BMW F30 Auto Stop/Start
BMW F30 Auto Stop/Start
Author
Discussion

mark8210

Original Poster:

6 posts

170 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
Greetings good people of Pistonheads.

I recently bought a BMW F30 and have been driving it around for 3 weeks now. Having not had an auto stop/start car before, it took a bit of getting used to but I eventually started to like the fuel-saving silence! However the last 3/4 days it seems to have stopped auto stop/starting at the lights or wherever completely. As far as I am aware, the only way to disable it is to press the button just above the engine start button, which I have not used.

Is there anything that anyone knows of that could be causing it? It being so new I wouldn't have thought it would be a fault on the vehicle, just wondered if anyone knows of anything I can check or keep an eye on that may affect it. Keen to hear of any other F30 owners (mine is a 320d Sport to be precise) who may have encountered anything similar. It may be that Im an idiot, but it was working fine previously.

Thanks for your time

rfn

4,609 posts

238 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
It's probably due to the temperature drop?
My MINI Clubman would only do it above 10c ambient temperature, and once the car was up to temperate (which obviously takes longer in colder temperatures).

mark8210

Original Poster:

6 posts

170 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
rfn said:
It's probably due to the temperature drop?
My MINI Clubman would only do it above 10c ambient temperature, and once the car was up to temperate (which obviously takes longer in colder temperatures).
I guess potentially, that did cross my mind as well, but even when the oil temp guage reads between 50-100C it hasn't done it. Will see what its like after a long run when its fully up to temperature.

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

173 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
mark8210 said:
However the last 3/4 days it seems to have stopped auto stop/starting at the lights or wherever completely.
The F25 handbook says it won't shut down automatically if temp below 3°c, low battery level, interior temp not at desired level and whole host of other things

mark8210

Original Poster:

6 posts

170 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
JimmyTheHand said:
The F25 handbook says it won't shut down automatically if temp below 3°c, low battery level, interior temp not at desired level and whole host of other things
Thanks for the info - I asked here before consulting the handbook. Looks like I'll have to take it on a longer run to rule out any of those conditions

mark8210

Original Poster:

6 posts

170 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
Found a good run down of start/stop over at f30driver.com http://www.f30driver.com/forum/showthread.php?t=90...

For others that may be interested, reasons for start/stop not activating listed there are:

The car is coasting (manual transmission)
Brake vacuum reading is too low (manual transmission)
Insufficient brake pedal pressure is being applied to hold the vehicle stationary (automatic transmission)
Stopping on a hill/downhill with a 12% or greater gradient
If the steering angle is more then 6 degrees
If the steering wheel is still be moved after approximately one second of coming to a stop
The system has not yet be activated by going over a speed of 5mph for automatics, 3mph for manuals since the last engine switch off
If the gas pedal is being pressed (engine must be at idle speed only)
You're coming to a stop from reverse
The driver gets out of the car
If Hill Decent Control (HDC) is activated
If the engine is not up to temperature
If the carbon canister is being purged
if the grade of the fuel is too low for the engine
Transmission adaptation is active (automatic transmission)
The hydraulic pressure accumulator is not yet up to pressure (automatic transmission)
Stop-and-go traffic - system is only activated by driving over 5mph for automatics, 3mph for manuals
Batter charge is low
Outside temperature is colder then 37.4 F / 3 C
Outside temperature above 95 F / 35 C and the air conditioning system is on
Fogging of the windshield is detected by the IHKA system
Climate control system is on but passenger compartment has not yet reached desired temperature
ABS system was used when coming to a stop

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

173 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
mark8210 said:
Thanks for the info - I asked here before consulting the handbook.
I grabbed a PDF copy for mine of the BMW USA site - much easier to search/check things


mark8210 said:
Looks like I'll have to take it on a longer run to rule out any of those conditions
You were just looking for an excuse for taking it out then wink

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Saturday 15th September 2012
quotequote all
I really dislike the stop/start. I think it's a false economy.

Whenever I start mine, I always turn it off. If I find myself in a position where I need it, I just press the start button myself!

I think if you intend to keep the car for a longer period, the additional wear on the starter motor (especially with a high compression diesel), the engine mounts, and all the other components during a start-up, far outweighs a bit of fuel benefit.

Euro emissions gone mad.

If I was able to set a 'timeout' on mine, of say, 15 seconds, I would probably use it - but I still prefer to control it myself.

Nearly every time it has kicked in, I've pulled away a few seconds later.

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Saturday 15th September 2012
quotequote all
I've got a F10 520d and almost all of my driving is out of town.

I've therefore had the stop/start recoded to remember last state rather then default to always on when you start up.

excel monkey

4,837 posts

258 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
I think if you intend to keep the car for a longer period, the additional wear on the starter motor (especially with a high compression diesel), the engine mounts, and all the other components during a start-up, far outweighs a bit of fuel benefit.
I love it. Have had it on my E90 for over four years now. Perhaps naively, I trust BMWs engineers to have done the cost/benefit analysis properly...

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
excel monkey said:
stuart-b said:
I think if you intend to keep the car for a longer period, the additional wear on the starter motor (especially with a high compression diesel), the engine mounts, and all the other components during a start-up, far outweighs a bit of fuel benefit.
I love it. Have had it on my E90 for over four years now. Perhaps naively, I trust BMWs engineers to have done the cost/benefit analysis properly...
I trust BMW's engineers to do what their management requires of them: to achieve the lowest possible fleet CO2 rating, not to worry about the owners of older cars out of warranty and out of the dealer network.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Lowtimer said:
I trust BMW's engineers to do what their management requires of them: to achieve the lowest possible fleet CO2 rating, not to worry about the owners of older cars out of warranty and out of the dealer network.
Exactly.

A starter-motor is a starter-motor. BMW won't be using anything 'super duper' just because you have stop start. I wonder if the motor is different in a car with stop start, and without? Without looking, I bet it isn't. What's the normal service life of a starter motor? Then in city driving, I would guess (one day I left it on), I used the starter motor at least 15-20 times. That's 10 times my normal usage. What about the wear on the other components of the car? Starting a high compression diesel isn't pretty - my whole car shakes.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
Exactly.

A starter-motor is a starter-motor. BMW won't be using anything 'super duper' just because you have stop start. I wonder if the motor is different in a car with stop start, and without? Without looking, I bet it isn't. What's the normal service life of a starter motor? Then in city driving, I would guess (one day I left it on), I used the starter motor at least 15-20 times. That's 10 times my normal usage. What about the wear on the other components of the car? Starting a high compression diesel isn't pretty - my whole car shakes.
To be fair to BMW, actually, as I understand it, the starter motor is claimed by Bosch, who make it, to be a different type for the stop-start cars. Even so, I have concerns. It's not just wear and tear on the starter, it's the number of times you kick over a high compression diesel from stationary with virtually zero oil pressure.

parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
A900ss said:
I've therefore had the stop/start recoded to remember last state rather then default to always on when you start up.
That's a REALLY good idea. How it should have been from the factory IMO.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
parapaul said:
That's a REALLY good idea. How it should have been from the factory IMO.
However, if it had been like that from the factory we would all be paying higher VED and/or company car tax. The stop-start, like the gear change assist light system, is only taken into consideration for the EU CO2 rating regime if it defaults to "on" as the car is supplied to the customer.

It's much less expensive to get it recoded than to have higher VED all the time you own the car. Mind you, personally I don't find it any inconvenience pressing the "off" button after I start the engine.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Lowtimer said:
However, if it had been like that from the factory we would all be paying higher VED and/or company car tax. The stop-start, like the gear change assist light system, is only taken into consideration for the EU CO2 rating regime if it defaults to "on" as the car is supplied to the customer.

It's much less expensive to get it recoded than to have higher VED all the time you own the car. Mind you, personally I don't find it any inconvenience pressing the "off" button after I start the engine.
It is actually starting to get on my nerves, having to keep pressing it.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Lowtimer said:
To be fair to BMW, actually, as I understand it, the starter motor is claimed by Bosch, who make it, to be a different type for the stop-start cars. Even so, I have concerns. It's not just wear and tear on the starter, it's the number of times you kick over a high compression diesel from stationary with virtually zero oil pressure.
Hadn't considered that.

kpb

305 posts

206 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
I have no worries about the starter motor etc as I've heard they are beefed up - my main concern is not having the option to warm down the turbo when you pull off a motorway and the start/stop kicks in at the slip-road traffic lights.

youngsyr

14,742 posts

223 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
kpb said:
I have no worries about the starter motor etc as I've heard they are beefed up - my main concern is not having the option to warm down the turbo when you pull off a motorway and the start/stop kicks in at the slip-road traffic lights.
Why would your turbo need cooling down after a cruise on the motorway? confused


kpb

305 posts

206 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
youngsyr said:
Why would your turbo need cooling down after a cruise on the motorway? confused
I dare say someone will correct my mechanical knowledge but warming turbos up and down is generally deemed to lengthen their lifespan - I think its something to ensuring the oil & unit temps in them are reduced slowly as opposed to just instantaneous drop off when temps are high. Hence the option to fit something like this...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo_timer

Obviously pulling off a motorway after an hour at 70+ mph (or a spirited b-road drive ending at some lights) and the stop start kicking in is somewhat counter to this.