120d and 118d. Couple questions.
120d and 118d. Couple questions.
Author
Discussion

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Morning,

Having too many issues with the OH's Auris T180 (2.2tdi) - so decided enoughs enough and we're going to try pick up a 1er (first BMW).

It's probs going to be 2006-08 depending on which model we go for - looking to test drive some this weekend.

So what's the pick of the bunch?
When did the 118d go from 120 - 140hp? When did the 120d go from 163 - 177hp?
Is there a great deal of difference between the two on the road?
What's the crack between SE and M, I've heard the M is fairly stiff. We also have a Honda s2000, so although we want a sporty ride, this car will be the "comfy cruiser". Plus what a previous mondeo owner calls stiff would be different to a s2000 owner says.

Anything I need to watch out for on either cars? Any spec/equip which is worth waiting for?
Any real world MPG figures from you chaps?

Thanks in advance

t955daytona

318 posts

214 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
The LCI (i.e facelifted cars are the higher power ones, they also got stop/start and slightly different styling so are easy to spot, basically anything after 07 registration. The build date is on a sticker on the front wing. Also all 3 doors had the later engines. They are much lower emissions wise so have a look at the tax disc and see what it had cost to tax, the 143 118d is £30 a year, the earlier one is over £100.

Hope this helps, Craig.

t955daytona

318 posts

214 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
The LCI (i.e facelifted cars are the higher power ones, they also got stop/start and slightly different styling so are easy to spot, basically anything after 07 registration. The build date is on a sticker on the front wing. Also all 3 doors had the later engines. They are much lower emissions wise so have a look at the tax disc and see what it had cost to tax, the 143 118d is £30 a year, the earlier one is over £100.

Hope this helps, Craig.

t955daytona

318 posts

214 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
The LCI (i.e facelifted cars are the higher power ones, they also got stop/start and slightly different styling so are easy to spot, basically anything after 07 registration. The build date is on a sticker on the front wing. Also all 3 doors had the later engines. They are much lower emissions wise so have a look at the tax disc and see what it had cost to tax, the 143 118d is £30 a year, the earlier one is over £100.

Hope this helps, Craig.

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for your reply, thanks for your reply, thanks for your reply. wink

Does the same apply for the 120d? So lower emissions and therefore Tax in 2007?

Anyone with experience of driving them back to back?


yozzer

98 posts

233 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
I have a 2007 120d M Sport, costs me £95 a year to tax (well did last year) and i have averaged 53mpg (calculated - not OBC)

bulldog5046

1,495 posts

209 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
I've a 2010 (60 plate) 144bhp 118d. As for real world MPG, my commute is 37miles each way, mostly motorway, plus a couple of miles on B roads to get lunch etc.

Highest weekly average = 74MPG (Mega granny driving)
Lowest weekly average = 48MPG (flat out all week)
Normal weekly average = 62-64MPG (55-65mph)

All computer readouts which are 1-2MPG over the realworld figures when i've calculated it.

Lovely car over the 15k i've done since Jan!

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
yozzer said:
I have a 2007 120d M Sport, costs me £95 a year to tax (well did last year) and i have averaged 53mpg (calculated - not OBC)
Ideal, I assume being 2007 this is the facelift 177hp version. What is the ride like?

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
bulldog5046 said:
I've a 2010 (60 plate) 144bhp 118d. As for real world MPG, my commute is 37miles each way, mostly motorway, plus a couple of miles on B roads to get lunch etc.

Highest weekly average = 74MPG (Mega granny driving)
Lowest weekly average = 48MPG (flat out all week)
Normal weekly average = 62-64MPG (55-65mph)

All computer readouts which are 1-2MPG over the realworld figures when i've calculated it.

Lovely car over the 15k i've done since Jan!
Cant complain at that. Our driving will be much more varied including a lot of town work, so we wont be achieving those figures. But a mid 40's average looks on the cards. Which is 10 more than we currently get. thanks.

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
As a matter of interest, is there any reason you'd want a One Series rather thana Golf, say?

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Sticks. said:
As a matter of interest, is there any reason you'd want a One Series rather thana Golf, say?
Because golfs make me feel sick.

I believe they are one of the blandest cars out and do not excite me one single bit - even the "hot" ones (which look no different).

Edited by russy01 on Wednesday 29th August 18:16

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
russy01 said:
Because golfs make me feel sick.
That'll do it biggrin

I had a facelift 120d M Sport and in short: lots of trim fell off, and paint; ride was awful (other car was a Z4 on 18s for comparison)and felt unstable; engine rough (not only compared to my 330d, predictably, but friend's Golfs); rear seats useless; 42mpg max (auto).

Seats and steering were good. Just wished I'd looked at how much 3 Series I cold have had for the money.

Just my view, of course smile

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Sticks. said:
russy01 said:
Because golfs make me feel sick.
That'll do it biggrin

I had a facelift 120d M Sport and in short: lots of trim fell off, and paint; ride was awful (other car was a Z4 on 18s for comparison)and felt unstable; engine rough (not only compared to my 330d, predictably, but friend's Golfs); rear seats useless; 42mpg max (auto).

Seats and steering were good. Just wished I'd looked at how much 3 Series I cold have had for the money.

Just my view, of course smile
Thanks for your input. I will be able to comment more after I have driven a couple this weekend, I want to take an M or an SE out as like I said before I don't need an uncomfy car. I have also had a couple powerful diesels in the past so I have a good basis on which to compare regarding power delivery etc.

As for 3 series, I'm 24 and the OH is 23 and to be honest we have no desire or requirements for a car that size (unless of course we're talking RS4 or V8 M3 (next year!) She is just after a hatchback and well the 1er suits perfectly. (had Astra, Audi is more expensive for model we're after, focus is a ford, golf is a golf - nothing else floats the boat)

As for mpg, if yours was manual you could have got say 45mpg - I'd be happy with that. Our current cars do high 20's or mid 30's.

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Ok, enjoy your testing. FWIW I had Prielli Euforia tyres and found them scarily poor - just my view, of course. That's not very good, my TT does better than that! Hope you find something you like.

Swervin_Mervin

5,014 posts

269 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
We've had our 120d MSport now for 12months. It's the 177bhp unit.

Only issue has been clutch judder when cold - there's a fix for that though. It just recently tripped over 70k and feels like new. No trim issues here. Plastics are far nicer than the equivalent VAG, and the Sport seats are immensely comfortable.

bulldog5046

1,495 posts

209 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
We've had our 120d MSport now for 12months. It's the 177bhp unit.

Only issue has been clutch judder when cold - there's a fix for that though. It just recently tripped over 70k and feels like new. No trim issues here. Plastics are far nicer than the equivalent VAG, and the Sport seats are immensely comfortable.
Have to agree with you on the build quality, mine is exceptional aswell.

Also, FWIW, i had the 3.0 Z4 previously on 18's too and i'd say the ride is a little less harsh in the 1 with sport suspension.

The standard Bridgestone Potenza's are good tyres, but a bit pricey.

And finally, i'm also 24 so check the insurance before you jump into one as i found mine jumped up to £800 when i was expecting more like £400-500.

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
bulldog5046 said:
Swervin_Mervin said:
We've had our 120d MSport now for 12months. It's the 177bhp unit.

Only issue has been clutch judder when cold - there's a fix for that though. It just recently tripped over 70k and feels like new. No trim issues here. Plastics are far nicer than the equivalent VAG, and the Sport seats are immensely comfortable.
Have to agree with you on the build quality, mine is exceptional aswell.

Also, FWIW, i had the 3.0 Z4 previously on 18's too and i'd say the ride is a little less harsh in the 1 with sport suspension.

The standard Bridgestone Potenza's are good tyres, but a bit pricey.

And finally, i'm also 24 so check the insurance before you jump into one as i found mine jumped up to £800 when i was expecting more like £400-500.
that's a good point to make. We had an LCI 118d SE with sports seats...lovely car once we changed to non RFTs! you can also have a re-map done so you pay 118d tax, for 120d performance!!! We loved ours (our first ever BMW) and did about 30k miles in 3 years. a bit disappointing was the economy which never bettered 45mpg...

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
il sole said:
bulldog5046 said:
Swervin_Mervin said:
We've had our 120d MSport now for 12months. It's the 177bhp unit.

Only issue has been clutch judder when cold - there's a fix for that though. It just recently tripped over 70k and feels like new. No trim issues here. Plastics are far nicer than the equivalent VAG, and the Sport seats are immensely comfortable.
Have to agree with you on the build quality, mine is exceptional aswell.

Also, FWIW, i had the 3.0 Z4 previously on 18's too and i'd say the ride is a little less harsh in the 1 with sport suspension.

The standard Bridgestone Potenza's are good tyres, but a bit pricey.

And finally, i'm also 24 so check the insurance before you jump into one as i found mine jumped up to £800 when i was expecting more like £400-500.
that's a good point to make. We had an LCI 118d SE with sports seats...lovely car once we changed to non RFTs! you can also have a re-map done so you pay 118d tax, for 120d performance!!! We loved ours (our first ever BMW) and did about 30k miles in 3 years. a bit disappointing was the economy which never bettered 45mpg...
I've heard other people report this, but also claims that the 118d is weaker all over (diff, brakes, turbo). We are both used to fairly quick cars and therefore drive fairly hard - I wouldn't want to take the lower spec car and stress it constantly, where the 120d sounds like it will be more up for the job out of the box (then there is the oppo to remap that to a properly quick car).

As for tax comments, I understand there is a saving. But being a yearly bill a hundred quid here or there won't put me off the more expensive option.

MPG - as said before 45mpg to us is perfectly acceptable. We are currently getting 25-37 with our current cars

As for tyres - what's the consequence of not running RFT's, Apart from the obvious? Are there any legal requirements?

Swervin_Mervin

5,014 posts

269 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
No legal requirements. A recent query from us found that many places will refuse to fit them though - I just belmed at them down the phone and found somewhere that would. We haven't done it yet though as she wants new wheels as well.

We've found the mpg to be a little disappointing at 37-45mpg tbh. But there's a check you can easily do to see if the coolant is getting up to temp properly - which if it isn't means a thermostat or two need replacing. I've just procrastinated over doing it though!

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
russy01 said:
I've heard other people report this, but also claims that the 118d is weaker all over (diff, brakes, turbo). We are both used to fairly quick cars and therefore drive fairly hard - I wouldn't want to take the lower spec car and stress it constantly, where the 120d sounds like it will be more up for the job out of the box (then there is the oppo to remap that to a properly quick car).

As for tax comments, I understand there is a saving. But being a yearly bill a hundred quid here or there won't put me off the more expensive option.

MPG - as said before 45mpg to us is perfectly acceptable. We are currently getting 25-37 with our current cars

As for tyres - what's the consequence of not running RFT's, Apart from the obvious? Are there any legal requirements?
no worries on the non RFT front. We changed our 118d's within 5k miles! you'll find too that understeer is greatly improved with non RFTs. Any tyre fitter worth his salt will know that BMW rims fit both RFT and non RFT, if they say they can't, walk away.
With regards to the differences between 118d and 120d, I think you'll find there is very little with regards to brakes/suspension etc. The main reason for suggesting getting the 118, is 2 fold...1-it's cheaper than a 120d, and can therefore be remapped and 2-you and your other half may find the 143bhp is enough. I know you said earlier you were used to high power diesels, but in general driving and in particular from a standing start the 118d is as fast or faster than say 170 golf tdi. Ours was times with an OBD wiget GPS thingy at 8.2 sec 0-60, which isn't shabby at all...i think the 120d is somewhere in the region of 7.5 ish.
I know 0-60 times aren't everything, but i would say you be just as happy in a 118d with your ideal spec as you would in a 120d without...whatever you choose, you'll enjoy it!