Auto or manual 335i
Auto or manual 335i
Author
Discussion

paf291x

Original Poster:

111 posts

285 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi All
Looking to buy a 335i very soon and was wondering what the auto box is like, i had an m3 smg and thought the box was sluggish around town but awsome when at full attack, overall i thought it spoilt the car to a certain extent.

So basically what your opinion on it ? auto or manual 335i ?

M888SXY

312 posts

188 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
I haven't driven a manual but the DCT in my 335i is excellent.

TheBMWDriver

594 posts

185 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
The Auto box works very well with the 335i, personally I think its a very quick box and have been more then happy with both the standard auto box and the DTC.

b14

1,322 posts

219 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
On the other hand the manual is very good, smooth and you can do lovely heel and toe.

I wouldn't have the auto but that's cos I like manuals. Both are good - take your pick really dependent on what you like.

Reliability wise I think the auto boxes might have the odd issue but I've never heard of any issues with the manual (it's the same gearbox from the M3 and the US-spec M5).

paf291x

Original Poster:

111 posts

285 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the replys keep them coming

If a nice 335i comes along i don't want to ignore it just because it's an auto if all the other spec. is spot on but also don't want to be stuck with a car i don't like driving, From your comments tho i think i will consider an auto as well.

gangzoom

9,012 posts

246 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Most 335is come with auto, I've never had an auto car before my 335i but a quick test drive changed my mind. The auto is obviously never going to be as involving as the manual but in real life is so easy to use. Normal driving in D mode the box is so smooth you don't even notice the gear changes, this is good and bad.

The good bits:

Traffic jams are much easier to deal with
Left foot braking is quite fun
Paddles on the steering wheel makes the box do what you want 95% of the time.

The bad bits:

The box is so smooth if you just put your foot down your soon end up well over the speed limit without realising!!
Your never really in FULL control, even in the DS (sport mode) if you mash the throttle and hit the "kick down" switch the box will change down, still this is easily avoided if you have some restraint with the right foot.
Not as quick as DCT, but unless your visiting the track it doesn't really matter.

Overall I don't think I'm going to buy another manual car again, for real life/day to day driving the auto box is perfect.

cerb4.5lee

45,330 posts

211 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
I think i would go manual for the extra involvement & the manuals are really rare aswell, we have a dual clutch gearbox in the Audi TT-S & its a quick changer & smooth but it just makes the car feel a bit push throttle & hang on! you feel a little detached from the actual car.

Autos are great for heavy commuting though, really easy & relaxing, i dont think you will be disappointed whichever one you choose, its a great engine imho. smile

JNW1

9,536 posts

225 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
I think i would go manual for the extra involvement & the manuals are really rare aswell, we have a dual clutch gearbox in the Audi TT-S & its a quick changer & smooth but it just makes the car feel a bit push throttle & hang on! you feel a little detached from the actual car.

Autos are great for heavy commuting though, really easy & relaxing, i dont think you will be disappointed whichever one you choose, its a great engine imho. smile
+1

The DCT is an excellent box and much more widely available second-hand. However, I jumped at a manual when one came along and no regrets; it's also a very good gearbox and for me the satisfaction of changing gear manually is part of the driving experience. If you do a lot of stop-start work around town DCT certainly has its merits but for driver involvement the manual still edges it for me (could be that I'm just a luddite though!).

smokey145

616 posts

181 months

Sunday 26th August 2012
quotequote all
DCT in my 335i and it's brilliant.