M54B30 weird running, misfire and high oil use, related, hmm
M54B30 weird running, misfire and high oil use, related, hmm
Author
Discussion

Mr Whippy

Original Poster:

32,453 posts

272 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
Just had a phone call from the wife saying my Z4 is idling funny and even when revving it's sounding like a 5 cylinder or so... and the engine light has come on. So coils 2/5 were not right and need replacing.

Can two coils just go like that? I've had the odd weird running/idling issue over the last 12 months just for a few seconds then it's run fine again... so early signs of failure of coils?


It's been using a bit more oil than usual in the last 15k too... could this all be down to a bad coil on one or more cylinders, causing bad combustion, and perhaps no combustion in some cases and so lower cylinder pressure has been sucking oil back through past the mis-firing cylinder more?!


Ah well, will report back if it's impacted the oil consumption, maybe early signs of coil failure is poor combustion and increased oil use?! Hmmmmmm


Cheers

Dave

Edited by Mr Whippy on Friday 31st August 17:00


Edited by Mr Whippy on Friday 31st August 21:38

rumple

15,445 posts

182 months

Saturday 1st September 2012
quotequote all
When does it do this, when left idling when cold, how much oil is it using.

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Saturday 1st September 2012
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Just had a phone call from the wife saying my Z4 is idling funny and even when revving it's sounding like a 5 cylinder or so... and the engine light has come on. So coils 2/5 were not right and need replacing.

Can two coils just go like that? I've had the odd weird running/idling issue over the last 12 months just for a few seconds then it's run fine again... so early signs of failure of coils?
Yes, coils can "just go like that". They can pack up completely out of the blue or they can have a fault that slowly gets worse. There was a whole production batch of coils that were found to have a fault with their plastic bodies that caused them to crack and fail (which affected other car manufacturers as well).


Mr Whippy said:
It's been using a bit more oil than usual in the last 15k too... could this all be down to a bad coil on one or more cylinders, causing bad combustion, and perhaps no combustion in some cases and so lower cylinder pressure has been sucking oil back through past the mis-firing cylinder more?!


Ah well, will report back if it's impacted the oil consumption, maybe early signs of coil failure is poor combustion and increased oil use?! Hmmmmmm


Cheers

Dave
Can't see the lack of combustion being the cause of increased oil consumption as the combustion process does not assist the sealing of the cylinders.

The cylinders and pistons should be mechanically sealed by the piston rings, valves and spark plugs. (Try turning over an engine by hand with the engine off and all of the plugs still fitted - you'll find it extremely difficult as you're fighting the sealed cylinders).
The only way oil can enter the cylinder is if there is wear/damage to the pistons or piston rings, valves or valve guides, or the head gasket or cylinder head have a problem.

If your engine was capable of drawing oil into the cylinder due to no combustion, then based on the fact that oil is a lot thicker than a vaporised petrol mixed with air, it stands to reason that with the engine working properly, you would be pushing the fuel/air mixture out of the cylinder on the compression stroke prior to combustion, thus losing compression in that cylinder.

Be aware that the M54b30 is notorious for oil consumption issues due to wear created in the cylinder bores from the days when the engines were run in by their first owners, basically the were driven too cautiously for the engines own good, hence the reason why some cars suffer more than others.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
You've probably got 2 issues going on, coil packs for the misfire, I've before now had failing coil packs that start as intermitent misfires that clear themselves before they fail totally and CCV issues for the oil consumption.

Mr Whippy

Original Poster:

32,453 posts

272 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
Sorry I forgot to update on this.

2/5 coil packs had gone, so I managed to get 5 Bremi's for £22.50 each at GSF (will get a 6th and keep the others as spares just in case)

My car is on 102k and is an 04 model so a worthwhile investment to get them done.

INPA plugged in and cleared the faults.


Runs better now I think, I've developed my bum dyno very well over the years and it's certainly taken out some of weird notchiness that had begun to appear when changing partial input throttle states mainly... I was thinking VANOS was slowly getting sloppy but it now seems to just react right away again now, rather than sometimes think for a fraction of time.


MPG has gone up too I think, always hard to know for sure but considering the only real change is coil packs and the other improved behaviour I think that generally the car is running better for new ignition coils!



What is the CCV issue for oil consumption? Is it that breather circuit/swirl pot stuff?

Generally this car/engine has been an absolute dream to work on so I might just take it in bits down the nearside of the engine/manifold and clean whatever looks a bit dirty.



Cheers

Dave

tgr

1,256 posts

202 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
CCV is a crank case breather valve. When it gets blocked it's generally thought to cause increased oil consumption

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
Here's a brief explanation of what goes wrong from: http://www.dvatp.com/bmw/diy/icv_ccv/ (it's for an E36 M52 engine but the principal is the same):

The CCV also has two failure modes.

The most serious failure mode occurs during sub-freezing temperatures and is the result of a mixture of oil mist and condensate (water) combining and freezing the separator solid so it can't do it's job.

In the other failure mode the integral diaphragm in the CCV cracks and creates both a vacuum leak and a path for oil vapor to be sucked into the intake manifold and later burned. The result is usually a rough running engine and lots of blue smoke billowing from the exhaust. If this occurs it will most likely be associated with a check engine light (CEL) due to the vacuum leak and misfires that are the result of the contaminated fuel mixture.

In a worst case scenario, if sufficient oil is sucked into the manifold the result can be a hydrolocked engine and a very large repair bill.

From personal experience however, you don't necessarily get: "lots of blue smoke billowing from the exhaust", with burning oil (even though common sense says you should!). My E36 328i Sport burns @ 1 litre per 250~300 miles and only smokes a little up @ the red-line!

The E46 version is more complex to replace, here's what's involved: http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/showthread.php?t=...


Mr Whippy

Original Poster:

32,453 posts

272 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the post.

It looks like about £65 of bits and then a steady away afternoon replacing the old parts.


I'll be keeping an eye on the oil consumption but considering the age is 8yrs/100k miles now these parts probably could do with a change any way.


Thanks

Dave

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Thanks for the post.

It looks like about £65 of bits and then a steady away afternoon replacing the old parts.


I'll be keeping an eye on the oil consumption but considering the age is 8yrs/100k miles now these parts probably could do with a change any way.


Thanks

Dave
put it this way - It's not going to hurt to change them!

(Sadly, I'd got My hopes up that this would solve My oil consumption issues but it was still the same after the swap! - I did feel happy that I hadn't had to pay a mechanic to do the job though!)

Considering how much oil My car is using (1 litre for every 250 ~ 300miles! yikes), BMW are baffled as to why it doesn't smoke severely all the time! ( And when they get the car for anything, the technician always reports that the oil needs topping up and the service staff tell Me: "You haven't topped up your oil this week Mr ************, have you!", after 25 years, they know Me well! hehe )

Best of luck with it, hope it sorts your issue out! smile