I've buckled a wheel on my Z4M! Options?
I've buckled a wheel on my Z4M! Options?
Author
Discussion

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Evening,

I hit a speed bump near to where I live about 4 weeks ago and have buckled my drivers side front frown only noticed it today with a steering wheel wobble, I jacked it up and it is buckled right by the tyre valve, not massive damage but enough to spoil my enjoyment and it seems to be accentuated when braking from high speed.

Anyway can these be repaired / balanced out or will it be a new wheel?

Cheers

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Buckled wheels can be straightened depending on how bad the are, contact your local wheel refurbishers. If it's badly bent then may be 'new' wheel time.

tjlazer

875 posts

205 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Time for CSLs...

Pig Skill

1,368 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Once a wheel is bent and then straightened it will never be as strong and will likely be a weak wheel compared to the others. Get a new one mate — not worth the risk. Straighten a panel maybe, but not he thing that keeps you on the road.

On a side note — aren't you supposed to slow down for speed bumps? fkrippletongue out

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Pig Skill said:
Once a wheel is bent and then straightened it will never be as strong and will likely be a weak wheel compared to the others. Get a new one mate — not worth the risk. Straighten a panel maybe, but not he thing that keeps you on the road.

On a side note — aren't you supposed to slow down for speed bumps? fkrippletongue out
Cheers, and yes you are, I just get used to gliding over them in my focus, unfortunately the Z4 doesn't so much glide as smash wink

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
tjlazer said:
Time for CSLs...
Don't tempt me, if it wasn't for the fact the Mrs had 9 months holiday to bring up a baby or something wink then they would already be on there!

smile

Pig Skill

1,368 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Urban Sports said:
Pig Skill said:
Once a wheel is bent and then straightened it will never be as strong and will likely be a weak wheel compared to the others. Get a new one mate — not worth the risk. Straighten a panel maybe, but not he thing that keeps you on the road.

On a side note — aren't you supposed to slow down for speed bumps? fkrippletongue out
Cheers, and yes you are, I just get used to gliding over them in my focus, unfortunately the Z4 doesn't so much glide as smash wink
Yeah those damn runflats do a great job of passing as much of the impact energy across into the chassis.

If you are new daddy then deffo don't risk a bent wheel - have you looked for a used on off the bay?

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Pig Skill said:
Urban Sports said:
Pig Skill said:
Once a wheel is bent and then straightened it will never be as strong and will likely be a weak wheel compared to the others. Get a new one mate — not worth the risk. Straighten a panel maybe, but not he thing that keeps you on the road.

On a side note — aren't you supposed to slow down for speed bumps? fkrippletongue out
Cheers, and yes you are, I just get used to gliding over them in my focus, unfortunately the Z4 doesn't so much glide as smash wink
Yeah those damn runflats do a great job of passing as much of the impact energy across into the chassis.

If you are new daddy then deffo don't risk a bent wheel - have you looked for a used on off the bay?
I've had a look on ebay but they tend to be refurbished so I'm not keen.

Normal tyres on the Z4M, no runflats. The annoying thing is I remember at the time thinking that I'd hit it that hard that it must have buckled a wheel, 4 weeks later after I'd forgotten about it.... rolleyes

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
On the off chance are these a warranty claim?

Cheers

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Sunday 12th August 2012
quotequote all
Urban Sports said:
On the off chance are these a warranty claim?

Cheers
No because the damage isn't due to a manufacturing fault or a design fault, they simply weren't designed for slamming into potholes (no wheel on a standard road car is, regardless of what tyre is fitted).

The damage was down to a poorly maintained road and a lack of observation on the part of the driver (and yes, quite often you get no warning of what's ahead of you when driving in traffic, but the fact that you indicate that you "glide" over the same pothole in your Focus says immediately that you are to blame for your own misfortune - you knew the pothole was there and did nothing to avoid it!).

You could try and claim compensation from the council in charge of the road however, as they've failed to maintain the road in an acceptable condition.
To do this, you'll need to take plenty of pictures of the pothole, including measurements of width, length, and depth and of the damage to your wheel (it would also pay to get BMW to do a report on the damage to the wheel to support your case.).

Note though: There is no guarantee that the council involved will accept liability and pay out. Many of them argue that they were unaware of the pothole at the time and cannot be expected to fix them all as soon as they appear. They also tend to have a policy denying liability if the pothole is deemed too small.

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Sunday 12th August 2012
quotequote all
4rephill said:
Urban Sports said:
On the off chance are these a warranty claim?

Cheers
No because the damage isn't due to a manufacturing fault or a design fault, they simply weren't designed for slamming into potholes (no wheel on a standard road car is, regardless of what tyre is fitted).

The damage was down to a poorly maintained road and a lack of observation on the part of the driver (and yes, quite often you get no warning of what's ahead of you when driving in traffic, but the fact that you indicate that you "glide" over the same pothole in your Focus says immediately that you are to blame for your own misfortune - you knew the pothole was there and did nothing to avoid it!).

You could try and claim compensation from the council in charge of the road however, as they've failed to maintain the road in an acceptable condition.
To do this, you'll need to take plenty of pictures of the pothole, including measurements of width, length, and depth and of the damage to your wheel (it would also pay to get BMW to do a report on the damage to the wheel to support your case.).

Note though: There is no guarantee that the council involved will accept liability and pay out. Many of them argue that they were unaware of the pothole at the time and cannot be expected to fix them all as soon as they appear. They also tend to have a policy denying liability if the pothole is deemed too small.
It wasn't a pothole it was a speed bump.

smile

Cheers

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Sunday 12th August 2012
quotequote all
www.alloyfix.co.uk

Fixed three of mine and they're all still perfect, he basically heats them up and then presses the bend out on a hydraulic jig. £50 per rim.

I have no qualms using them and don't expect my alloys are likely to explode as a result.

Of course he's probably a bit far away for what you need!

Pig Skill

1,368 posts

234 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Blue Oval84 said:
www.alloyfix.co.uk

Fixed three of mine and they're all still perfect, he basically heats them up and then presses the bend out on a hydraulic jig. £50 per rim.

I have no qualms using them and don't expect my alloys are likely to explode as a result.

Of course he's probably a bit far away for what you need!
Of course they can be repaired so they are round again, but that doesn't mean they are as strong as they once were and the straightened section will always be a weak spot.

Once bent out of round then on a molecular level it is impossible to recreate the uniformity and as such they are never the same. As an example take a strip of copper wire and kink it, then try and straighten it back to perfection....

OP get a new wheel — imagine having wife and child and hitting another bump or pothole and losing control.

Forget cheap fixes as they could well become an expensive mistake.

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Pig Skill said:
Of course they can be repaired so they are round again, but that doesn't mean they are as strong as they once were and the straightened section will always be a weak spot.

Once bent out of round then on a molecular level it is impossible to recreate the uniformity and as such they are never the same. As an example take a strip of copper wire and kink it, then try and straighten it back to perfection....

OP get a new wheel — imagine having wife and child and hitting another bump or pothole and losing control.

Forget cheap fixes as they could well become an expensive mistake.
He won't be (legally)able to get wife and child in a Z4 at the same time though. jester

I agree, get a new wheel.

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

210 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
I would get a new wheel

They come up fairly regularly on ebay etc

Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Took it to my local tyre fitters and neither were buckled but the weight on the drivers side one had come off, probably when I hit the speed bump, they are now balanced perfectly.

Result

thumbup

Oh and it was free as my Dad knows the owners!

cerb4.5lee

45,324 posts

211 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Urban Sports said:
Took it to my local tyre fitters and neither were buckled but the weight on the drivers side one had come off, probably when I hit the speed bump, they are now balanced perfectly.

Result

thumbup

Oh and it was free as my Dad knows the owners!
Cracking result then!

Pig Skill

1,368 posts

234 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
eastsider said:
Pig Skill said:
Of course they can be repaired so they are round again, but that doesn't mean they are as strong as they once were and the straightened section will always be a weak spot.

Once bent out of round then on a molecular level it is impossible to recreate the uniformity and as such they are never the same. As an example take a strip of copper wire and kink it, then try and straighten it back to perfection....

OP get a new wheel — imagine having wife and child and hitting another bump or pothole and losing control.

Forget cheap fixes as they could well become an expensive mistake.
He won't be (legally)able to get wife and child in a Z4 at the same time though. jester

I agree, get a new wheel.
Yeah, I knew that. I was just checking you were all awake that's all wobble

christer

2,804 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Urban Sports said:
I've had a look on ebay but they tend to be refurbished so I'm not keen.

Normal tyres on the Z4M, no runflats. The annoying thing is I remember at the time thinking that I'd hit it that hard that it must have buckled a wheel, 4 weeks later after I'd forgotten about it.... rolleyes
Dude, just be aware that "refurbished" usually refers to the cosmetics 99% of the time so one of those should be fine.


Urban Sports

Original Poster:

11,321 posts

234 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
christer said:
Urban Sports said:
I've had a look on ebay but they tend to be refurbished so I'm not keen.

Normal tyres on the Z4M, no runflats. The annoying thing is I remember at the time thinking that I'd hit it that hard that it must have buckled a wheel, 4 weeks later after I'd forgotten about it.... rolleyes
Dude, just be aware that "refurbished" usually refers to the cosmetics 99% of the time so one of those should be fine.
I know, but I bought some refurbished wheels for my E90, they were awful.

No need now anyway!

smile