to shed or not to shed - 540i E39
to shed or not to shed - 540i E39
Author
Discussion

cvega

Original Poster:

467 posts

190 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Want to tick off a V8 off my list. Wanted a Monaro, but they're rarer and rarer and getting expensive. 540i seems to be at a good price now. Pros/cons? (running costs != con)

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I had an auto a couple of years back, like all E39s they are comfortable for long journeys. I was getting about 23mpg average, and the grunt was worthwhile when you needed it. I had to replace a the cats on it to get it through an MOT, which was a bit of an ouch, but the next MOT it sailed through, so overall if you get lucky you'll get some cheap motoring, but if anything expensive goes, then it can be a BIG bill, but for what you get in terms of luxury and it being a nice place to be, I'd still be tempted to get it repaired rather than replaced.

Crombers

374 posts

222 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Depends on the budget. A 1 or 2k 540i is not luxury motoring, it's a shed that could easily cost you the same again to keep on the road. Find a facelift around 5k with a good history and it may be a pleasant proposition.

Buy on condition not on mileage alone.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I've heard recent horror stories of a few V8 BMW's of the era generating massive bills because of the chains going brittle and falling apart taking the engine with it or something? I think I also read even a preemptive fix is £1000+. Anyway as always check the cooling system, and replace everything that hasn't been in the cars lifetime. Don't worry about Nikasil, if it's still running 14 years after they stopped using those blocks it shouldn't be an issue.

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Something I debated for a long time. One of the members on another BMW forum I frequent ran one for a while (ended up selling it to the bro of another member) and some of the bills were hefty enough to make me think twice.

They are very very tempting however. A good example would be a pleasure. A bad example would be a money pit.

cvega

Original Poster:

467 posts

190 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
5k ish was the budget I am aiming for.

madou

366 posts

282 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Crombers said:
Find a facelift around 5k with a good history and it may be a pleasant proposition.

Buy on condition not on mileage alone.
Good advice !

I have really enjoyed my 2001 E39 iA Sport Touring, but it has cost me a lot more than I had planned in running costs to keep in good condition, as over c. 5 years 40k miles I appear to have had just about every classic E39 problem with brakes, suspension, electrics, cooling, oil leaks, ... so even using a good independent the bills have averaged £2k per year ! I have never had the nerve to add them up exactly

ajb85

1,124 posts

173 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Lovely cars, but I think the 286bhp felt a bit underpowered. Driven maybe 2 or 3 and expected a bit more performance. Mercedes' equivalent V8 certainly go better and sound gruntier in my opinion.

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
cvega said:
Wanted a Monaro, but they're rarer and rarer and getting expensive.
Really? Rare-ish for sure though there's usually a decent throughput of ones up for sale.

Not sure about expensive though - they're certainly coming down in price. Heavily modified / rare special editions excluded. The pricing for them is, generously, all over the shop given their rarity / different models.

If you fancy a Monaro - sit tight. Though it will depend on your budget I guess.

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
sparks_E39 said:
I've heard recent horror stories of a few V8 BMW's of the era generating massive bills because of the chains going brittle and falling apart taking the engine with it or something? I think I also read even a preemptive fix is £1000+. Anyway as always check the cooling system, and replace everything that hasn't been in the cars lifetime. Don't worry about Nikasil, if it's still running 14 years after they stopped using those blocks it shouldn't be an issue.
Not quite.

Timing chain guides become brittle and break. Fix is about £500 in parts, £500 in labour. Clattering sound from the front of the engine is the giveaway - most happen at 150k miles onwards.

No E39 540 had a Nikasil block, so that's not an issue.

Usual E39 foibles apply - rocker cover gasktets go, cooling systems are weak. Gearboxes tend to be ok. Later M62B44TU engines have water-cooled alternators that cost a small fortune to replace.

Oh, and all the shocks and bushes will need replacing.

madou

366 posts

282 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
rocker cover gaskets go
Just gone. And gear selector rebuild. And rear discs and pads. And air conditioning needed a full service. Oops, away goes another grand

S. Gonzales Esq.

2,559 posts

243 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Six months in and I'm pretty happy with my '97 540i/6 Touring. I'm working my way through the usual issues, and am hopeful I'll get it through another 100k miles if I can keep on top of things.

It's a big old bus, so more suited to A-roads and long M'way trips, but I'm starting to appreciate the quality of the chassis and engineering. Sounds good too.

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
madou said:
Just gone. And gear selector rebuild. And rear discs and pads. And air conditioning needed a full service. Oops, away goes another grand
Rocker cover gaskets isn't too bad a DIY job, aside from removing the injector clips. Rear discs and pads is a very easy DIY.

Might help save some of that bag o'sand.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
Not quite.

Timing chain guides become brittle and break. Fix is about £500 in parts, £500 in labour. Clattering sound from the front of the engine is the giveaway - most happen at 150k miles onwards.

No E39 540 had a Nikasil block, so that's not an issue.

Usual E39 foibles apply - rocker cover gasktets go, cooling systems are weak. Gearboxes tend to be ok. Later M62B44TU engines have water-cooled alternators that cost a small fortune to replace.

Oh, and all the shocks and bushes will need replacing.
Not so bad, I think I would budget that in if I wanted a 540, but if I was to purchase a BMW V8, it would have "M5" on the boot!

Esseesse

9,027 posts

239 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all

cvega

Original Poster:

467 posts

190 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
i'd love the M5, but gotta keep feet on the ground. Although the V10's are getting cheaper by the minute almost :> thanks for the feedback so far.

rm163603

656 posts

279 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
I bought an E39 540i sport back in January and have put another 15K on the clock since...

I love it! The e39 is just such a well made solid car and the V8 just suits it perfectly.

For long trips it's just so relaxed but at the same time it handles very well for such a big car. People complain about the steering being numb but compared to most new cars it feels pretty good to me.

I would say go for it if you are able to DIY stuff. If not the cost of little things could really add up.

So far things I've done include:

Blower resistor
Radio unit resoldered to solve intermittant speaker problems
Timing chain tensioner replaced as a precaution
New front disks and pads
Cam position sensor
MAF

Economy is around 24mpg ish overall

Watch out for rust, especially under the jacking points and inner wings where it has been known to rot out so badly the car is scrap.

ukdennis

167 posts

249 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
rm163603 said:
Radio unit resoldered to solve intermittant speaker problems
Hi, Could I ask what exactly you did to fix this? My 740i E38 has developed similar symtoms!

Thanks in advance.

counterofbeans

1,092 posts

170 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
This my 2002 540i sport auto:-



It's a great car especially for long journeys, although I only put 3-4000 miles a year on it (for various reasons) therefore I've yet to experience any major expenses (touches wood, crosses fingers etc.) other than a failed gear position switch which put the gearbox into a temporary failsafe mode.




Gad-Westy

16,666 posts

244 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
counterofbeans said:
This my 2002 540i sport auto:-



It's a great car especially for long journeys, although I only put 3-4000 miles a year on it (for various reasons) therefore I've yet to experience any major expenses (touches wood, crosses fingers etc.) other than a failed gear position switch which put the gearbox into a temporary failsafe mode.
That's lovely. I love Imola red. Genuinely, if you ever feel like selling, I'd appreciate a nudge.