Considering E36 328, 3.0 M3, 3.2 M3, E46 M3, E39 540
Discussion
I'm seriously considering going back to a BMW. I had an E36 328 and I liked it. Comfy, nice engine note, decent performance and quite good handling for its size. I've since gone through an MR2T, Primera GT, an MX5 and now a Clio 172, but now I'm yearning to be back in a BMW for its all round ability.
Low depreciation now and reasonable to buy, they've got a lot to offer a petrolhead with their all round ability and sonorous engines.
So here are my options, and how I see them.
E36 328 - Yes, revisit my old car, but this time with the 325 manifold, throttle body and remap. Cheaper running costs than an M3, and, I'm guessing, not much slower than a 3.0 M3.
E36 M3 3.0 - Nice slug of extra power over my old 328 (actually near 50%). Higher reliability and lower running costs than the Evo. Closer than you think on paper to an Evo?
E36 M3 Evo - More power and revviness, better handling, a properly fast car, E46 M3 rivalling power. The E36 to have, really. More expensive to buy, run and insure than the 3.0 for only another 10% power?
E46 M3 - These are creeping down to £6-£7k now. The best M3 since the E30, and maybe not surpassed even now? However, they must be dogs for this kind of cost, and no doubt even more expensive to run.
E39 540 - Comfort, power, torque, looks, and interior, but most importantly, a V8 noise. Very thirsty though, but on the upside, probably less to insure than the M3, and less likely to be thrashed.
What would you recommend?
Low depreciation now and reasonable to buy, they've got a lot to offer a petrolhead with their all round ability and sonorous engines.
So here are my options, and how I see them.
E36 328 - Yes, revisit my old car, but this time with the 325 manifold, throttle body and remap. Cheaper running costs than an M3, and, I'm guessing, not much slower than a 3.0 M3.
E36 M3 3.0 - Nice slug of extra power over my old 328 (actually near 50%). Higher reliability and lower running costs than the Evo. Closer than you think on paper to an Evo?
E36 M3 Evo - More power and revviness, better handling, a properly fast car, E46 M3 rivalling power. The E36 to have, really. More expensive to buy, run and insure than the 3.0 for only another 10% power?
E46 M3 - These are creeping down to £6-£7k now. The best M3 since the E30, and maybe not surpassed even now? However, they must be dogs for this kind of cost, and no doubt even more expensive to run.
E39 540 - Comfort, power, torque, looks, and interior, but most importantly, a V8 noise. Very thirsty though, but on the upside, probably less to insure than the M3, and less likely to be thrashed.
What would you recommend?
E46 M3 for me, for me the best looking car they ever made, if not an E36 M3, which one would depend on condition, and my opinion is as nice as they are an 3.0 M3 would have a 328 for breakfast, its faster, better brakes, better suspension,better everything, a modded 328 would touch one, unless you did some sort of forced induction then you'd end up retrofitting M3 bits antway to cope with the power.
I think out of the lot you will find the 540i very big and heavy, its a totally different car to the rest. Well the M cars mainly.
I love mine, but I'm 25 and wish it was one of the others!
Try and get an M car, depends what you want to spend really. Your list ranges from £500 to ~£15k+!
I love mine, but I'm 25 and wish it was one of the others!
Try and get an M car, depends what you want to spend really. Your list ranges from £500 to ~£15k+!
Depending on who you listen to, most Evos in at the cheaper end of the market dont make stock power by a fair margin, while the non Evo 286bhp engine doesn't suffer as badly.
Any E36 M3 is in a different league to a 328i performance wise. Like night and day, in fact.
An E46 at that sort of money would be a risky proposition indeed.
A well looked after Evo with recent Vanos overhaul and evidence of the tappets being done would be lovely, but will, on average, cost slightly more to run than a non Evo. Standard decent ones for sensible money are getting hard to find now as well.
If you can get the right Evo, with the work done, then thats where my money would go , and failing that a non Evo model.
I wouldnt compare a 540i with those, good though they are.
The M3s can be surprisingly good on fuel as well!
Any E36 M3 is in a different league to a 328i performance wise. Like night and day, in fact.
An E46 at that sort of money would be a risky proposition indeed.
A well looked after Evo with recent Vanos overhaul and evidence of the tappets being done would be lovely, but will, on average, cost slightly more to run than a non Evo. Standard decent ones for sensible money are getting hard to find now as well.
If you can get the right Evo, with the work done, then thats where my money would go , and failing that a non Evo model.
I wouldnt compare a 540i with those, good though they are.
The M3s can be surprisingly good on fuel as well!
TameRacingDriver said:
E39 540 - Comfort, power, torque, looks, and interior, but most importantly, a V8 noise. Very thirsty though, but on the upside, probably less to insure than the M3, and less likely to be thrashed.
What would you recommend?
You won't get a nice V8 noise on the standard exhaust so budget for an upgrade.What would you recommend?
Insurance for me was peanuts on the 540, about half that of a quote on an e46 M3
I owned from new an E36 328, M3 Evo and E46 M3 (the joys of being single).....of those cars I would order them E46 M3, E36 328 and E36 Evo. The E46 M3 is streets ahead of the Evo IMHO.....much better chassis and the engine is just different gravy too. The E36 328 is great car...better all round package for the money at the time than the Evo.
I still reckon I could be happy with a 328, as long as it had the breathing mods, as one thing I felt was that my old one felt a little strangled at the top end, which apparently is because of the restrictive breathing? Even so, it still wasn't exactly "slow", it used to keep pace with my mates old (standard) Megane R26, and did a 14.2 quarter mile at Bruntingthorpe Proving Ground.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


