E34 Shed. Should I go for it?
Discussion
Hi there,
I have been looking at an E34 520i Touring that is up for sale, close to where I live. From 1996, with 156k miles on the clock. Up for £800. I went to see and drive it, and it seemed like a good car. There is however one thing that stops me from making a decision. Rust.
I don't mind the aesthetic part, but people say you should avoid it like the plague. Why is that? The car is 16 years old, and covered 150k odd miles, so that's what you'd expect, right? Here in Belgium they throw salt on the roads in winter like you wouldn't believe, and it's been on the road here for all of it's life.
Anyway; Things I found:
- On the A-pillar, a piece a good inch long, rusting from the windshield.
- Exhaust muffler and it's mountings were pretty brownish.
- Didn't really look like actual rusting, but where the door-rubbers touch the door sill there is a bright orange 'strip'. (I should have looked a bit closer at that one, yes.)
However, suspension and steering parts at the front only had a slight brake-dust-like shade of brown to them. Looking in good, non-corroded shape.
Should I walk away on this base? I just can't make up if this is bad, or not a big deal. The car drives, looks and feels pretty good aside from that.
Pictures from the add:

What do you guys think? Maybe some E34-specific things I should know or check? Been browsing the web, but information is rather vague.
Thanks.
PS: I should add that I'm 21 years old, and this would be my first car that would be actually used on the road, as a daily. It's not just for the fun of it, so I would like to avoid big bills. On the other hand I like the idea of buying it, as it is a bit silly.
I have been looking at an E34 520i Touring that is up for sale, close to where I live. From 1996, with 156k miles on the clock. Up for £800. I went to see and drive it, and it seemed like a good car. There is however one thing that stops me from making a decision. Rust.
I don't mind the aesthetic part, but people say you should avoid it like the plague. Why is that? The car is 16 years old, and covered 150k odd miles, so that's what you'd expect, right? Here in Belgium they throw salt on the roads in winter like you wouldn't believe, and it's been on the road here for all of it's life.
Anyway; Things I found:
- On the A-pillar, a piece a good inch long, rusting from the windshield.
- Exhaust muffler and it's mountings were pretty brownish.
- Didn't really look like actual rusting, but where the door-rubbers touch the door sill there is a bright orange 'strip'. (I should have looked a bit closer at that one, yes.)
However, suspension and steering parts at the front only had a slight brake-dust-like shade of brown to them. Looking in good, non-corroded shape.
Should I walk away on this base? I just can't make up if this is bad, or not a big deal. The car drives, looks and feels pretty good aside from that.
Pictures from the add:

What do you guys think? Maybe some E34-specific things I should know or check? Been browsing the web, but information is rather vague.
Thanks.
PS: I should add that I'm 21 years old, and this would be my first car that would be actually used on the road, as a daily. It's not just for the fun of it, so I would like to avoid big bills. On the other hand I like the idea of buying it, as it is a bit silly.
Edited by cure on Friday 31st August 20:10
Looks nice! I think you should go back armed with some cash, but only hand it over after you have thoroughly examined the rust and satisfied yourself it isn't terminal. The sill jacking points go bad very quickly. Bid low, they'll probably be dying to shift it.
Check the double sunroof works if fitted
Switch the lights on and make sure you don't get any light warnings on the dash
How fast did you drive it? These are prone to wobble suspension which tends to manifest itself between 50 and 60 mph
Check the double sunroof works if fitted
Switch the lights on and make sure you don't get any light warnings on the dash
How fast did you drive it? These are prone to wobble suspension which tends to manifest itself between 50 and 60 mph
Double sunroof is fitted, and working. The motor for the drivers' side rear window is broken though, but I don't really mind. I read about the wobbling bit after I test drove it, and I didn't reach 50 mph, so I should check that again. Jacking points are something I forgot about, thanks.
On the dash warning lights; All lights are off, but I don't know what the yellow/green/red light cluster in the middle is for, so I can't make any of it. Is this explained somewhere? It's a car without the board computer next to the radio by the way, so no things to read-out from that.
On the dash warning lights; All lights are off, but I don't know what the yellow/green/red light cluster in the middle is for, so I can't make any of it. Is this explained somewhere? It's a car without the board computer next to the radio by the way, so no things to read-out from that.
cure said:
Double sunroof is fitted, and working. The motor for the drivers' side rear window is broken though, but I don't really mind. I read about the wobbling bit after I test drove it, and I didn't reach 50 mph, so I should check that again. Jacking points are something I forgot about, thanks.
On the dash warning lights; All lights are off, but I don't know what the yellow/green/red light cluster in the middle is for, so I can't make any of it. Is this explained somewhere? It's a car without the board computer next to the radio by the way, so no things to read-out from that.
Do check for the wobble. I didn't on my 525i touring and it will cost me- I'm putting it off until I can afford the time/money, but the wobble is killing my balljoints as well now!On the dash warning lights; All lights are off, but I don't know what the yellow/green/red light cluster in the middle is for, so I can't make any of it. Is this explained somewhere? It's a car without the board computer next to the radio by the way, so no things to read-out from that.
The sunroofs aren't supposed to be delicate but they need to be used regularly and lubricated occasionally.
Neither of my rear electric windows worked when I got the car. The solution? Slam the doors a few times! The weather strips had gotten a bit stuck and both windows now work.
The jacking points will look nasty and out of shape because of poor design but if there is structural rust there, walk away.
The line of green/amber/red lights is the service indicator. All lights illuminated after starting- the service indicator has been re-set (car should be freshly serviced). Only the red illuminated means service overdue.
P.S. I'm 23 by the way! Old Beemers with round headlights are cool I reckon, and they aren't getting any cheaper or more plentiful, so it's a good time to buy a good one.
Edited by HustleRussell on Saturday 1st September 14:37
£800 might be a touch steep, but then again a new one is over 30 grand. E34's can rot badly on the sills if it has the plastic sill covers. These were standard on SE's from around late 1994. Black leather is nice, so is the manual box and lack of self levelling (unless it was optioned). It's got imperial sized tyres. The Vanos 520i isn't too slow and it should be a tough and reliable old s
tter. The double sunroof wants liberal greasing and sparing use! If it goes tits up (and they do), you'll be sealing it shut with gaffa tape. E34's generally have shagged front dampers and bushes but are otherwise a tough car.
I'd have a good look around it and if it's sound, wave £650 around and see what that achieves.
tter. The double sunroof wants liberal greasing and sparing use! If it goes tits up (and they do), you'll be sealing it shut with gaffa tape. E34's generally have shagged front dampers and bushes but are otherwise a tough car.I'd have a good look around it and if it's sound, wave £650 around and see what that achieves.
The sills are difficult to see because of the plastic sill covers, but you should check the rear wheel arches inside the rear doors. Also push hard with a penknife on the rust areas where the door has been touching the sill. check that the rear window support springs still support the window which opens independently of the whole tailgate.E34 tourers are great cars and last for ever if looked after.
Edited by griffhnter on Saturday 1st September 17:27
The rust on the A-pillar would be an issue...what you can see will be the tip of the iceberg...expect a totally rotten windscreen mounting lip...potential leak into the cabin and resulting floor corrosion (lift the footwell carpets) and water in the kickwells which is where the central locking relay and audio speakers are.
The double sunroofs can fail...usually in the open position...Lovely to have and use when working, but don't be surprised if it gets stuck open...just as you try and close it during a downpour!
The big electrical issue is chafed wires in the tailgate hinges (especially the right hand one) leading to non-opening or malfunctioning tailgate glass release and often shorting out the lighting loom leading to random strange light related issues and it can kill the lighting module under the back seat.
The 520i has the "low" dashboard, so dead pixels are less of an issue...The service indicator strip should extinguish entirely when reset..If it doesn't, then a new dash module is the usual fix, but you may be able to resurrect it by soldering in a new battery.
The only real mechanical issue is the waterpump...originals are plastic impeller (on a metal shaft) and are prone to fracturing sending shards of plastic into your cooling system...change for an aftermarket metal impeller type ASAP...
The steering shimmy (or front suspension wobble) is just worn front wishbone rubbers and lower ball joints...fairly easy to fix cheaply.
Rear suspension needs to be checked for beam/subframe mounting bush wear (leading to a loose and vague feel to the rear end)...also check/change the dogbone locator links as the wear out circa 100K miles.
The Tourings were usually fitted with SLS...check for leaks from the rear strut toweres/dampers as they are expensive to replace...Also check the condition of the front to rear pressure pipes (runs from the rear of the PAS pump) and the accumulator spheres above the rear beam, near the diff.
The double sunroofs can fail...usually in the open position...Lovely to have and use when working, but don't be surprised if it gets stuck open...just as you try and close it during a downpour!
The big electrical issue is chafed wires in the tailgate hinges (especially the right hand one) leading to non-opening or malfunctioning tailgate glass release and often shorting out the lighting loom leading to random strange light related issues and it can kill the lighting module under the back seat.
The 520i has the "low" dashboard, so dead pixels are less of an issue...The service indicator strip should extinguish entirely when reset..If it doesn't, then a new dash module is the usual fix, but you may be able to resurrect it by soldering in a new battery.
The only real mechanical issue is the waterpump...originals are plastic impeller (on a metal shaft) and are prone to fracturing sending shards of plastic into your cooling system...change for an aftermarket metal impeller type ASAP...
The steering shimmy (or front suspension wobble) is just worn front wishbone rubbers and lower ball joints...fairly easy to fix cheaply.
Rear suspension needs to be checked for beam/subframe mounting bush wear (leading to a loose and vague feel to the rear end)...also check/change the dogbone locator links as the wear out circa 100K miles.
The Tourings were usually fitted with SLS...check for leaks from the rear strut toweres/dampers as they are expensive to replace...Also check the condition of the front to rear pressure pipes (runs from the rear of the PAS pump) and the accumulator spheres above the rear beam, near the diff.
The 24v 520i (and 518i) don't have pixels in the cluster apart from the gearshift selector on Autos.. They had a unique cluster with the digital mileage in the segment at the base of the speedo and for some reason they seem to be the least reliable, suffering from the same total failure as E36 units.
520i's didn't have SLS so pray that the first owner didn't spec it as an option!
For £800 it's not worth worrying about the little rusty bits. If you can get a couple of years reliable use from it before selling it on Ebay for 200 quid, you've done well.
520i's didn't have SLS so pray that the first owner didn't spec it as an option!
For £800 it's not worth worrying about the little rusty bits. If you can get a couple of years reliable use from it before selling it on Ebay for 200 quid, you've done well.
Ok, so I've taken it for a bigger drive today, and visited the BMW-dealership. They had a quick look around and concluded that for 800 pounds I shouldn't worry to much, and just have things repaired if they should go wrong. Is that the way to go? Sounds a bit optimistic to me. At least the rear windows were indeed repaired by slamming the doors.
They could tell me the rubbers in the suspension bits and rear sub-frame are pretty worn-out, which is to expect. It does feel very vague when driving around. Comfy, but it doesn't send much information to me. Are new rubbers at certain places going change that, or am I expecting too much? Compared to it, my dads' (newish) astra feels like it turns in like a ferrari so to speak. (OTR: That astra isn't a bad car.) I would like to replace those if it is possible to do that myself, and if it really makes a difference. I fear I might get bored of the chassis by the time I get used to the lovely sound of the straight six.
The good bit it is it doesn't wobble. There is one very short period where it wants to start wobbling if you're really looking for it, but doesn't seem like something to worry about.
And last but not least; It's got SLS, and the window in the bootlid doesn't respond to the opening switch at all. Run?
They could tell me the rubbers in the suspension bits and rear sub-frame are pretty worn-out, which is to expect. It does feel very vague when driving around. Comfy, but it doesn't send much information to me. Are new rubbers at certain places going change that, or am I expecting too much? Compared to it, my dads' (newish) astra feels like it turns in like a ferrari so to speak. (OTR: That astra isn't a bad car.) I would like to replace those if it is possible to do that myself, and if it really makes a difference. I fear I might get bored of the chassis by the time I get used to the lovely sound of the straight six.
The good bit it is it doesn't wobble. There is one very short period where it wants to start wobbling if you're really looking for it, but doesn't seem like something to worry about.
And last but not least; It's got SLS, and the window in the bootlid doesn't respond to the opening switch at all. Run?
Edited by cure on Friday 7th September 17:30
It's just £800! Do or do not; there is no try.
Bushes are various amounts of hassle. Worst of the lot are the pair of rear beam 'beercan' bushes, but once replaced with polyurethane - done forever.
No it might not turn in like the Astra, what do you expect? It's 400Kg heavier. Even so, a good E34 can be hustled like you definitely would not believe, and will be a nicer place to be on long journeys. Still fine cars, hewn from granite - and often abused/neglected because of this TBH. A car to build a long-term relationship around - a little attention now and it'll still be running in another 20years.
If that's not for you, buy some other snotter with the £800.
Bushes are various amounts of hassle. Worst of the lot are the pair of rear beam 'beercan' bushes, but once replaced with polyurethane - done forever.
No it might not turn in like the Astra, what do you expect? It's 400Kg heavier. Even so, a good E34 can be hustled like you definitely would not believe, and will be a nicer place to be on long journeys. Still fine cars, hewn from granite - and often abused/neglected because of this TBH. A car to build a long-term relationship around - a little attention now and it'll still be running in another 20years.
If that's not for you, buy some other snotter with the £800.
Edited by Huff on Friday 7th September 21:48
Well, 800 pounds is indeed nothing to worry about, but as a poor student it would not be welcome to have bills as big as that every month. That would be something to worry about. I'm aware it is a heavy estate, not a sportscar, but I can expect some sharpness from the steering, right? I'm not saying it doesn't corner. It still does what you ask from it. It just doesn't tell you. I'll bet on some new bushings and see what I get for it. I'm going to buy the car anyway as I've started to like it too much. Fingers crossed it doesn't start falling apart. Thanks for the info on the E34 - that's what I was looking for after all.
Steering - no at best it will feel a little, shall we say, quiet. Not actually lacking in feel or communication its just rather more heavily damped than rack&pinion. This was a deliberate choice by BMW in terms of NVH, and in fact it is also what makes the car so nice on long journeys.
BTW even when new, 3-6mm of light play at the steering wheel rim is normal owing to finite clearances in the steering box. This doesn't get in the way of enjoying driving it though. Older cars will have more, most of it can be trimmed-out with care but if your prospective example has inches of play - leave it and find another.
I do hope you enjoy it - if you have any particular problems there is a wealth of good info here via the search button
(I'm into my 5th year with a 540, and have no plans to sell it!)
BTW even when new, 3-6mm of light play at the steering wheel rim is normal owing to finite clearances in the steering box. This doesn't get in the way of enjoying driving it though. Older cars will have more, most of it can be trimmed-out with care but if your prospective example has inches of play - leave it and find another.
I do hope you enjoy it - if you have any particular problems there is a wealth of good info here via the search button

(I'm into my 5th year with a 540, and have no plans to sell it!)
Edited by Huff on Friday 7th September 23:01
Most steering wheel play on E34's is due to the 32mm nut at the base of the steering column needing a tighten. It's where the upper and lower columns join on a ssliding splined section so the column can adjust in and out. Give that nut a good tighten and that makes a hell of a difference.
As for suspension, only the axle beam bushes are really worth bothering with.
As for suspension, only the axle beam bushes are really worth bothering with.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


