F10 5-series questions
F10 5-series questions
Author
Discussion

Roo3Stuart

Original Poster:

307 posts

191 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Afternoon all

I'm planning on changing my E60 530d M Sport for a the latest F10 and have a couple of questions.

I'm leaning towards the 535d but is that 'necessary'? I only real use the car for commuting on motorways and A roads and never feel my current car is too slow. But it just seems wrong to not choose the extra power and flexibility of the twin turbo. Any thoughts/experiences appreciated.

Adaptive drive/VDC - really necessary? Seems a bit of a waste of money to me, current car is just fine on normal sport suspension, as is the wife's X3.

Thanks in advance.

14-7

6,233 posts

222 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Have a drive of a 530d with the 8 speed auto box. Absolutely fantastic car and personally the one I would go for If you do mostly motorway miles.

s2000db

1,428 posts

184 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
I've got a 535d with msport suspension, based in Germany at the moment, what would you like to know?

Apart from, it's very quick, it's very economical (40 mpg), the suspension is just right, and the many toys are great fun and useful... HUD, prof sat nav, adaptive lights etc

Roo3Stuart

Original Poster:

307 posts

191 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
s2000db said:
I've got a 535d with msport suspension, based in Germany at the moment, what would you like to know?

Apart from, it's very quick, it's very economical (40 mpg), the suspension is just right, and the many toys are great fun and useful... HUD, prof sat nav, adaptive lights etc
Mainly interested in whether you have normal sport suspension or any of the fancy clever stuff (that seems quite pricey). I'd definitely go for all the other extra as you have. Thanks

s2000db

1,428 posts

184 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Yes just the normal Msport suspension, with no electronic adjustment. I believe it's 15mm lower and as far as I can tell having driven a 525 with the adjustable dampers seems about as taught as it did on sport, with a touch more absorption and control..
Also there's no perceptible turbo lag, which I did notice with the smaller engines..

Roo3Stuart

Original Poster:

307 posts

191 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks both for your input, it's helped with my thinking.

sp222

203 posts

180 months

Sunday 14th October 2012
quotequote all
Hey - I went from an E61 525 MSport Touring to an F10 (F11?) 530d MSport Touring in June. Mine doesn't have the adaptive suspension. I would have liked to have tried it, but there were only 2 or 3 530D touring available when I was looking for mine.

I get the impression that it's the kind of option that you sometimes wonder if the car would be that much better if it had it.

The new car is a little less sharp than the old one (I have/had them both on run flats as standard etc), but the new one is much more refined - wind and tyre noise is down considerably. The price of this is that as I said above, the steering isn't quite as detailed.

you do adapt to it though, so when I'm not driving with the family and two dogs, you can still enjoy the handling.

As for 530d vs 535d - I think if I had the budget I would go for the 535, but i don't feel that i'm missing out for 95% of the time.

I've put on about 7k miles since June and it's been a great place to be - just don't let your kids put a coin in the CD Drive - a new one is £650, as I found out!!

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 14th October 2012
quotequote all
I have a 530D MSport touring with 8 speed box, 19 inch wheels and adaptive ride. Much quicker than my old E61 530d and I dd not feel the extra from the 535 warranted the money. I rarely take the adaptive ride out of normal. It is crap in comfort, and very focused in Sport. But it is the flat cornering due to adaptive ARBs that sold it to me - and much less understeer than the E61. Downside is at it sits a bit higher than standard M Sport.

Overall an incredible car - effortless and very refined.

Wills2

29,950 posts

206 months

Sunday 14th October 2012
quotequote all

If you want your F10 to drive as a BMW should then you need adaptive drive, the difference is night and day even between a VDC equipped car.

An f10 on standard suspension is the best Mercedes BMW have ever made.

Roo3Stuart

Original Poster:

307 posts

191 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
I'm just struggling with nearly £3k for suspension. Surely the normal ride is fine, especially as I only really use it motorway and DC driving?

Milky Joe

3,851 posts

235 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
14-7 said:
Have a drive of a 530d with the 8 speed auto box. Absolutely fantastic car and personally the one I would go for
yes

I know it's not very PH to say but the 530d has more than enough grunt.

Wills2

29,950 posts

206 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
Roo3Stuart said:
I'm just struggling with nearly £3k for suspension. Surely the normal ride is fine, especially as I only really use it motorway and DC driving?
I have VDC and the ride is excellent (see my Mercedes comment) but sharp and sporty it is not, adaptive drive goes a long way to making it handle like a BMW should.

All depends what you are looking for, I didn't have the chance to spec adaptive drive as it was only available on the 530d and above but after trying one recently I would have done had it been available. (if that makes sense)

A 530d with adaptive drive is a wonderful car.

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
Roo3Stuart said:
I'm just struggling with nearly £3k for suspension. Surely the normal ride is fine, especially as I only really use it motorway and DC driving?
I have VDC and the ride is excellent (see my Mercedes comment) but sharp and sporty it is not, adaptive drive goes a long way to making it handle like a BMW should.

All depends what you are looking for, I didn't have the chance to spec adaptive drive as it was only available on the 530d and above but after trying one recently I would have done had it been available. (if that makes sense)

A 530d with adaptive drive is a wonderful car.
If you are a big motorway driver, please don't think you'll be getting a dog of a car if you go with the standard suspension.

I'm sure that adaptive suspension is great, it should be for £3k.

I've got an F11 on standard (SE) suspension and it rides and handles just fine as I'm concerned. It's firmer than the current E Class and about the same firmness as a S Line A6 but out handles both of them.

Good luck.

Wills2

29,950 posts

206 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
A900ss said:
If you are a big motorway driver, please don't think you'll be getting a dog of a car if you go with the standard suspension.

I'm sure that adaptive suspension is great, it should be for £3k.

I've got an F11 on standard (SE) suspension and it rides and handles just fine as I'm concerned. It's firmer than the current E Class and about the same firmness as a S Line A6 but out handles both of them.

Good luck.
It's a great motorway car, whisper quiet and very stable, in no way is any f10/f11 a dog, but if you're coming from an e60 the handling will disappoint hence my comments.

As for the A6 S line that has rocks for springs and an engine in the front bumper so not much of a match. biggrin


Edited by Wills2 on Monday 15th October 19:54

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
As for the A6 S line that has rocks for springs and an engine in the front bumper so not much of a match. biggrin


Edited by Wills2 on Monday 15th October 19:54
I don't know if you've driven the new A6 or not.

I have driven one for about 2,000 miles and was amazed. Totally different to the previous shape and a much more compliant suspension, even on the 19 inch wheels mine had.

I woudn't have thought it but if I was choosing saloon versus saloon, I would have gone with the Audi. As it turned out, I could get a 5 series touring for the same as the A6 saloon and that is what made my mind up.

The new A6 is much better than the old one.

Wills2

29,950 posts

206 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all

I'd forgotten they'd brought out a new A6, so I'll bow to your first hand knowledge, however in FWD guise it's still driving the wrong wheels with an engine in the wrong place.

I'm not an Audi hater (having owned an allroad) but for a 35k car once you've put on a bit of spec to have front wheel drive and an engine out over the front axle doesn't cut the mustard IMO especially if they are still mating it to that awful CVT gearbox.








Roo3Stuart

Original Poster:

307 posts

191 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
All very interesting! I like the ride in my E60 M Sport and we also have an X3 M Sport without VDC or anything which rides well. The X3 is the 30d with the 8 speed box and is very impressive. However I set myself a budget and am still leaning towards 535d rather than adaptive drive and still not hearing anything enough to convince me I won't love the car on standard sport suspension, particularly as that's what I'm used to.

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Monday 15th October 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
I'd forgotten they'd brought out a new A6, so I'll bow to your first hand knowledge, however in FWD guise it's still driving the wrong wheels


Can't deny that. smile