X3 advice
Author
Discussion

contracttor

Original Poster:

922 posts

216 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Hi,

The missus is looking at other cars. She's currently in a 335i MSport Conv and for various reasons is looking to change. We've looked at X3/5/6 and while she likes the X6, lifting things into and out of the boot is quite difficult and for other size-related reasons she's heading towards an X3. The X5 has been discounted too.

We're looking at the 35d M-Sport and this would be pretty well loaded with most options and ends up in the region of 50k new eek

1. Are there deals to be done on factory orders? I've compared Broadspeed price v. list and there's maybe 7.5% on base, no discount on option. Can this be bettered?
2. In a dealership yesterday we were having a casual discussion and the guy said delete the sports suspension. Any thoughts on this, and on 18v19 inch wheels
3. Thoughts on the vehicle in general.

She'll be keeping the car for 5 years so it will probably be straight loan/HP rather than PCP although I'm not ruling that option out.

The other option is to not get an X* but opt for a used e90 M3 with DCT and run that for 3-5 years. Part of me is also struggling with the whole 50K for an X3 thing. I'd sooner pay 50K for an X6/X5/M3 if that makes sense but I have to remind myself the car is for her, not me - I'm keeping my M6.

I'd just thought I'd try and see what others make of this. Thoughts and opinions welcome.

Thanks.


LeoSayer

7,865 posts

275 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
This is why I bought a 2 year old X5 for £30k. An equivalent new X3 with the options we wanted would have been £46k.

My Mrs preferred the smaller size of the X3 but the car is fairly new and in short supply so discounts are hard to come by.

Personally I don't see the point of sports suspension on a 4x4 SUV. If comfort is important to you then consider the VDC, although you really need a long test drive to decide what's right for you.

Why have you discounted the X5?


contracttor

Original Poster:

922 posts

216 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
She's discounted the x5 and x6 because lifting things up onto the boot is harder than the x3 (boot lip is higher). She has a bad back so this is a definite factor.

MarkM5

265 posts

220 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
I'd be surprised if an X5 with the bottom half of the split tailgate down is higher than the X3? Either way, the split tailgate means no bashing big cricket bags on the bumper...

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
I doubt you'll get much if anything off an X3. You would be much better off in an X5 of about 18months old. Pick one up with a 5 year service plan and extend the warranty...job done!!

My friend who works at the local dealer said the waiting list for X3 is about 4 months, but nearer 6-7 for panoramic roof and electric tailgate... of course, you could always wait and get an F31 330xd touring if 4wd is important.

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

173 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
About 5% to 8% seems max at the moment

I picked up a 3.0 D SE 3 weeks/800 miles ago - so haven't had chance to see what it is like when pushed hard around corners yet - but it seems competent enough and able to handle road humps etc. without too much fuss (unlike E83 version), but so far I am happy.

Suggestions are X3 should hold it's price well - I think I wait and see before I pass judgement on that one, but the low tax bracket may help there.

For a completely unbiased set of opinion and whines etc you might want to look through - Link

breadvan

2,122 posts

199 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
The F25 35d is a great car and a sound purchase new or nearly new especially with the new X5 around the corner.

Regarding the MSpt suspension - there's no question it is firm but only on a par with the E9x 3 series MSpt suspension, it is hugely better than the last gen where it really had to be deleted. You must try the deleted suspension in a 35d, I don't like it, there's too much roll when pressing on, no point in 0-60 in 5.7 secs if your feeling sick when you get there.

Oh, and the boot is significantly lower than the X5 and you don't have the lip (my dogs hate that), and I had a nosy around the new 3 series touring yesterday and the boot is tiny.

contracttor

Original Poster:

922 posts

216 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Thanks all for the responses so far.

aberdeeneuan

1,437 posts

209 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
contracttor said:
Thanks all for the responses so far.
My old man was looking at these recently. We were told that they had been in short supply for a while so no dealers could get them, hence no deals on them. They could do deals on X5 though, and the figures came out pretty good.

I'd struggle justifying paying 50K for an X3 though!

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

173 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
aberdeeneuan said:
My old man was looking at these recently. We were told that they had been in short supply for a while so no dealers could get them, hence no deals on them.
I placed an order in 3rd week of June it was at dealer's middle of August - I think dealers build slots might be the biggest issue

Mustard

6,992 posts

276 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
X3 availability has improved a lot in recent months, now circa 3 months for a factory order, with the odd stock car about.... Delivery was about 7months at its peak

Roo3Stuart

307 posts

191 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
I bought one for my wife a few months ago. 3.0d M Sport - agree the price is a bit eye watering by the time you load it up.

I think a few % discount is good going given relatively short supply. We waited about 3 months from order to delivery.

Also kept the sport suspension and no VDC but with 19 inch wheels and the ride is fine, same as any M Sport BMW I have ever driven.

Overall good size car without being too big and nice looking and all round very pleased with it.