Winter Run Flats?
Winter Run Flats?
Author
Discussion

andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Saturday 1st September 2012
quotequote all
Hi everyone.

Apologies for this thread as I must be asking an often repeated question but having searched the site I haven't seen the answer I was looking for.

My query is this:- I am about to order a set of winter wheels and tyres and have done some research into what options I have. Basically, I've narrowed it down to two choices, option 1 is to get Goodyear winter runflats and a separate set of wheels then have them fitted to the wheels by a tyre shop, totally something like £750 to £800 by the time they're fitted. The other option is to get a similar Goodyear tyre but in non run-flat form which will cost me £600 as a set and I'll fit them to the car myself, saving £200. I am pretty sure I'm just going to go for the non run-flats and see how I get on but wanted to see what other people's experiences are.

I am quite keen to change away from run-flats as I'm beginning to dislike them quite a lot after 6 months of owning the car. My only real concern is what happens if I puncture one with no spare. Is there a roadside repair kit worth buying? Not a fill-it-with-goo type kit, more a get-you-home type thing should I get a flat. I can't carry a spare in the boot so that's not an option really but don't know the ins and outs of the repair kits.

For the life of me, I can't see what's wrong with normal tyres and carrying a spare in a wheel well, but I knew this before I opted for a BMW so there's no point me complaining now! smile

I've disregarded putting run flat winters on the "summer" wheels as there is only one tyre I can find to fit the 17" rears on my car and the set will cost me a fraction less then having a spare set of wheels and tyres.

Any help would be great. smile

Thanks.

Andy

Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Saturday 1st September 2012
quotequote all
andyp79 said:
Hi everyone.

Apologies for this thread as I must be asking an often repeated question but having searched the site I haven't seen the answer I was looking for.

My query is this:- I am about to order a set of winter wheels and tyres and have done some research into what options I have. Basically, I've narrowed it down to two choices, option 1 is to get Goodyear winter runflats and a separate set of wheels then have them fitted to the wheels by a tyre shop, totally something like £750 to £800 by the time they're fitted. The other option is to get a similar Goodyear tyre but in non run-flat form which will cost me £600 as a set and I'll fit them to the car myself, saving £200. I am pretty sure I'm just going to go for the non run-flats and see how I get on but wanted to see what other people's experiences are.

I am quite keen to change away from run-flats as I'm beginning to dislike them quite a lot after 6 months of owning the car. My only real concern is what happens if I puncture one with no spare. Is there a roadside repair kit worth buying? Not a fill-it-with-goo type kit, more a get-you-home type thing should I get a flat. I can't carry a spare in the boot so that's not an option really but don't know the ins and outs of the repair kits.

For the life of me, I can't see what's wrong with normal tyres and carrying a spare in a wheel well, but I knew this before I opted for a BMW so there's no point me complaining now! smile

I've disregarded putting run flat winters on the "summer" wheels as there is only one tyre I can find to fit the 17" rears on my car and the set will cost me a fraction less then having a spare set of wheels and tyres.

Any help would be great. smile

Thanks.

Andy
Went through this last year - ended up with a set of S/H BMW Alloys off Ebay which was cheaper than buying Steelies (there are loads of BMW wheels for sale on there) and the Goodyear winter runflats. They are nicer to drive on than the summer Bridgestone RFs - go figure.

Cost some money but the S/H wheels kept the cost down & over 3-4 years the difference will be negligible. They are in my garage ready for this winter & the cost is long since forgotten anyway.

andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Saturday 1st September 2012
quotequote all
I did have this option in mind too but I wrote it off (so to speak) when I started to find it hard to understand what size / fit of wheels to go for.

It should be a case of just going for 16-17" BMW wheels right? Will older ones fit - E46 etc.? I have prepared myself to spend £600-£700 for this so maybe it's worth looking at the second hand alloy option...

I think I'll try to find some on eBay before I commit to ordering the steelies.

Thanks. smile

Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Saturday 1st September 2012
quotequote all
andyp79 said:
I did have this option in mind too but I wrote it off (so to speak) when I started to find it hard to understand what size / fit of wheels to go for.

It should be a case of just going for 16-17" BMW wheels right? Will older ones fit - E46 etc.? I have prepared myself to spend £600-£700 for this so maybe it's worth looking at the second hand alloy option...

I think I'll try to find some on eBay before I commit to ordering the steelies.

Thanks. smile
Not sure what car you've got but on mine there is a plate in the door shut that lists all the wheel/tyre combos for the E90

I just bought a set of standard E90 16" wheels - same as were on it for the summer tyres so it was fairly easy.

andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
It's an E90 318d but it's on the standard 17" M Sport alloys which seem to wear unusual size tyres.

There's bound to be the same info on the door plate on mine then. I thought it just had tyre pressures so it never even occurred to me to look there!

Cheers.

smile

andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
It's an E90 318d but it's on the standard 17" M Sport alloys which seem to wear unusual size tyres.

There's bound to be the same info on the door plate on mine then. I thought it just had tyre pressures so it never even occurred to me to look there!

Cheers.

smile

Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
andyp79 said:
It's an E90 318d but it's on the standard 17" M Sport alloys which seem to wear unusual size tyres.

There's bound to be the same info on the door plate on mine then. I thought it just had tyre pressures so it never even occurred to me to look there!

Cheers.

smile
Nothing to stop you putting 16s on it for the winter - standard fitment is 205x55x16. If you want winter tyres in the first place then narrower is probably marginally better anyway (and they will be cheaper than the 17s)

andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Yip. 205 16s seem to be the best call.

I've put a bid in on a set of spare alloys that bd tomorrow. Will see how it goes!

Thanks for the help. smile

aeropilot

40,914 posts

258 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
andyp79 said:
My only real concern is what happens if I puncture one with no spare. Is there a roadside repair kit worth buying? Not a fill-it-with-goo type kit, more a get-you-home type thing should I get a flat.
I'm not sure what you mean by a 'get-you-home' type thing?

You have only two options.

Chucking an appropiate BMW space saver in the boot.

Or....

Buying a BMW Mobility kit (or similar non-BMW one) which is essentially the fill-it-with-goo type kit that you describe.


andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I was thinking of the goo you put in the tyre in advance of getting a puncture that seals the hole when it appears. I have ended up buying a set of steels and non run-flat tyres so will look at theses options now. The space saver might well be the winner. Then I can replace the run-flats altogether as they definitely drive strangely.

Thanks.

Andy

Lefty

21,615 posts

233 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Are you going to keep run flats for your summer tyres?

andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
I think having looked at it now that I'm just going to get a small jack, brace and "mobility kit" and eventually junk the run-flats altogether. I will get a fair bit more out of the "summer" tyres before they're goosed. Will get the tyre kit sorted out ahead of fitting the winters and see how I get on. If the summer ones are still going come the Spring I'll just wear them out then go for non run-flats when they're done for.

I did prefer the space saver idea, but having read up on them I reckon the mobility kit and tools is a better plan. Still think the whole run-flat thing is daft to be honest.


LeoSayer

7,865 posts

275 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Runflats are arguably more useful in winter than summer, as it means you don't need to freeze your nuts off changing a wheel or waiting for recovery while it is dark, cold and possibly snowing.

If you've got space in the boot for a space saver wheel then buy one.

aeropilot

40,914 posts

258 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
LeoSayer said:
Runflats are arguably more useful in winter than summer, as it means you don't need to freeze your nuts off changing a wheel or waiting for recovery while it is dark, cold and possibly snowing.
Only if they are proper 'winter' tread run flats, such as Pirelli Sotto Zero.

'Ordinary' RFT's are even more useless in winter than they are in summer, due to the lack of give with the ultra stiff sidewalls.



andyp79

Original Poster:

385 posts

206 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
I did consider that sort of thing but the choice was so limited (and expensive) from what I could find that I figured the best bet was to get away from the RFTs.

I'll look at the space saver option properly before I commit to anything more. This tyre thing was the main problem I could foresee with buying a recent BM... and it does seem to have become one. If the car had a wheel well, the problem wouldn't exist. frown

If I can get a setup I'm happy with, the summer RFTs will be canned also when they've worn out.