current x5 owners advice for prospective x5 owner
current x5 owners advice for prospective x5 owner
Author
Discussion

menousername

Original Poster:

2,526 posts

173 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all

Hi all

Any x5 owners please advise things to look out for when thinking about an x5?

Anything from tyre costs, performance in snow on summer Tyres, common faults or expenditures on older x5s

My budget puts me in the 2004/2005 area. Looked at a couple so far.

One had non-bmw service history and I was not sure if that was a problem. Its last service was8k previous so I expected a service reminder or overdue warning when turning on the ignition but it just went straight to the mileometer. I have a 3 series not sure if the reminder is in the same place on the x5? Is this a concern? Chasity dropped off the readings due to the non-bmw service history?

Another one was in good condition but the folding mirrors did no work and I couldn't gauge how much hassle and cost that would involve

Any advice appreciated


cerb4.5lee

45,351 posts

211 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
menousername said:
Hi all

Any x5 owners please advise things to look out for when thinking about an x5?

Anything from tyre costs, performance in snow on summer Tyres, common faults or expenditures on older x5s

My budget puts me in the 2004/2005 area. Looked at a couple so far.

One had non-bmw service history and I was not sure if that was a problem. Its last service was8k previous so I expected a service reminder or overdue warning when turning on the ignition but it just went straight to the mileometer. I have a 3 series not sure if the reminder is in the same place on the x5? Is this a concern? Chasity dropped off the readings due to the non-bmw service history?

Another one was in good condition but the folding mirrors did no work and I couldn't gauge how much hassle and cost that would involve

Any advice appreciated
Hello, i used to own a 4.8iS & tyres range between £150 - £300 each in my experience & they are quite wide so they suffer a little in the snow tbh, with regards to service it is condition based to each car, so they can go a reasonable amount of time before anything needs doing so thats not a too bigger worry.

If its been serviced by an independent then thats fine also as most people steer clear of main dealer because of heavy servicing costs, there are alot of electric items on them aswell so just check they all work.

Good luck in your search smile

menousername

Original Poster:

2,526 posts

173 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all

Thanks mate

What does suffer in the snow re. the tyres?




cerb4.5lee

45,351 posts

211 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
menousername said:
Thanks mate

What does suffer in the snow re. the tyres?
With the tyres being wide & low profile the X5 does struggle a little for traction in the snow & alot of owners swap to winter tyres for more reassurance, it lacks grip on summer tyres in the snow but that can also be said for most cars, its a heavy beast so stopping it once its sliding can get interesting!

Zato

330 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Folding mirrors are expensive to replace. Just had one done under warranty. £400 fitted. I have a 54 plate x5 and would not own one without a bullet proof warranty. Sunroof motor went and it was 2.5k to replace.

Great cars and had mine 8 years.

menousername

Original Poster:

2,526 posts

173 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Wow thats alot. Was that just to fix the mechanism or did you need the mirrors replaced?

That's astronomical money for the Sunroof tho

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
The panoramic sunroof and the wing mirror issue are both well known problems on the E53 X5 and the 5 series - luckily the car I bought had a new sunroof cartridge fitted as part of its AUC prep.

However, I wouldn't buy one with the roof without a bombproof warranty as its exceptional for them not to require replacement if they fail.

A decent indy should be able to sort the reversing mirror function - mine plays up occasionally but so long as it doesn't get any worse I will wait for the next service before sorting it.

The E53 range of X5's is covered by the reduced price servicing offered by most dealers - for example an oil service is £169 inc parts, labour and VAT which is a relatively cheap way of keeping the BMWFSH.

David



Edited by sumo69 on Monday 24th September 09:47

menousername

Original Poster:

2,526 posts

173 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all

Ah right, that makes sense. Personally im not keen on the panoramic roofs so hopefully I wont have any horror stories there

I just wondered whether its worth taking on a cheaper car with these issues or going up in budget for one that's pretty solid

Oil service doesn't sound much more than my 330 too so that's good to know- same engine pretty much tho

thanks everyone

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Unless you need the 4wd it's fundamentally an E39 Touring on stilts (Same engines, electrics, etc) and you'd get a cracking one for less money than the X5 plus they are quicker, more economical, cheaper tyres etc.

rumple

15,451 posts

182 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Unless you need the 4wd it's fundamentally an E39 Touring on stilts (Same engines, electrics, etc) and you'd get a cracking one for less money than the X5 plus they are quicker, more economical, cheaper tyres etc.
I guess some people like to be high uprofl

menousername

Original Poster:

2,526 posts

173 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all

The 4wd is the main motivation

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
menousername said:
The 4wd is the main motivation
So you can spin 4 wheels and go nowhere in the snow we rarely get rather than 2 hehe

rumple

15,451 posts

182 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
At least the op is looking at x5's and not q7's,rofl

menousername

Original Poster:

2,526 posts

173 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
So you can spin 4 wheels and go nowhere in the snow we rarely get rather than 2 hehe
So you are saying it does not cope in yhe snow..... in which case what's your recommendation for a 4wd in the same class for the same money that does perform in the snow?

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
menousername said:
Fox- said:
So you can spin 4 wheels and go nowhere in the snow we rarely get rather than 2 hehe
So you are saying it does not cope in yhe snow..... in which case what's your recommendation for a 4wd in the same class for the same money that does perform in the snow?
Ignore Fox, his standard answer to anything BMW related usually ends up at the E39

I have an E53 X5, a 2006 Sport Exclusive, that I may need to part with this month if its any use to you?

Buy carefully, I was fussy about spec when I looked for mine, I also specifically discarded any sunroof equipped cars due to the potential headaches noted above

All in all great all round car that I initially wasn't sure about, however any doubts are a mere distant memory

Edited by martin mrt on Monday 24th September 21:53

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
menousername said:
So you are saying it does not cope in yhe snow..... in which case what's your recommendation for a 4wd in the same class for the same money that does perform in the snow?
No 4wd with huge low profile summer tyres is going to cope well in the snow - my recommendation if you actually need snow performance is the right tyres, which when fitted to a 4wd vehicle will provide excellent performance.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
martin mrt said:
Ignore Fox, his standard answer to anything BMW related always ends up at the E39
Thats hardly fair - though in this case its particularly relevent as you know quite how heavily related they are. They are fundamentally the same car in many respects, yet one is half the price of the other so it would be foolish not to at least mention it.

Though the point you've replied to is true - he seems to be chosing the X5 for snow performance - it's fairly sensible to point out that stellar snow performance is not a feature of an X5 on ultra wide low profile summer tyres. It'll spin 4 wheels rather than 2. If you want to move around in snow you need either the right tyres, or you need narrower tyres, IMHO (Or you need to realise it doesnt snow much here and its not a big deal but I'm not opening that can of worms this year hehe)

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
martin mrt said:
Ignore Fox, his standard answer to anything BMW related always ends up at the E39
Thats hardly fair - though in this case its particularly relevent as you know quite how heavily related they are. They are fundamentally the same car in many respects, yet one is half the price of the other so it would be foolish not to at least mention it.

Though the point you've replied to is true - he seems to be chosing the X5 for snow performance - it's fairly sensible to point out that stellar snow performance is not a feature of an X5 on ultra wide low profile summer tyres. It'll spin 4 wheels rather than 2. If you want to move around in snow you need either the right tyres, or you need narrower tyres, IMHO (Or you need to realise it doesnt snow much here and its not a big deal but I'm not opening that can of worms this year hehe)
I have edited the above post Fox wink

I am under no illusion that my X5 will be useless in the snow on its current wheel/tyre combination, and as a result I was intending to fit winter tyres on smaller wheels



Speed addicted

6,336 posts

258 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
I had two E53 X5s, a 2003 and a 2004. I live in the north east of Scotland so we get proper winters, two years ago we had 3-4' of snow for about 6 weeks.

Both of them were OK in snow with the standard wheels on (19" on the last car), but were much better with smaller 17" wheels and offroad tyres which I've never got round to selling.

Both had issues with the door handles freezing and jamming in cold weather, around -5 seemed to be the problem point. This was partially cured with special grease from BMW.

The later car had intermittently squeaky front door trims, this totally did my head in.

Look out for the digital display on the dash failing as a lot of them seem to do this.
They like brakes and bushes so listen for any clonks, the rear subframe bushes are apparently quite expensive to change.

I now have a Q7 which may be also intresting in snow and is even bigger than the X5. I went to Audi after 10 years of BMW because I don't get on with the sport seats and wanted a change from the BMW dash. My wife preffered the X5, I'm not sure either way.


snow by Brent Leport, on Flickr

The running boards just collect crap, but do make washing the roof easier.





Edited by Speed addicted on Monday 24th September 22:53