Ah well, it'll T-Cut out I suppose
Discussion
Down in the South of France and we've just had the most remarkable hail strom which has dented every panel bar the plastic front wings on our spanking new 7 week old X5 

Last Import-222 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Last Import-220 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Last Import-219 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Last Import-214 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr
Our two friends Volvos fared no better to include a smashed windscreen on one.
Just got to hope the insurance company honour their new for old policy, as far as I can see its a re-shell and I really wouldn't feel happy with that TBH.
Still, at least Team GB has won lots of Gold medals


Last Import-222 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Last Import-220 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Last Import-219 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Last Import-214 by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr
Our two friends Volvos fared no better to include a smashed windscreen on one.
Just got to hope the insurance company honour their new for old policy, as far as I can see its a re-shell and I really wouldn't feel happy with that TBH.
Still, at least Team GB has won lots of Gold medals

Edited by HoHoHo on Sunday 5th August 18:09
You must be gutted!
It may not need a new shell though ....
There are certain PDR guys that travel the world calling themselves 'storm chasers'.
Every now and then a hail storm will hit new car compounds where thousands of new vehicles are kept for export ... they get called out and work 10 or 12 hrs a day, 7 days a week, for weeks at a time on thousands of cars with damage just like yours.
Then the cars are exported and sold as new and none of us are any the wiser.
So it maybe the case that PDR will be the way it goes.
It may not need a new shell though ....
There are certain PDR guys that travel the world calling themselves 'storm chasers'.
Every now and then a hail storm will hit new car compounds where thousands of new vehicles are kept for export ... they get called out and work 10 or 12 hrs a day, 7 days a week, for weeks at a time on thousands of cars with damage just like yours.
Then the cars are exported and sold as new and none of us are any the wiser.
So it maybe the case that PDR will be the way it goes.
beanbag said:
Blimey! That doesn't look good at all. Wouldn't that be a total write-off in insurance terms?
All it needs is a bonnet, tailgate, roof skin ( http://tis.spaghetticoder.org/s/view.pl?1/06/07/08 ), and a paint job!(And yes, I am aware of how much labour is involved in replacing the roof skin!)
Still upsetting though! hope you get it sorted OP!
4rephill said:
beanbag said:
Blimey! That doesn't look good at all. Wouldn't that be a total write-off in insurance terms?
All it needs is a bonnet, tailgate, roof skin ( http://tis.spaghetticoder.org/s/view.pl?1/06/07/08 ), and a paint job!(And yes, I am aware of how much labour is involved in replacing the roof skin!)
Still upsetting though! hope you get it sorted OP!
Isn't a roof skin really a re-shell?
Commiserations OP - this happened in Leicestershire a few weeks ago too: http://www.alfaowner.com/Forum/alfa-147-156-and-gt...
HoHoHo said:
Isn't a roof skin really a re-shell?
Not necessarily. BMW will sell the roof skin as a part on it's own, ~£1000 + VAT.ETA, just looked at your pictures and notice it's a panoramic roof, it will cost more eventhough there is less metal, but still available.
Edited by E30M3SE on Sunday 5th August 20:06
Squiggs said:
You must be gutted!
It may not need a new shell though ....
There are certain PDR guys that travel the world calling themselves 'storm chasers'.
Every now and then a hail storm will hit new car compounds where thousands of new vehicles are kept for export ... they get called out and work 10 or 12 hrs a day, 7 days a week, for weeks at a time on thousands of cars with damage just like yours.
Then the cars are exported and sold as new and none of us are any the wiser.
So it maybe the case that PDR will be the way it goes.
This is indeed true (well, not sure about the storm chasers bit). When I worked in Austria - a place that gets some shocking thunder/hail storms - there would be hundreds of cars lined up for shipping when a hail storm would roll in. The manufacturers have insurance against hail storms and the repair would be to pull all the dents. The dent guys certainly earned their overtime those weeks!It may not need a new shell though ....
There are certain PDR guys that travel the world calling themselves 'storm chasers'.
Every now and then a hail storm will hit new car compounds where thousands of new vehicles are kept for export ... they get called out and work 10 or 12 hrs a day, 7 days a week, for weeks at a time on thousands of cars with damage just like yours.
Then the cars are exported and sold as new and none of us are any the wiser.
So it maybe the case that PDR will be the way it goes.
Either way, sorry for the OP. That must be truly gutting

HoHoHo said:
Also the rear quarter panels are dented 
The only panels that aren't damaged are the front wings, and that's because they're made of plastic!
Really is upsetting to see!, I feel your pain! 
The only panels that aren't damaged are the front wings, and that's because they're made of plastic!
Edited by HoHoHo on Sunday 5th August 20:11

(If only they made more of the car out of plastic! - Dear BMW, have you thought of using more plastic panels on your cars? )
There's a 3week old, brand new Vauxhall Insignia down the road from Me that has about three times as many dimples on its roof, bonnet, boot and front wings due to the exact same thing! (I think that's a company car though so I doubt the owners that upset about it).
I can't remember ever seeing damage like that on a car in all My life! (which is a fair length of time!
). I have heard about such damage in others countries though, like in the USA.
I hope whichever way this goes, you are put back in a position where you are 100% happy with whichever car you end up with (replacement or repaired).
Best of Luck with it!
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



t, sorry, I meant TBH......duh!