335i v 335d from a "money spent on fuel" perspective?
Discussion
Hi guys,
I know this has probably been covered a million times, but the search function isn't the greatest.
I am looking at both variants, and the 335d seems to be about £2,000 more for a similar spec over the 335i. Now i know the fuel economy is a hell of a lot better on the 335d, but with diesel being more expensive, it got me wondering if the diesel would actually be cheaper considering the relatively low amount of miles i do. I'd say i do no more than 10,000 miles a year.
Would it be false economy getting the diesel? I had an Audi S4 before and used to hate seeing an 18 mpg average on my read out! It's much more satisfying seeing 44 mpg in my diesel golf, but how big does the gap need to beocme before it's worth it on low miles? Specifically when directly comparing the 335i to the 335d?
I know this has probably been covered a million times, but the search function isn't the greatest.
I am looking at both variants, and the 335d seems to be about £2,000 more for a similar spec over the 335i. Now i know the fuel economy is a hell of a lot better on the 335d, but with diesel being more expensive, it got me wondering if the diesel would actually be cheaper considering the relatively low amount of miles i do. I'd say i do no more than 10,000 miles a year.
Would it be false economy getting the diesel? I had an Audi S4 before and used to hate seeing an 18 mpg average on my read out! It's much more satisfying seeing 44 mpg in my diesel golf, but how big does the gap need to beocme before it's worth it on low miles? Specifically when directly comparing the 335i to the 335d?
my 335i gives me a 25-26 mpg average and live in the london suburbs with most driving being local although off peak.
This can go down to low 20's when pressing on but up to 35 on a long motorway cruise (averaged this going to Le Mans). The BMW 6 cylinder petrol engines are rather economical day to day
This can go down to low 20's when pressing on but up to 35 on a long motorway cruise (averaged this going to Le Mans). The BMW 6 cylinder petrol engines are rather economical day to day
kiethton said:
my 335i gives me a 25-26 mpg average and live in the london suburbs with most driving being local although off peak.
This can go down to low 20's when pressing on but up to 35 on a long motorway cruise (averaged this going to Le Mans). The BMW 6 cylinder petrol engines are rather economical day to day
Thanks, that's good to know and sort of sway sme towards the 335i more. I was dreading another 18-20mpg average car as i hate the thought of spending that much on fuel. But that actually doesn't sound too bad!This can go down to low 20's when pressing on but up to 35 on a long motorway cruise (averaged this going to Le Mans). The BMW 6 cylinder petrol engines are rather economical day to day
A lot also depends on how you drive those annual 10.000 miles - a few long motorway stints (335d superior) or a lot of short journeys (there will be little difference in economy between the 335i or 335d, as the d takes along time to heat up and has poor economy as a result)
Only thing that may be a factor for you is that the 335d seems like a more reliable engine (can of worms opened)
Only thing that may be a factor for you is that the 335d seems like a more reliable engine (can of worms opened)
rassi said:
A lot also depends on how you drive those annual 10.000 miles - a few long motorway stints (335d superior) or a lot of short journeys (there will be little difference in economy between the 335i or 335d, as the d takes along time to heat up and has poor economy as a result)
Only thing that may be a factor for you is that the 335d seems like a more reliable engine (can of worms opened)
my commute is a short stop and start journey and i only occasionally do longer miles at the weekend if i'm going somewhere! so even more case for the 335i then really!Only thing that may be a factor for you is that the 335d seems like a more reliable engine (can of worms opened)
i was taught at car salesman school that the cross over is 18,000 miles. so with mixed driving, If you do less than that you get a petrol, if you do that or more, diesel.
That said, if its pure town driving with the occasional motorway, petrol regardless of miles covered, vice versa if its gonna be all motorway runs, diesel.
That said, if its pure town driving with the occasional motorway, petrol regardless of miles covered, vice versa if its gonna be all motorway runs, diesel.
I have to say that if you are trying to save money, and yet you're still thinking of some course of action that involves your somehow paying to run, however briefly, a new car, you are not taking the exercise seriously.
However, your car WILL be a lot nicer (and newer) than mine, that's for sure.
Anyway, you can use maths to figure this out. Everybody uses miles per gallon, even though petrol is sold in litres, and the conversion factors are unpleasant, so people end up using rules of thumb and guesswork rather than just going through the numbers and figuring it out. But there's no need to guess - you can use google to get you part of the way, as it has a built-in calculator and units converter. Use google to search for something like "35 miles per imperial gallon in litres per 10000 miles" - don't forget the "imperial"! - and you'll get a litres figure that you can multiply up by the price.
So, using that, fuel:
10,000 miles, 25mpg, £1.36/L = £2,473
10,000 miles, 35mpg, £1.41/L = £1,831
(diesel = £642 cheaper)
10,000 miles, 35mpg, £1.36/L = £1,766
10,000 miles, 45mpg, £1.41/L = £1,424
(diesel = £342 cheaper)
(BTW I believe you should fill your average turbocharged six cylinder 300hp petrol car with super unleaded, but since this exercise is all about the saving money, we'll just put ordinary petrol in there.)
On top of the fuel, you'll save about £55 on car tax straight away. (Don't spend it all at once.)
So, I'd suggest buying the cheaper car, because you're unlikely to save £2,000 on fuel any time soon. I have no idea about servicing.
However, your car WILL be a lot nicer (and newer) than mine, that's for sure.
Anyway, you can use maths to figure this out. Everybody uses miles per gallon, even though petrol is sold in litres, and the conversion factors are unpleasant, so people end up using rules of thumb and guesswork rather than just going through the numbers and figuring it out. But there's no need to guess - you can use google to get you part of the way, as it has a built-in calculator and units converter. Use google to search for something like "35 miles per imperial gallon in litres per 10000 miles" - don't forget the "imperial"! - and you'll get a litres figure that you can multiply up by the price.
So, using that, fuel:
10,000 miles, 25mpg, £1.36/L = £2,473
10,000 miles, 35mpg, £1.41/L = £1,831
(diesel = £642 cheaper)
10,000 miles, 35mpg, £1.36/L = £1,766
10,000 miles, 45mpg, £1.41/L = £1,424
(diesel = £342 cheaper)
(BTW I believe you should fill your average turbocharged six cylinder 300hp petrol car with super unleaded, but since this exercise is all about the saving money, we'll just put ordinary petrol in there.)
On top of the fuel, you'll save about £55 on car tax straight away. (Don't spend it all at once.)
So, I'd suggest buying the cheaper car, because you're unlikely to save £2,000 on fuel any time soon. I have no idea about servicing.
I'd be looking at the 335i (or even the 330i) personally. The BMW diesels are truly excellent, but also truly dull in the way they go about their business. The 335d will be an excellent tool, but I doubt you'd ever start it up with the door open just to hear that straight six fire up like you would in the 335i.
For reference, I have recently changed from a 328i to a 330d (older models granted), and as awesomely competent as the 330d is, I do miss the 328i barking into life first thing in the morning. Also, due to how linear the torque curve on the 330d is, it never really feels as quick as the 328i did. I'm doing 18k a year for work so though the diesel would be worth a try, and it is saving me money on fuel. It's still getting replaced by soemthing with an "i" badge on the back when the time comes however.
For reference, I have recently changed from a 328i to a 330d (older models granted), and as awesomely competent as the 330d is, I do miss the 328i barking into life first thing in the morning. Also, due to how linear the torque curve on the 330d is, it never really feels as quick as the 328i did. I'm doing 18k a year for work so though the diesel would be worth a try, and it is saving me money on fuel. It's still getting replaced by soemthing with an "i" badge on the back when the time comes however.
Purely looking at the fuel economy vs fuel cost, you can compare directly based on the percentage difference.
Diesel is about 7p a litre more, based on around £1.40, so 5% more. Which means the diesel only needs to be 5% more efficient to break even, which it pretty much will be.
However, to get you the £2k premium back based on fuel savings, you might need to do quite a few miles...
On a fuel price difference of 7p, (diesel more,) and mpg difference of 5mpg, (diesel more,) the savings with diesel are about £200 per 10,000 miles.
If you can get 10mpg better on diesel, you'd need to do 50,000 miles before you broke even on the £2k premium, although the car might be worth a bit more than the petrol at time to sell.
Diesel is about 7p a litre more, based on around £1.40, so 5% more. Which means the diesel only needs to be 5% more efficient to break even, which it pretty much will be.
However, to get you the £2k premium back based on fuel savings, you might need to do quite a few miles...
On a fuel price difference of 7p, (diesel more,) and mpg difference of 5mpg, (diesel more,) the savings with diesel are about £200 per 10,000 miles.
If you can get 10mpg better on diesel, you'd need to do 50,000 miles before you broke even on the £2k premium, although the car might be worth a bit more than the petrol at time to sell.
bodhi said:
I'd be looking at the 335i (or even the 330i) personally. The BMW diesels are truly excellent, but also truly dull in the way they go about their business. The 335d will be an excellent tool, but I doubt you'd ever start it up with the door open just to hear that straight six fire up like you would in the 335i.
For reference, I have recently changed from a 328i to a 330d (older models granted), and as awesomely competent as the 330d is, I do miss the 328i barking into life first thing in the morning. Also, due to how linear the torque curve on the 330d is, it never really feels as quick as the 328i did. I'm doing 18k a year for work so though the diesel would be worth a try, and it is saving me money on fuel. It's still getting replaced by soemthing with an "i" badge on the back when the time comes however.
I too have a 330D (2009) and love it. 50mpg on a run with bags of torque. It is a real mile muncher and competent in the twisties! I have come from a B5 RS4 and then a E90 M3. Loving getting well over 500 miles between fill ups.......For reference, I have recently changed from a 328i to a 330d (older models granted), and as awesomely competent as the 330d is, I do miss the 328i barking into life first thing in the morning. Also, due to how linear the torque curve on the 330d is, it never really feels as quick as the 328i did. I'm doing 18k a year for work so though the diesel would be worth a try, and it is saving me money on fuel. It's still getting replaced by soemthing with an "i" badge on the back when the time comes however.
Another vote for the petrol!
I've got an E92 335i with the later N55 engine and it's averaging 31mpg without much in the way of long runs; I don't doubt a 335d would be better but I suspect the advantage would be rather less than the 9mpg the published figures suggest (5 to 6mpg would be my guess). As others have said, on 10k miles a year the fuel cost saving is too small to be of any real consequence so at that mileage the only reason for buying the 335d is if you prefer the way it drives. I know some love the torque of the 335d but the 335i isn't lacking in that department either and it's available across a much wider rev range. Factor in the much nicer noise and a choice of transmissions (manual or DCT as against old-style auto only) and it's a pretty easy decision IMO!
I've got an E92 335i with the later N55 engine and it's averaging 31mpg without much in the way of long runs; I don't doubt a 335d would be better but I suspect the advantage would be rather less than the 9mpg the published figures suggest (5 to 6mpg would be my guess). As others have said, on 10k miles a year the fuel cost saving is too small to be of any real consequence so at that mileage the only reason for buying the 335d is if you prefer the way it drives. I know some love the torque of the 335d but the 335i isn't lacking in that department either and it's available across a much wider rev range. Factor in the much nicer noise and a choice of transmissions (manual or DCT as against old-style auto only) and it's a pretty easy decision IMO!
Derek Chevalier said:
You realise the direct injection petrols sound very diesel-like at low revs?
And you realise that a 335i sounds nothing like a 335d when you rev it through the gears? I've owned a 6-pot BMW diesel and, good as they are, the noise of the petrol is far more appealing IMO!Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


