BMW mpg figures
BMW mpg figures
Author
Discussion

mattwatson

Original Poster:

45 posts

176 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Ok so there are a few things I would like to address in this topic.

1. specifically bmw petrol vs diesel mpg achieved

2. bmw claimed mpg figures Vs other manufacturers

So firstly, I think it is generally accepted that with most bmw diesels with a good amount of motorway/mixed driving you can achieve on average 10% less than the reported figures over a period of time.

For example my e46 320cd claims to achieve 49mpg combined but in reality with a good mix of driving I see 44mpg which very rarely varies from this.

So what do the petrol engines achieve? (I know it is a very general question but I did not have any experience of to comment). I would appreciate input from people who do a good mixture of driving i.e. a few short ish commutes to work during the week but also some considerable motorway journeys.

Example an e46 320ci claims 31mpg combined. Does the 'take the 10% off' apply or not?

Secondly, bmw vs other mnufacturers. Example as follows (figures taken from Parkers)

BMW e90 320d - 58mpg combined.
Audi A5 2.0 tdi quattro - 55mpg.

Based on 10% theory above I could expect to see 53mpg from the e90 (taking of the 10%) but what about the Audi, do they perform more realistically than a bmw? is there reported 55mpg more achievable in the real world?

The same goes for other manufacturers are they more realistic with their mpg figures? For example the Jaguar XF 2.2d is a comparable engine in terms of performace and reportably achives 52mpg combined. Is this the case? Or again does the 10% theory apply?

What I am trying to get at is are all manufacturers equally misleading in their mpg figures or are BMW worse than others? lets face it MPG is a very important factor when buying a car for most people in the current climate.

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Remember all MPG figures are worked out by measuring exhaust emissions in a laboratory when engines are warm. Realistically, you should only ever use the 'urban' mpg as what you will achieve in the real world.
My old A6 2.7tdi, was meant to get 45mpg. it NEVER did more than 38 - and the 'urban' value was 36mpg (i think!)
however, my current 330i E91, gets around 32-34 and the official is 37, but my theory of 'urban' stats goes out the window because its urban value is around 27...
I seem to find in general that it is easier to get nearer with petrol driving normally than with a diesel. Plus, with a bigger petrol engine, it is much easier to exceed the combined mpg with a very steady right foot and a loooooooong drive. My record is 41 from Salisbury to Ely!
I could also add that in a brief 30 minute test drive of the new 328i engine, I managed to see 46mpg...just such a pity it sounds like S-IT!

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
You can hit any claimed MPG figure in any car if you drive to achieve it.This means you have to drive really easy and be as smooth as possible,lifting off at the right spots and very light braking,planning well ahead so you don't have to stop at all.Plus a million other things to take into consideration.
I've hit and exceeded the claimed figures in my car but it's not very fun driving at all to be fair,it's a chore.
Once you use the cars power and get on boost(turbo engines) you can chuck those figures in the bin because you will blow the claimed MPG to pieces.

In the real world we all don't drive like this so whilst it's possible to get the claimed figures,it's not how we always drive so expect lower.

Sam.F

1,145 posts

231 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
It depends a lot on the sort of journeys you're doing I find - I had a colleague who was running a 330Ci between Carlisle and Newcastle who averaged 38mpg because all he was doing was tootling to and fro across the A69, whereas if I was driving the same car my average would be more like 20mpg because almost all my driving is either stop-start town stuff or, erm, making progress.

FWIW I think you'll find the "10%" idea is less reliable in the newer BMWs as they all have the Eco-gubbins these days - my OH's 116d has a combined of 62.8mpg but the only way you can get close to that is on a gentle A-road run, it drops to mid-30s around town.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
E39 528i SE steptronic.

35-40 mpg on a run usually always over 35 if motorways are involved

20-25 mpg around town

15-20 mpg in traffic

Run it on V Power most of the time.

clockworks

7,818 posts

176 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
When I was doing 40k a year in repmobiles, I used to end up a little higher than the combined figure. Same seems to be holding true now that I've taken early retirement, and drive a lot less - with one exception. Before I got bored, and bought the E60 and 964, I spent 2 years driving a Fiat Qubo 1.3 diesel. I averaged just under 50mpg, which is a fair bit less than the combined figure. The problem was, it was so slow, I had to thrash it everywhere! The only car I've owned where the economy on a run was worse than when I was just doing local journeys. Very poor aero, I guess.

varsas

4,077 posts

233 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
I'm slightly over the figure on my E36 328i manual, claimed 30.7 combined I get more like 32. Last month I gut 500 miles or 36mpg out of a tank due to the hot weather and kids being off school. My commute in the morning is 10 miles, no motorway, 7 miles of 50mph roads with two 30mph villages either end, just driving normally. I get 35+ on the motorway.

I used to get 36 on my drive to work and 40+ on the motorway in my 2 litre Vectra B, which is, again, a bit better then the book says (33 combined and 45 extra urban).

I would be very disappointed with 31mpg out of an E46 320i given that the E46 is more aerodynamic then my car and the engine is more advanced (with dual vanos etc)...also the capacity decrease should help a bit shouldn't it? I was hoping for 34mpg out of my 330ci when I upgrade.



Edited by varsas on Thursday 6th September 22:59

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

210 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
BMW diesel = claimed EU mpg -25%
BMW turbo petrol = claimed EU mpg - 20%
BMW normally aspirated petrol = claimed EU mpg + 20%

mattwatson

Original Poster:

45 posts

176 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
pilchardthecat said:
BMW diesel = claimed EU mpg -25%
BMW turbo petrol = claimed EU mpg - 20%
BMW normally aspirated petrol = claimed EU mpg + 20%
Interesting - where you got the figures from?

contracttor

922 posts

216 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
pilchardthecat said:
BMW diesel = claimed EU mpg -25%
BMW turbo petrol = claimed EU mpg - 20%
BMW normally aspirated petrol = claimed EU mpg + 20%
Speaking from experience, your NA figures are way out (well they are for my V10) smile

MattOz

4,021 posts

295 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
My 330d's (I've had a few) would range from 40-42 mpg on average. My 535d was 32mpg. Surprisingly, my M3 averages over 27mpg. Mostly motorway and A roads. Only about 20% urban. I'd say that single turbo diesel matched the claimed outputs for the car, E46 and early E90. The 535d didn't, and the M3 is about 3mpg better than the official combined.

the_kato

411 posts

218 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
320cd averages 40.6 which is a long way off the claimed 49mpg

mboon

955 posts

233 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
200 mile trip in a E46 330i Saloon with toys and leather. Trip computer said around 35mpg but not sure i reset it. I got home and someoneworked out how much fuel I used to miles etc and it was over 40 mpg.

My old E36 M3 Evo convertible with the roof down at 80 was showing 36mpg on the computer

Interested in this as looking to buy a 5 diesel.

Animal

5,670 posts

299 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
E60 545i - 34.4mpg at the motorway limit over 225 miles up to Yorkshire Dales last week. Enthusiastic driving for 3 days up there and a fast cruise home (m'ways again) gave 28.8mpg indicated for 720 miles.

Peak and average speeds sadly not recorded.

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
OK - I keep a 'sad bd' spreadsheet which covers all the fuel and mileage for my cars going back a few years. I don't know why I've kept it up, I guess I am just that saddo hehe

Model & year(Man/Auto) BMW figures Actual Average Total miles Years owned
2001 - E46 320d Touring(M5) 47.8mpg 37.591mpg 21,434 2.02
2003 - E46 320d Touring(M6) 47.8mpg 37.776mpg 7,981 0.87
2005 - E87 130i(M) 30.7mpg 23.285mpg 17,021 2.83
2005 - E83 X3 2.0d(M) 39.2mpg 30.553mpg 59,549 5.21
2008 - E83 X3 3.0d(A) 36.7mpg 27.649mpg 11,970 1.13


Use of the cars tends to be loads of short(under 20 miles) journeys with the occasional(once a month) long (100 miles+) one thrown in. Annual trips include a 1500 mile round trip for a rally in Scotland and a skiing trip to the Alps - also there are regular events where I have the engine running for approx 15 mins in an hour and the car stationary - charging the battery for radio use.

Remember, this is a whole life average, not a snap shot or OBC read-out. From this I judge that when someone says they're getting 40mpg from a 3.0d it really means that they saw the numbers on the OBC once - reality is quite different.

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

210 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
contracttor said:
pilchardthecat said:
BMW diesel = claimed EU mpg -25%
BMW turbo petrol = claimed EU mpg - 20%
BMW normally aspirated petrol = claimed EU mpg + 20%
Speaking from experience, your NA figures are way out (well they are for my V10) smile
I've been doing the same round-trip 60 mile commute for ever. Those are the actual numbers for 123d, 135i and Z4M respectively.

mattwatson

Original Poster:

45 posts

176 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
the_kato said:
320cd averages 40.6 which is a long way off the claimed 49mpg
As I said I quite easily average 45mpg when doing regular motorway journeys (and the warmer weather helps 2-3mpg)

mike325112

1,074 posts

215 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
Ranger 6 said:
Remember, this is a whole life average, not a snap shot or OBC read-out. From this I judge that when someone says they're getting 40mpg from a 3.0d it really means that they saw the numbers on the OBC once - reality is quite different.
I get a real world average of 43mpg from my manual E46 330d, it lives on fast roads though my average mph is around 35 mph. I get around 40 in the winter and 46 in the summer. So it can be done, although I realise that my comute is very favourable for a large diesel, I dont hang around though.

Intrestingly I also get about 33mpg out of our manual 3.0d X3 it also does about 25mpg towing a 1500kg caravan.

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
How do you measure that? Brim to brim figures on a spreadsheet or OBC?

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
BMW Z4 3.0si Coupe

Average - 28.22 mpg (over 8,512 miles)
High - 35.93 mpg
Low - 14.62 mpg (that was a good day!)

All done on Tesco Momentum. Happy with the economy for a 3 litre if I'm honest, but I didn't really buy it for the economy.... smile

ETA - MPG per Parkers is 32mpg (no idea if that's same as BMW?) - so within 4 mpg, I will take that!

Edited by miln0039 on Friday 7th September 16:50