BMW quality, am I expecting too much?
BMW quality, am I expecting too much?
Author
Discussion

Reardy Mister

Original Poster:

13,758 posts

253 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
It's my first one. I would hazard I haven't purchased the definitive example of quality, its a low mileage 325i coupe from 2008.

It has a dashboard rattle somewhere deep in the passenger side. That's a bit annoying but a bit more volume on the radio fixes it. But after 22k miles, should it have that?

It's not made any better by the 30 and 35 profile RFTs and stty damping, either. And it's only an SE. Pity the m-sport owner with any fillings.

And here is by far the worst bit. To my knowledge, it still has the original wipers on it. They do a good job, are not loud on the sweep or the direction change particularly BUT, I can FEEL the change of direction through my fking brake pedal when stationary!! Really obviously. What. The. fk. Is all that about? A they connected? Is the firewall made of 2mm mdf?

It's sts me to tears and with winter coming, I feel it might fk the whole ownership experience. It just shouldn't happen.

Edited by Reardy Mister on Sunday 30th September 23:16

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
The rattle shouldn't be there, so your not expecting too much in that respect, I've had 3 E91s and the only one to have a rattle was my last one, from the rear seat area, the child's seat fitted to the car made it worse

The wipers being felt through the pedal is a well known E9x issues nothing that can be done to rectify it

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
My E39 is hewn from solid granite thumbup

Reardy Mister

Original Poster:

13,758 posts

253 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
BliarOut said:
My E39 is hewn from solid granite thumbup
I worked for a BMW dealer when the E39 came out. One of the great models of theirs ever. It was a cracking design, lovely interiors with quality feel and fit on most of the surfaces. The centre consoles looked better than the current cars and I don't think there was a duff engine amongst them. And there are many that look like they will still be going strong for years.

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
Mines about thirteen years old and still as tight as a nut. You'd have to pay ten times what she cost me to better it IMO.

I've grown to like the look of the Bangle cars but they don't seem so well put together going on what people say.

Birdster

2,548 posts

174 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
martin mrt said:
The rattle shouldn't be there, so your not expecting too much in that respect, I've had 3 E91s and the only one to have a rattle was my last one, from the rear seat area, the child's seat fitted to the car made it worse

The wipers being felt through the pedal is a well known E9x issues nothing that can be done to rectify it
Darn. I've never noticed this. Now I'm going to look for it.

Reardy Mister

Original Poster:

13,758 posts

253 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Birdster said:
martin mrt said:
The rattle shouldn't be there, so your not expecting too much in that respect, I've had 3 E91s and the only one to have a rattle was my last one, from the rear seat area, the child's seat fitted to the car made it worse

The wipers being felt through the pedal is a well known E9x issues nothing that can be done to rectify it
Darn. I've never noticed this. Now I'm going to look for it.
Just googled it. Seems it is very common.

I mean its not a deal breaker, really. Had I discovered it beforehand, along with all the other problems listed, I could probably feel better about it.

But this one slipped through the net. Annoying and slightly disappointing. I cant believe no one discovered it in the testing phase, unless a design change was made late-on (maybe at the manufacturing stage) that people thought would have no impact on the driving experience.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Rattle and creaks may be due to any number of reasons.

Ditching the RFT's will solve one of your complaints, try new blades also.


croyde

26,551 posts

261 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
My E36 bought almost new in 1998 still drives like new with no squeaks or rattles. They built them properly back then and I have not been impressed by the interiors of newer and far more expensive BMWs that I have driven since.

Sorry OP frown

Reardy Mister

Original Poster:

13,758 posts

253 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
Rattle and creaks may be due to any number of reasons.

Ditching the RFT's will solve one of your complaints, try new blades also.
I read recently that PIAA silicone blades are the way to go, will give them a try. But as I say, the current blades aren't bad. They don't make much noise themselves on the direction change indicating that they haven't gone hard and are probably ok, but each change is still felt through the brake pedal.

RichyBoy

3,749 posts

248 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
For bmw mini it's expecting too much, when I've had other bimmers they were always solid. I bought a prereg mini last year, rattles at low speed and a high pitched noise at high speed that couldn't be masked by loud music - 7 visits and couldn't be rectified.

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Reardy Mister said:
E30M3SE said:
Rattle and creaks may be due to any number of reasons.

Ditching the RFT's will solve one of your complaints, try new blades also.
I read recently that PIAA silicone blades are the way to go, will give them a try. But as I say, the current blades aren't bad. They don't make much noise themselves on the direction change indicating that they haven't gone hard and are probably ok, but each change is still felt through the brake pedal.
Just reading up on that as mine screech a bit if it's dry. Not sure if the situation has changed but the E39 uses a special connector so you *may not be able to get them to fit...

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
The plethora of rattles despite 25k miles and 2.5 years of age had a big play in my early hatred for the 335i I bought last year and one of the reasons why I decided to get rid of it so soon after buying it. It rattled more than my 200,000 mile 10 year old 530i does despite costing many, many times more money and being a low mileage, young Approved Used Car. I have no doubt that I could have got the rattles fixed but frankly the fact it even developed them in the first place at 25k miles worried me greatly.

I rented an F10 M5 last month - absolutely epic car in almost every way but I was very suprised at how cheap feeling the plastics were around the base of the door cards..

I don't really understand why they seem to miss the level of quality present in the older models? How hard can it be? They nailed it in 1996 so why does it now elude them?

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
My 330D E91 (2009) is beautifully put together. Not a creak or rattle anywhere at any speed - and still have the RFTs. It even has the panaoramic sunroof which is superb, not a sound from it.

halo34

2,890 posts

230 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
My 330D E91 (2009) is beautifully put together. Not a creak or rattle anywhere at any speed - and still have the RFTs. It even has the panaoramic sunroof which is superb, not a sound from it.
I had no rattles, problems with build quality or anything during my time with my E90 (now sold).

Probably best built car have owned bar Volvo V70 I used to have.

my E46 was terrible in comparison.

Stevie750iL

100 posts

180 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
My last E39 523iT had well over 294k miles on the clock without a squeak or a rattle. My "new" 130k mile 540iT is much the same. But it does have a thirst for the north sea stuff!!

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
They don't make 'em like they used to.

If you want properly 'solid' BMWs you need to go back to the days of the E34/E32 imo.

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
My E36 bought almost new in 1998 still drives like new with no squeaks or rattles. They built them properly back then and I have not been impressed by the interiors of newer and far more expensive BMWs that I have driven since.

Sorry OP frown
I've had a few E36 and they varied a lot. Stuff like mystery rattles seems to depend a lot on road quality and also how fastidious the mechanics that have worked on the car over the years have been.

M888SXY

312 posts

188 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
I've owned E36 and E46.
Currently own E92 and E39.

Just taking the 3-series, in my opinion the quality of the E92 is better than the E46, which is light years ahead of the E36.

bennyboydurham

1,617 posts

205 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Have an E92 and an E65. The 3 is 3 years newer and has a quarter of the mileage of the 7 but feels nothing like as well screwed together.