E92 335i - which tyres to replace the run-flats?
E92 335i - which tyres to replace the run-flats?
Author
Discussion

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

I’ve had my E92 335i for coming-up 3 months and, although the ride quality isn’t awful, I’m not convinced about the run-flats and hence I’m thinking of getting rid in favour of conventional tyres. Therefore, just wondering how many people out there have made a similar change and whether there are any particular tyres people would recommend?

My car has 19” wheels (the same as my old M3 CS) and I ran that on Vredestein Ultrac Sessantas. I was always very happy with them (IMO as good as the PS2’s they replaced with the bonus of being a fair bit cheaper as well) but I chose them on the back of an EVO tyre test going back several years and I guess the game may have moved on since then?

The Continental Contact Sport 3’s came out top in EVO’s 2012 test but from what I can see they’re not available in a size to fit the front of the 335i (225/35). The tyre that came out second was the Hankook Ventus S1 and they are available in the right size and at a pretty competitive price too (around £675 for a full set from Camskill); however, I’ve no experience of those so has anyone tried them and if so what are your thoughts? The tyre that finished third in the EVO test was the Goodyear Asymmetric 2; they’re about £65 more for a set than the Hankooks but would seem a pretty safe choice and in truth I’d have probably used them on the M3 had they been available in the right size.

Anyway, all views welcome!

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
I changed the 4 on my E92 335i (19") with Falken 452's over 2 stages, fronts in September and rear's in January.

The ride is dramatically better, it now goes over bumps and minor road imperfections when it didnt wothout breaking you before. Wear seems similar as does noise.

Although I do have to say that i've found through my girlfriend's driving that the rim protection isn't as good...

They are good tyres and either the same again or the Vred's are what I would replace with, especially at sub £130 a corner.

My only worry was re. punctures. I baught a can of the foam and a cigarette lighter inflator but luckily I havn't had cause to use them as of yet.

Edited by kiethton on Monday 20th August 14:13

b14

1,322 posts

219 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Falkens are good tyres - I'm just about to replace the run flats on my 335i and will go for F452s.

FYI don't put too much faith in Evo's tyre tests, they are primarily a marketing tool for Continental.

SBN

1,030 posts

183 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Ditched the run flats for michelin ps3, great tyres and got rid of all tramlining. I would always opt for decent tyres... Saw some comments about falkens losing shape recently but that's probably the same for most tyres if the alignment isn't spot on.

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
[redacted]

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
SBN said:
Saw some comments about falkens losing shape recently but that's probably the same for most tyres if the alignment isn't spot on.
Yes, also seem to remember seeing some comments to the effect the Falkens are good but don't necessarily wear very well. I appreciate tyre life depends on driving style and conditions but roughly what sort of mileage are people getting out of 452's?

TheBMWDriver

594 posts

185 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
eagle f1 GS-D3 or CS 5P

They cost a few quid extra over cheap crap but worth every penny

dace

202 posts

241 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Goodyear F1 Assy's all the way for me. Had them on my RS4 and could not fault them! I too will be ditching my run flats for these, albeit on a E90 330D.

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
TheBMWDriver said:
eagle f1 GS-D3 or CS 5P

They cost a few quid extra over cheap crap but worth every penny
Not familiar with that derivative of the Eagle F1 but looking on Camskill's website it appears it could be a run-flat? Not what I'm after if that's the case!

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
JNW1 said:
SBN said:
Saw some comments about falkens losing shape recently but that's probably the same for most tyres if the alignment isn't spot on.
Yes, also seem to remember seeing some comments to the effect the Falkens are good but don't necessarily wear very well. I appreciate tyre life depends on driving style and conditions but roughly what sort of mileage are people getting out of 452's?
As i said I've had my fronts on for c.6k and the rears for about 4k miles. I've done nothing but town driving (plus Le Mans which may be counted as similar wear rates) and the tyres have c.7mm left.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Falkens - Noisy and shouders go off fast. Good grip for 65% of tyres life then they are useless.

Pirelli - Good grip fast wear rate, good grip 65% of tyres life etc.

Michelin PS series - Good grip 85% of tyres life etc.

Goodyear F1, excellent wet grip good dry for 85% of tyres life etc

Michelin Super Sport...best tyre i ever drove on but expensive. Not done a full use on them.

Curveball.....Nankang NS2...Based on the original PS1 tread pattern as far as i can tell, good all round performance for 80% of tyre life, just fitted a complete set 225/265 19's.

I get through 2-3 sets of tyres a year, pleased with the NS2's and good for the money.

Crackie

6,386 posts

273 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
JNW1 said:
I’ve had my E92 335i for coming-up 3 months
Good choice thumbup

JNW1 said:
I’m not convinced about the run-flats and hence I’m thinking of getting rid in favour of conventional tyres.
Ditch the RFs as soon as possible imho; RF tech may have improved enormously during the past 3~4 years but this has only improved them to point where they're useless.
I've been happy with Falken 452s on my 335i. Some PH posters have said that 452 wet grip drops off badly at higher mileages but not in my experience. There has certainly been a change in wet grip but I think its only marginally lower than when they were new. The drop off has only been 5% max over a distance of 9k-10k miles and imho it is still fine.




Edited by Crackie on Monday 20th August 23:49

rm163603

656 posts

279 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Another vote for Eagle F1 Asym 2s..

Wet or dry they work really well.

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
Thanks to everyone for their replies. As I said in my original post the Goodyears look a safe choice and having done a bit more digging - and taking into account the comments above - I think that's the way I'm leaning. The Vreds gave excellent service on the M3 but their price seems to have edged up since I last bought some of those and a full set is actually more expensive than the Goodyears.

As a further thought, my run-flats all have loads of tread on them (fronts over 6mm, rears about 5mm) and have never been repaired or scuffed. Brand new the set would cost just over £1k (!) so I'm wondering whether it might be worth trying to flog the part-worn tyres? However, never attempted to sell anything like that before so what sort of money do people think they might be worth?

FastNReliable

308 posts

210 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
I changed from Bridgestone RFTs to Conti SP5s nearly 10 months ago. The SP5s while more expensive than some of the tyres already mentioned in this thread were still less expensive than new RFTs.

If you're considering ditching the ditchfinders then I say go for it! I'd also recomend the SP5s, I'd considered Michelin Piot Sports but couldn't find them in the correct sizes at that time. I'd used Pilot Sport IIs on my last car (2 or three sets of them over the years) and was very happy with them so the move to the Contis was a step into the unknown however they are as good if not a little better than the Pilot Sport IIs in most condditons and considerably better thna the Pilot Sports in winter.

SBN

1,030 posts

183 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
No one has mentioned dunlops sports. Was given a great price on these and have them on the tourer, haven't noticed much difference and seem to wear very well so far

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
[redacted]

Salom

230 posts

207 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
My 330Ci had Falkens on when I bought it, they were dreadful, the worst tyre I have ever experienced; hard ride and lethal in the wet.
I generally always go for 'Quality' names like Michellin, Pirelli etc, but I did a lot of research and ended up with Vredestein Ultrac Sessantas, an amazing tyre at only £100.00 a corner!

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
SBN said:
No one has mentioned dunlops sports. Was given a great price on these and have them on the tourer, haven't noticed much difference and seem to wear very well so far
When you say you haven't noticed much difference what's the tyre you're comparing against? Also, in the sizes that fit the E92 335i (225/35 front, 255/30 rear), the Dunlops appear to be more expensive than the Goodyears (or at least they are with Camskill!).

JNW1

Original Poster:

9,535 posts

225 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
Salom said:
My 330Ci had Falkens on when I bought it, they were dreadful, the worst tyre I have ever experienced; hard ride and lethal in the wet.
I generally always go for 'Quality' names like Michellin, Pirelli etc, but I did a lot of research and ended up with Vredestein Ultrac Sessantas, an amazing tyre at only £100.00 a corner!
I've also had very good experience with the Vreds but can you point me in the direction of where you can get them for £100 a corner to fit 19" wheels on an E92 335i?!! The Ultrac Sessantas are actually slightly more expensive for a set than the Goodyears based on the prices Camskill are quoting on their website; I've also used Tyremen in the past but their price for the Vreds is a touch higher than Camskill's.

In terms of the Falkens, I've no personal experience of them but from the research I've done they sound like they're a step down in performance compared to tyres like the Goodyear Eagle F1 or the Ultrac Sessanta. In some respects that's no surprise as they're quite a lot cheaper (£520 for a set as against £738 for the Goodyears and £764 for the Vreds). However, there seems little point in spending thousands on a car and then compromising performance (and perhaps safety) by saving a couple of hundred quid on the tyres; therefore, the Falkens are out for me!