3-Series Speaker (E91)
3-Series Speaker (E91)
Author
Discussion

bracken78

Original Poster:

996 posts

237 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Hi All,

We have recently purchased a 56 reg BWM 3 series Touring and it has quite possible the worst stereo I have ever heard. I’m amazed at how poor the sound quality is.

I’m not so keen on paying close to 4 figures to have the stereo upgraded with amps and new speakers (as quoted by the local ICE centre) and would be happy to remove the door cards etc and fit new speakers myself.

The question is, has anyone ever done a straight swap of the speakers before and is it worth it? If so, what speakers did you fit?

Cheers,
Henry

scooters

217 posts

246 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
bmw alpine kit did it for me. OEM fit and easy to do yourself. phone around a couple of dealers for quotes though as they can vary a bit.

scooters

217 posts

246 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
bmw alpine kit did it for me. OEM fit and easy to do yourself. phone around a couple of dealers for quotes though as they can vary a bit.

bracken78

Original Poster:

996 posts

237 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
scooters said:
bmw alpine kit did it for me. OEM fit and easy to do yourself. phone around a couple of dealers for quotes though as they can vary a bit.
Hi Scooters, Not heard of this before. What does the Alpine Kit include? I had a Google and found this link.

http://bmwfans.info/parts/catalog/E91/Touring/Euro...

scooters

217 posts

246 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
pretty much that. An amp that goes under the boot, wiring harness to subs under each front seat, tweeters and mid for door card. you'll need to get new front door plastic trim to house the tweeter (by mirrors) but bmw should advise. Note, this was based on me having the bmw 'professional' (not) sound kit.
hope this helps but let me know if you have any other questions and I will do my best to help

Billyray911

1,086 posts

235 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
I've started replacing my Professional system with logic 7 speakers.
At the moment,I've only replaced the under seat subs which have improved things somewhat-they were a plug and play fit.
I did want the Alpine upgrade as there was a group buy via Sytner a while ago.
However,as I have dab,the amp couldn't be fitted due to the position of the dab module.
Would be interested in seeing what other options there are...

bracken78

Original Poster:

996 posts

237 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
Many thanks scooters and I will speak to the local dealer and see what they have to say.

Billyray, I also have DAB, maybe this might cause a problem but I will check.

Billyray911

1,086 posts

235 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
bracken78 said:
Many thanks scooters and I will speak to the local dealer and see what they have to say.

Billyray, I also have DAB, maybe this might cause a problem but I will check.
Keep us posted...

KW 355

32 posts

184 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
I replaced the speakers with Focal items in my e90 which made a noticeable improvement. I used their Access 100 ca 1 model in the front doors, they surface mounted with no cutting / damage to the door card.

bracken78

Original Poster:

996 posts

237 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
KW 355 said:
I replaced the speakers with Focal items in my e90 which made a noticeable improvement. I used their Access 100 ca 1 model in the front doors, they surface mounted with no cutting / damage to the door card.
Hi KW 355, Did you replace all four speakers (one in each door) with the Access 100 ca1 speakers?

bracken78

Original Poster:

996 posts

237 months

Saturday 21st July 2012
quotequote all
Billy Ray, you where right. As our BMW has DAB we can not fit the Alpine speakers system.

I'm making some investigation with local ICE companies.

KW 355

32 posts

184 months

Wednesday 25th July 2012
quotequote all
bracken78 said:
Hi KW 355, Did you replace all four speakers (one in each door) with the Access 100 ca1 speakers?
Mine was an e90 so I fitted larger Focal speakers in the rear shelf. If the touring front and rear speakers are the same they should fit in the rear.

80sboy

452 posts

188 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
I probably wouldn't bother with the Alpine upgrade. Generally I see it as an expensive option and from what I read doesn't actually sound that great.

The Alpine stuff intended for OEM replacement isn't near as decent as their after-market stuff. It's still to focussed on cost rather than performance.

People often comment that the Alpine option has a harsh treble, average clarity, and is generally disappointing.

There are cheaper and better solutions out there. I've been there and considered Alpine, but quickly went aftermarket. Results were very impressive and cost was reasonable.

I didn't do this, but Google 'Jenhert Flatline speaker kit'. Very highly rated and is an easy fit. You'll need a suitable 5-channel amp.

It'll be worth the slight extra effort/cost.


Esseesse

9,027 posts

239 months

Friday 27th July 2012
quotequote all
bracken78 said:
KW 355 said:
I replaced the speakers with Focal items in my e90 which made a noticeable improvement. I used their Access 100 ca 1 model in the front doors, they surface mounted with no cutting / damage to the door card.
Hi KW 355, Did you replace all four speakers (one in each door) with the Access 100 ca1 speakers?
I'm thinking of replacing the OEM speakers with components in the e39 at some point.

IIRC The Focal Access stuff is now discontinued (although you can still pick it up).

No offence KW 355, I was thinking of getting Focal Access myself but I hear that they're a little bright. I'm probably going to go with some of the Morel components as they're meant to be a bit more balanced with their silk tweeters.

bracken78

Original Poster:

996 posts

237 months

Saturday 28th July 2012
quotequote all
80sboy said:
I probably wouldn't bother with the Alpine upgrade. Generally I see it as an expensive option and from what I read doesn't actually sound that great.

The Alpine stuff intended for OEM replacement isn't near as decent as their after-market stuff. It's still to focussed on cost rather than performance.

People often comment that the Alpine option has a harsh treble, average clarity, and is generally disappointing.

There are cheaper and better solutions out there. I've been there and considered Alpine, but quickly went aftermarket. Results were very impressive and cost was reasonable.

I didn't do this, but Google 'Jenhert Flatline speaker kit'. Very highly rated and is an easy fit. You'll need a suitable 5-channel amp.

It'll be worth the slight extra effort/cost.
Many thanks for the link to Jehnert Flatline speaker kit. Looks good and straight swap. I'll be in contact with them.

Not made any progress this week as work has been crazy so nothing to update.