535d or 530d?
535d or 530d?
Author
Discussion

wavydavy

Original Poster:

16 posts

195 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Not sure if this subject has been raised before as the search function's not working....

I'm going all sensible and getting rid of my 650 Sport convertible in favour of going back to a diesel 5-series. I've found a great low mileage 530d M Sport on a '59 plate and another low mileage 535d M Sport on an '09 plate, both AUC and both priced within £500 of each other. I've had a couple of 530d's before so know what I'm getting there but have never driven a 535d. Question is therefore is the performance of the 535d noticibly different to the 530d and the one to go for?

ajb85

1,124 posts

173 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Yes, there's a noticeable performance difference in my opinion. From the off, imagine a 530d on full boost with no lag, that's how a 535d feels.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
I cannot imagine either of these cars are cheap. Wrong side of £20k which is simply silly money to be spending on an E60. You can nearly get into an F10 for that sort of money and it's a better car in every way.

wavydavy

Original Poster:

16 posts

195 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
I cannot imagine either of these cars are cheap. Wrong side of £20k which is simply silly money to be spending on an E60. You can nearly get into an F10 for that sort of money and it's a better car in every way.
Hi Fox, just slightly north of £20k.... equivalent AUC F10 530d M Sports are another £8-9k minimum which is a big chunk extra.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
I'd have an F10 SE over an E60 M Sport every day of the week, mind. £20k+ just seems like so much money to spend on a car of which fundamentally similar examples (Not that I am suggesting them as alternatives, just as an illustration) now pop up regularly in the sub £5k smoker barge thread. It's a 10 year old design now. £20k+ is a lot to spend on that - I'd want something fresher for that sort of outlay, or I'd want to spend less money if I wanted an E60.

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3968189.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/4106407.htm

etc - both 6 cylinders, good spec and current generation. I can't think of a single thing an E60 530d M Sport does that makes it a better buy than that 530d SE.

wavydavy

Original Poster:

16 posts

195 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
I'd have an F10 SE over an E60 M Sport every day of the week, mind. £20k+ just seems like so much money to spend on a car of which fundamentally similar examples (Not that I am suggesting them as alternatives, just as an illustration) now pop up regularly in the sub £5k smoker barge thread. It's a 10 year old design now. £20k+ is a lot to spend on that - I'd want something fresher for that sort of outlay, or I'd want to spend less money if I wanted an E60.

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3968189.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/4106407.htm

etc - both 6 cylinders, good spec and current generation. I can't think of a single thing an E60 530d M Sport does that makes it a better buy than that 530d SE.
Cheers for the feedback, Fox, but I'm not a fan of the SE model aesthetics. Sport version for me. Will probably change the car after 2-3 years anyway as I'll get bored.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
So fit Sport bumpers or something. Seriously, it's SO much better and so much more worth £20k. Spend less if you really want an E60.

ajb85

1,124 posts

173 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I'd agree with WavyDavy on the Sport over SE thing with the 5, although would happily take an SE over Sport on the E90 3 series, negligible difference and the Sport interiors can be drab.

magnum555

473 posts

190 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I'd go for the 535d the twinturbos make a noticeable difference.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
ajb85 said:
I'd agree with WavyDavy on the Sport over SE thing with the 5
Usually so would I when its the same model but would you really want a 9+ year old design over the fresh and excellent F10 for similar money just for the bumpers? You could probably fit some M Sport bumpers to an F10 for not a huge amount of money.

satup1

5 posts

169 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Hello all

i am a new member to pistonheads and joined soley to participate in this interesting forum as i am in a very simialr position.
i am on the verge of buying a late model 09/59 525d or 530d m sport for 18/19k and contemplating whether to go for a f10 se which is also within not so far reach. i understand the f10 would be an se spec however the build quality seems more superior and the design more up to date along side engineering and technology. my only worry is that the se spec may be too soft for my sporting style of driving unless i lower the suspension at a later date and fit more sporting wheels. furthermore i am worried that the e60 selling for 18/19k today will drop far quicker in value than the f10 se
would really appreciate some advice.
many thanks

AutoAndy

2,270 posts

246 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
There is more to a sport spec than bumpers... If you like SE then get a merc as they are for old men too wink ( meant to be funny before you go off on one).

My advice ; if it is second hand then you have the opportunity to get something fully loaded at a fraction on the price so hold on for the right one.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
AutoAndy said:
There is more to a sport spec than bumpers... If you like SE then get a merc as they are for old men too wink ( meant to be funny before you go off on one).
There is more to Sport than bumpers I agree but other than bumpers all the other fundamental features of an M Sport are also speccable and often found on SE specification cars.

I'd always want M Sport over SE but I'd struggle to justify an E60 - a car almost a decade old in design terms and not even close to the best 5 Series they've done - over an F10 irrespective of spec. The F10 is an excellent car.

Buy an F10 SE and fit some bumpers. Everything else about an F10 is just better than an E60. Better interior. Better specification. Better engine. Better iDrive (The CIC fitted E60's are ultra rare).

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
20 grand for an E60 is indeed madness. They are almost 10 years old and will soon be in 3 grand knuckledragger category with the most expensive examples rapidly following on. For 10 grand, an E60 diesel makes sense if you like that sort of thing.
Fact is, you can buy an F10 525d or 530d SE on a 10 plate with nice mileage from a BMW dealer for 22-23 grand. As has been said, it's an infinitely nicer car in every respect, will be in production for another 5 years and won't shed value like an E60. Unlike the E60, the F10 looks just fine as an SE, particularly if it's been dechromed - they are a very pretty car and the interior is just a thousand years away from the E60.

It's a no brainer.

satup1

5 posts

169 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
hi folks
thanks for your comments
i will take on board what has been said an

- isore - what u said makes perfect sense however

one more scenario

how about an e60 14-15k mark is this a good middle ground

as most cars 10-12k are pre facelift and not without the newer style engines and gearboxes

thanks

IATM

3,948 posts

178 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
the difference between a 530d e60 and 535d e60 is significant - if anyone says otherwise shouldnt be in either car and just get a 1.8 petrol.

the smoothness and surge of power from the 535d is very apparent. the 530d is a great engine! but the 535d is special!!! you are in awe of the performance it has - total admiration.

i would love to get myself in a f10 535d - dream car the mo.

wibblebrain

656 posts

171 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
So fit Sport bumpers or something. Seriously, it's SO much better and so much more worth £20k. Spend less if you really want an E60.
I'd love to know where you can find new shape 530d for £20k. The fact is that there are none, at least not with reasonable mileage and hence the uplift to go from E60 to current shape is considerable. So I don't think the choice you are advocating is actually realistic.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
wibblebrain said:
I'd love to know where you can find new shape 530d for £20k. The fact is that there are none, at least not with reasonable mileage and hence the uplift to go from E60 to current shape is considerable. So I don't think the choice you are advocating is actually realistic.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201240487240902/sort/default/usedcars/maximum-age/up_to_2_years_old/model/5_series/make/bmw/onesearchad/used/onesearchad/nearlynew/onesearchad/new/radius/1500/keywords/530d/page/1/postcode/pl11aa?logcode=p

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2012...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2012...

Selection of mileages and specifcations there, low 20's.

I stand by my opinion that £20k + E60 = not in a month of Sundays. It is no longer a £20k car unless it has a V10 under the bonnet and M5 stuck to the bootlid.

wibblebrain

656 posts

171 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
I stand by my opinion that £20k + E60 = not in a month of Sundays. It is no longer a £20k car unless it has a V10 under the bonnet and M5 stuck to the bootlid.
I think you are right to suggest £20k on an E60 is too much. I think a max of about £15- £16k would be more reasonable. The uplift for the new shape would then be around 50% to get one of these.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Quite, and the OP was looking at spending just over £20k on an E60, hence my opinion throughout this thread. If you are spending £14k its rather a different story.