Anyone got a Compact?
Anyone got a Compact?
Author
Discussion

dhutch

Original Poster:

17,962 posts

228 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Trying to buy a E36 compact.
- Anyone got anything for sale, thoughts or suggestions, things to look out for?
- Guide price for average but functional n-reg with 150k on the clocks?

Leins

10,515 posts

179 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Great cars, I've had three, although only one of them was an E36. Wouldn't have thought there would be a huge difference in price between them all now, so I'd be looking for a clean '99 or '00 318ti 1.9 Sport if I were you, preferably in Avus or Techno Violet. They look much nicer than std or SE IMO, and carry better spec. There was a Dakar Edition at the very end too

dhutch

Original Poster:

17,962 posts

228 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Budget is around the £800 mark really, and im quite struck on it being a bright colour, red/midblue/etc, which is why im looking for higher millage offerings.

Origanally started another thread, but whats you thought on this rubber at the bottom of the windscreen?
- Photos are awfull, but is this a common issue? Or would I be able to find a good one in a scrap yard? Easy fit? Doesnt appear to effect the sealing but looks mess.




Leins

10,515 posts

179 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
There seem to be pretty much two types of E36 Compacts left now:

- the well-maintained, well-specced one that costs a few quid more
- the cheap one that's either been modified badly, not serviced properly, is getting eaten by rust now in the wheel-arches, or all of the above

Most of these were private buys when new, and generally looked after properly for the first 5-6 years. What happened them afterwards is anyone's guess, but I still know of a couple of 1-owner cars around that do small mileage and are well looked after


This one looks interesting for < £1000, but really I'd say forget about the colour choice and get the best one you can for your money:

http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds/use...

Not sure what's going on in that picture. Rust in the scuttle?

n_const

1,826 posts

232 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Can i ask why your thinking of a compact rather than a coupe or saloon ? For that money youll get a better spec and better engine.

Leins

10,515 posts

179 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
n_const said:
Can i ask why your thinking of a compact rather than a coupe or saloon ? For that money youll get a better spec and better engine.
Whilst I understand where you're coming from, this is a question I got asked all the time as many people just don't get the appeal of the Compact. I much preferred my last 325ti to the car I replaced it with, the E92 335d. I never once wished I had bought a 330ci instead either. Not as quick, but a rawer and more entertaining drive

If I was to go back to a 4-cyl E36, I would chose the 318ti over a 318iS saloon or coupe, again as it's rawer and I love the looks (subjective, I know smile)

With regards to saloons, would you suggest to someone looking for a Golf GTi that they buy a Passat instead? Slightly different scenario, but still this is the appeal of the hatchback

dhutch

Original Poster:

17,962 posts

228 months

Friday 19th October 2012
quotequote all
Here what your saying about forgetting the colour but this is always going to be a bit of a 'follow your heart and do man-maths to make it seem sensable' purchase otherwise and the colour matters in that.

The photos awfull, but its not rust, its just a rotten scuttle (good word) cover/trim thing which appears common, apprently spares are available which was my main worry, although im yet to actaully find anywhere that has one. What are BMW like as new spares? Obviously there would be a premium, but would they likely stock such a thing? £50, £150?

Compact because I need the boot space (folding seats and full tailgate) but dont want a Touring, and because actaully I quite like the quirky looks and dont need the larger engine.


Daniel

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 19th October 2012
quotequote all
Compacts are okay, but the newest one is now 12 years old and most are tired. They don't rust as badly as the Coupe/Saloon can (particularly rear arches) but have plenty of issues. Window regulators are a common fail, as are rear axle beam bushes (a £100 fix) plus front outer balljoints, tailgate gas struts etc. Many have whiney diffs.
The 316i is a waste of time unless you stumble across a minter for the right money. They are so cheap now that a 318Ti is the only one worth the bother. They have the same fuel economy (30-35 average and 38-40 on a steady run) and go a LOT better. The old M-N reg M42 1.8's are rare now but there are loads of 1.9 Ti's around. The engine is much better and doesn't suffer the headgasket issues that the single cam M43 does.
The S/T reg onwards 316i 1.9 has the E46 engine and with it comes the MAF that fails as well as the E46 ASC/ABS ECU, plus they are just as prone to head gasket failure. They love to piss oil out of the oil filter to block gasket as well, a boring job to sort out. Again - just buy a 318Ti.
Sport models from late 1997 with the half leather sports seats, M3 style bumpers, black headliner, clear lights, sports suspension and 16 inch wheels are worth having and £800 might buy a tidy one.

These cars are basically cheap bangers now and you may struggle to find one that's decent and up together. But a good one is cheap to run and pretty robust. I have a 1.9 Ti Sport in the purply blue metallic, not a bad old stter with 165'000 miles and it's a useful old tram.