. Apart from regular servicing we only had to replace a single coil pack on a spark plug. It is a smashing car. Drive several before you buy, as the good ones stand out a mile.
We find the hard top worth the extra cost (~£600). Wind deflector is also a must. There are some wonderful storage solutions for the hard top (fitted cover that you can hang on the garage wall.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
MPG is the same for all of them.

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

262 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Cheers for all the replies, Just summed up what I thought.

Placed a deposit on a 330ci this morning !

Happy days !

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Just to confirm, there is little difference between the M54 engines in terms of economy. There is just 1.5mpg on the combined cycle between the most thirsty (The 3.0) and the most frugal (The 2.2). Reliability/repair bills are the same, servicing costs are the same (Bar brakes but it's only marginal), so unless you find a particularly nice 320i or 325i the 330i is the one to have.

noumenon

1,282 posts

235 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all

You'll probably drive the smaller engines harder, meaning in the real world they'll all have the same MPG!

Patrick Bateman

13,219 posts

205 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
The only reasons you'd go for the smaller engines would be

A) You're daft

or

B) Your budget is too low for a 330

blippo1984

358 posts

177 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Disagree.

Lots of very tired 3 series out there now in e46 guise. You might get a 325 for example as its a bit if a deal and/or a minter.

That said I had 330

Patrick Bateman

13,219 posts

205 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
In which case your budget would be too low for a decent 330.

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

262 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Well I think I chose the right engine its only done 85k with fsh.

Quick question are they chain driven or cambelt?

Twin Turbo

5,544 posts

297 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Chain.......and my 330i auto gets an average 29.4mpg smile

gaz1234

5,233 posts

250 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
chain

clabcon

325 posts

236 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Twin Turbo said:
Chain.......and my 330i auto gets an average 29.4mpg smile
My OBC currently reports 19.5 mpg for a 330Ci auto. In the week it gets used 2-3 miles daily for commuting, so the engine does not really get warm. On the weekends it gets driven hard on a mixture of A/B roads using WOT as/when safe. My e36 m3 evo with 6 speed manual box got a better fuel consumption; I thought it was just the autobox. I get around 270 miles from the 63 litre tank (19.5 mpg). Is there anything mechanical reason other than a lead foot as to why I am getting 10 mpg less than you? My tyre pressures are obviously spot on!

Phunk

2,102 posts

202 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
I used to get 19mpg in my 330Ci auto round town and on short commutes too.

Twin Turbo

5,544 posts

297 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
I should have said......my commute (47 miles) is done at 0500hrs and is a 10 mile section of clear A road, the rest is on the M4. So, no stopping and somewhere between 50-80mph all the way. My return journey is done (usually) before the main rush hour, too.

I do use it for the occasional trundle around town at weekends, where it'll be getting high-teens.

On average, I'll get about 350 miles from a tank (I fill up before the light appears) and the OBC reads 29.4mpg. Climate control/air-con always on a comfy 21 degress!

I suspect my sort of commute means that's the most you're likely to get out of one smile

laingy

676 posts

272 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
I get 22mpg in my 330 cab. But it is used for 3 mile commutes to the station.

mini1380cc

2,949 posts

202 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Phunk said:
I used to get 19mpg in my 330Ci auto round town and on short commutes too.
This is exactly the same for me.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Twin Turbo said:
Chain.......and my 330i auto gets an average 29.4mpg smile
You must be driving like Miss Daisy to get anywhere near that!!