545i or 550i?
545i or 550i?
Author
Discussion

Blue Oval84

Original Poster:

5,399 posts

192 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Okey doke, now that my Z4 is sold I'm running my E39 530i and will probably run it into the ground.

Whilst waiting for it to inevitably go pop (auto box is on over 155K already) I'm channelling extra money into my breakage fund in the hope that by the time I need to change I have enough to buy a nice E60, or at least a huge deposit.

However, having looked at the tech specs of the 545i and 550i, I can't decide if it's worth setting my sights on the 550i or whether the 545i would do just as well.

What do people think?

Whilst I'm a year or two off buying it I want to have something to aspire to because I know I'll save harder. Plus I can keep an eye on their values which I presume will continue to plummet as fuel prices soar smile

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
A 550i is effectively a newer 545i - they never sat in the range together, the 550i replaced the 545i. So which to buy? A 550i, unless you don't want to spend that much. It's not night and day better, its just.. newer. Do try very hard to get an LCI E60 though. The subtle changes make a huge difference to the way the car looks and feels IMHO and removes some of the ridiculous BMW cost cutting (ie not bothering with proper headlights, LED's etc).

Jobbo

13,921 posts

295 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Most (all?) 545 and 550is will have Xenons; I'm pretty sure they were standard. So they had proper headlights. There's not a huge difference to the way the car feels, contrary to Fox's assertion; the older iDrive controller feels nicer to me too. Basically, an LCI may be worth finding, but it'll cost more to buy; only you can decide whether you're willing to pay the extra. For me, the LCI makes more of a difference on the lower spec E60s.

With a newer car you will definitely have to pay more road tax - indeed, only the earliest 550is avoided the £460 band which applies to cars registered after 22 March 2006.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
They were not standard.

Jobbo

13,921 posts

295 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox is correct, having checked the early E61 brochure; but I haven't seen a 545i for sale without them.

Blue Oval84

Original Poster:

5,399 posts

192 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
All interesting stuff, so probably not a "night and day" difference between the two cars.

I have to say I don't mind the pre-LCI E60 at all so the only issue for me would be if there were major performance differences.

The lower tax on a pre March 2006 model is also relatively attractive but not a deal breaker, I just suspect that there will be a lot more choice of 545is within budget so imagine that may be the route I end up going down.

Thanks guys smile

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
I'd go for a 550i because the 545i's are getting on a bit now. The later engine is less prone to oil leaks (the early N62 V8 is a bugger for cam cover gaskets) and just a nicer unit. 550i's have standard Dakota leather, wood trim, lane departure warning and stuff like that. Xenons are absolutely essential - non xenon lights on the E60 border on dangerously poor. Many's the time when I've driven one home on a dark rainy night and I've had to have it on main beam with the lights adjusted to full downwards position in order to see where I'm going. They are that bad.

The V8 is one of the few E60's that ellicits a spark of interest - see if you can find a six speed manual as well because they're just epic. The M Sport version is the thinking Man's M5 - fast enough, but with bearable economy. You could get SMG on the 545i and 550i but the standard 6 speed auto is just easier to live with.

As for where to buy one, you'd be lucky to find a BMW dealer who'd have one on the forecourt as they're only marginally more desirable than Aids (from a resale point of view) and compared to the E39, very few V8's were imported. Old shape 5 Series V8 petrol = kiss of death. Still, that means a cheap car for you!

Jobbo

13,921 posts

295 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
All BMW V8s suffer from the cam cover gaskets going brittle with age - it's hardly surprising the issue isn't that prevalent on 550is yet, but they will start to suffer in exactly the same way as the 545, and the E39 540i before it. The gaskets are identical on the 545 and 550.

As for the engine being nicer - it's the same N62 Valvetronic engine but with ~10% more displacement and ~10% more power. It's not smoother nor more economical nor anything else, just a bit more pokey.

Dakota leather is the basic leather which is found on virtually all E60s, and nothing to crow about. Finding an upgrade (whether on a 545 or a 550) would definitely be a good thing. I'm not a massive fan of the Nasca leather which came with seat ventilation (my last 545 had it and it feels like quality but hard); the Exclusive option is way nicer, and occasionally you find an Individual spec with Merino leather which is also rather lovely.

Edited by Jobbo on Friday 21st September 17:34

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Jobbo said:
All BMW V8s suffer from the cam cover gaskets going brittle with age - it's hardly surprising the issue isn't that prevalent on 550is yet, but they will start to suffer in exactly the same way as the 545, and the E39 540i before it. The gaskets are identical on the 545 and 550.
The N62 gaskets were upgraded some time ago yet still retain the same part number. The ones released as replacements around 5-6 years ago are rather better - perhaps that's why they don't leak anything like as badly? Of course, all rubber gaskets will eventually leak, pretty obvious really.

The 550i engine is nicer. It uses no more fuel, and goes quite a bit better. That's not nicer?

Dakota leather is alright. It's not the highest quality but it's better than the Montana Vinyl based leather in lesser BMW's.

Jobbo

13,921 posts

295 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
The N62 gaskets were upgraded some time ago yet still retain the same part number. The ones released as replacements around 5-6 years ago are rather better - perhaps that's why they don't leak anything like as badly? Of course, all rubber gaskets will eventually leak, pretty obvious really.
Well, let's see when they get to 8 years old before asserting that they're going to be better in the future, eh?

As for nicer, it's 10% more powerful and won't use any more fuel; whether that's worth paying twice the price, I would debate. If they were the same price, a no-brainer, but they aren't; the 545i looks like better value.

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Jobbo said:
Most (all?) 545 and 550is will have Xenons; I'm pretty sure they were standard. So they had proper headlights. There's not a huge difference to the way the car feels, contrary to Fox's assertion; the older iDrive controller feels nicer to me too. Basically, an LCI may be worth finding, but it'll cost more to buy; only you can decide whether you're willing to pay the extra. For me, the LCI makes more of a difference on the lower spec E60s.

With a newer car you will definitely have to pay more road tax - indeed, only the earliest 550is avoided the £460 band which applies to cars registered after 23rd March 2006.
EFA

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Jobbo said:
Well, let's see when they get to 8 years old before asserting that they're going to be better in the future, eh?
Only one more year to go.............. :-)