M54 fan issues
M54 fan issues
Author
Discussion

Luca Brasi

Original Poster:

885 posts

205 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
A few days ago I had the viscous fan clutch, belt and water pump replaced on my 325i (86k miles). Ever since then it seems that when I get on the accelerator the fan kicks in with a wooshing sound so I can't hear the nice straight six purring away. No loss of power, gets up to temperature nicely just like before, no increased consumption. What's causing this?

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
What make of fan is it?

Probably a faulty fan that is 'working' all the time.

Luca Brasi

Original Poster:

885 posts

205 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
I have no idea, the guy who fitted all the stuff is head mechanic at my local dealer so he just orders the parts at work.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Local BMW dealer?

Get him to look at it to confirm it's not 'working' permanently.

Luca Brasi

Original Poster:

885 posts

205 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
Local BMW dealer?

Get him to look at it to confirm it's not 'working' permanently.
Yup, he's got a pretty nice workshop at his house to work on cars after hours. Will give him a call then.

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Luca Brasi said:
A few days ago I had the viscous fan clutch, belt and water pump replaced on my 325i (86k miles). Ever since then it seems that when I get on the accelerator the fan kicks in with a wooshing sound so I can't hear the nice straight six purring away. No loss of power, gets up to temperature nicely just like before, no increased consumption. What's causing this?
It's normal, don't worry

bababa

132 posts

195 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Absolutely - I had the same when I replaced the viscous clutch on my E36. The previous one was completely knackered, so that the fan could just freewheel all the time.

Essentially, now your fan actually has some drive getting to it, it'll be pulling a reasonable quantity of air through, hence the noise.

The idea with the viscous clutch is that it "firms up" as the ambients in the engine bay increase, thereby delivering more power to the fan and moving more air. In practice, I found that mine is very firm from cold, but then eases off after the first few miles, but gradually firms back up again as the temperature increases.

ETA: But as E30M3SE says, if it's permanently like that all the time, it may be good to investigate - I've heard horror stories of fan blades detaching from the hub and causing damage in the engine bay if the viscous clutch gets seized and the fan permanently runs at the same speed as the engine.

Edited by bababa on Friday 24th August 16:58

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Having done one this morning, yes the above post is correct they are more audible than a totally fked coupling , however,

OP said:
seems that when I get on the accelerator the fan kicks in with a wooshing sound so I can't hear the nice straight six purring away.
A correctly working fan coupling should not be louder than the engine on acceleration.

Luca Brasi

Original Poster:

885 posts

205 months

Saturday 25th August 2012
quotequote all
bababa said:
Essentially, now your fan actually has some drive getting to it, it'll be pulling a reasonable quantity of air through, hence the noise.
That's exactly what he said.
He took the car for a short drive and noticed nothing uncommon.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 26th August 2012
quotequote all
My E39 does this now, in the past 6 months all belts, water pump and viscous have been replaced. It's normal, but it only does it for the first minute or so of driving though. I've noticed an overall quieter engine and better MPG since having the work done. If it's on all the time have the mechanic look at it.

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Sunday 26th August 2012
quotequote all
sparks_E39 said:
...If it's on all the time have the mechanic look at it.
The viscous fan will always spin to some degree whilst the engines running - if it doesn't then it's broken.

What should happen is that if the engine temperatures are below the fans thermal engagement point then the fan only spins slowly as it will be barely engaged. (In this situation, it should be possible to stop the fan rotating using the rolled up newspaper method).

Once the engine temperature rises above the fans thermal engagement point, the fan fully engages and runs at full speed, rising and dropping with with the engine revs. (Not advisable as you could damage the fan blades but, if you were to put a rolled up newspaper into the fan now, it'll get shredded).


If the fan is fully engaged at all engine temps then the viscous fan clutch is faulty (but as the OP has said he's just had this replaced I highly doubt that it'll be faulty).


Basically, using a rolled up newspaper against then fan blades with the engine running:

1) Engine cold/cool - newspaper stops fan blades rotating = viscous coupling ok
2) Engine hot - newspaper shredded = viscous coupling ok
3) Engine cold/cool - newspaper shredded = viscous coupling faulty
4) Engine hot - newspaper stops fan blades rotating = viscous coupling faulty