Weird resonance on motorway E46 tourer
Weird resonance on motorway E46 tourer
Author
Discussion

Zead

Original Poster:

377 posts

238 months

Tuesday 7th August 2012
quotequote all
I was driving down M1 on Sunday when the car started to rumble. The first time it was relatively gentle. Similar to out of balance wheel but with no steering wheel shake. I slowed down partly due to traffic, and it stopped. Up to speed again and it was fine. It started again after a while and seemed worse. Much more turbulent like a flat spotted tyre! to the point I was looking for a safe gap to get to the hard shoulder. As I slowed and started moving in the effect went. I drove gently for a while waiting for a convenient exit to see anything had fallen off underneath. Could see nothing wrong. Anyway M25 and A3 home it didn't happen again. Inspected car today and can find nothing! No loose wheels, tyre pressures good, all four wheels pointing in the same directionsmile any ideas what it could be as it was quite concerning. Thanks Z

s4avant

196 posts

227 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
This happens to me on the M9 between Edinburgh and Perth and it seems that the concrete road surface at this point is to blame.
The "rumble" was so marked in a Golf GTI that I once had, that i pulled into the hard shoulder expecting a puncture.
Once onto a tarmac surface however, the resonance disappears.

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
I was convinced mine had a knackered wheel bearing, but I think it's just tyre noise on certain surfaces. Some days I'm convinced something is about to sieze, other days I don't notice it at all.

Zead

Original Poster:

377 posts

238 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Thanks, I hope it was the road. Although my wife reminded me the sun roof might have been open. In which case the inner screen may have been fluttering as one of the clips is broken.
There is section of M2 outside Dover that has concrete that makes my old VDub camper feel like the whole rear-end is about to drop off. It freaks me out every time we take it abroad. Luckily I remember now!

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Zead said:
Thanks, I hope it was the road. Although my wife reminded me the sun roof might have been open. In which case the inner screen may have been fluttering as one of the clips is broken.
There is section of M2 outside Dover that has concrete that makes my old VDub camper feel like the whole rear-end is about to drop off. It freaks me out every time we take it abroad. Luckily I remember now!
Rear window slightly open or back seats down?

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
May well be the cause, front windows and one rear open-sonic boom.

Zead

Original Poster:

377 posts

238 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
Update. Tried to recreate problem today and did! I slowed down and could feel immediately a front caliper sticking. Drove slowly home and did a 'spit on the disc test' and the front right spat back. Pulled the caliper apart and the piston is definitely sluggish although it did move. Rods are perfect. So a bit of GT85 in the piston boot to ease things for now but a caliper rebuild is due.

So beware, not always a road surface, or an open window. My car is beginning to tick the known faults boxes! At least they are relatively easy to fix. So far!