330d Est or 530d Est
330d Est or 530d Est
Author
Discussion

magpies

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

213 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I'm looking to replace my aging current estate and have approx £5.5k

I need an estate as I go scuba diving and need space for 2 lots of equipment.

I also live 30 miles from work - mostly dual carriage/motorway and then country roads.

I need space / pace and comfort. Not magically concerned about fuel consumption as long as I can get at least 40mpg on the run to work.

what are the pros and cons between the 3 and 5 series. My thoughts are the type of person using a 5 as a generalisation may be less hard on the car.

Looking at Auto Trader - the prices are similar and that money covers 3 to 4 years spread. I'm not too bothered about mileage but would prefer around 100 to 120k (or lower smile )

bolide

582 posts

285 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I don't think you'll get two sets of gear in a 3-Series. 5-Series it'll go in easily and will probably be hidden under the load cover

330D is quite a piece of kit - very torquey, great with the auto box. The 3-Series feels lighter but the cabin is tighter and the load area is very small unless you fold the rear seats down. 5-Series feels more grown up but still handles well

The load space size difference is greater than you'd think

Nick Froome

Edited by bolide on Thursday 13th September 19:52

zip929

670 posts

208 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I had an E61 530D and I must say they are a great car.
Plenty of space, good power and economy. I have never driven a 3 series so cannot compare.
The 5 cabin is a nice spacious place to be. I am not sure why you would choose a 3 over the 5?


Drek

609 posts

196 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
bolide said:
I don't think you'll get two sets of gear in a 3-Series. 5-Series it'll go in easily and will probably be hidden under the load cover

330D is quite a piece of kit - very torquey, great with the auto box. The 3-Series feels lighter but the cabin is tighter and the load area is very small unless you fold the rear seats down. 5-Series feels more grown up but still handles well

The load space size difference is greater than you'd think

Nick Froome

Edited by bolide on Thursday 13th September 19:52
Wot he said. I have a 3er Touring and the boot ain't that big really. Go for the 5 if space for your kit is key.

SBN

1,030 posts

183 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Definitely go for 5 series as the 3 series is pretty small and has a awkward loading bed from the rear arches protruding in to the cabin.

magpies

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

213 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I have a 2.5 tdi V6 A4 at the mo....don't comment

I have a mate who had a 3 estate 2.0 tdi......although seemed almost as quick didn't have the load space.... but was nice

looking at the comments the 5 looks the better choice up to now

bolide

582 posts

285 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
I just realised I have the photos:

E46


E39


Nick Froome

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
zip929 said:
The 5 cabin is a nice spacious place to be. I am not sure why you would choose a 3 over the 5?
In my case (having previously had two E39s) because the Five is now just too much of a whale. Obviously you need a car that fulfils what you generally need it to do, and if you regularly fill an E61 or later 5-series Touring then fair enough, you need a car that size. However, if you can carry what you need in an E91 instead, there are many advantages. Engine for engine, they're faster, lighter, more economical, frequently cheaper to tax and insure, nimbler and easier to thread down a narrow lane. Plus a 3-series will fit into most single garages whereas a current 5-series won't. For me, those were all good reasons to give up on the ever-fatter 5-series models as the 3-series in turn grew into the size category that the 5 used to occupy in the E39 days.

By 2025 I'll probably be driving whatever they then have wearing a 1-series badge, because that will then be the size of an E39.