E46 330d - Coupe vs Saloon
Discussion
I'm thinking my next car should be an E46 330d - I currently have an MG ZT CDTi (same engine as the 320d*) and want something a bit more powerful and RWD
I was originally after a saloon, but thinking about it I think the coupe looks much better. What differences are there between the two (the coupe is much more expensive!)? Does the coupe handle any better?
Also, what were the differences that the facelift brought? I've also noticed there are SE / Sport models, where the differences just visual or was the suspension etc different?
Also, are there any common failures or issues I should be looking out for? I'm ok with spanners so I can sort out *some* issues myself (i.e. swirlflaps etc) but not everything!
I was originally after a saloon, but thinking about it I think the coupe looks much better. What differences are there between the two (the coupe is much more expensive!)? Does the coupe handle any better?
Also, what were the differences that the facelift brought? I've also noticed there are SE / Sport models, where the differences just visual or was the suspension etc different?
Also, are there any common failures or issues I should be looking out for? I'm ok with spanners so I can sort out *some* issues myself (i.e. swirlflaps etc) but not everything!
- same engine, different turbo's, but mine has ~160HP
Edited by Jakg on Thursday 18th October 16:35
The sport models have a bodykit, a fatter steering wheel, and firmer suspension and 18" wheels. The larger wheels and tighter suspension don't seem to be to all tastes, but I've come to like them on mine, even though the roads round my way are pretty poor. The ride is pleasingly firm, rather than bone-shattering, and certainly keeps the car very level compared to the normal suspension.
I'm not sure what changes came with the facelift, apart from the facelift bits of course, but unlike the 320d the engine didn't change straight away, so if you just go by appearance you could still get the older 185hp engine even if you buy a facelift model. (I think you can tell by the manual gearbox - 5 speed = 185hp, and 6 speed = 205hp.)
I'm not sure what changes came with the facelift, apart from the facelift bits of course, but unlike the 320d the engine didn't change straight away, so if you just go by appearance you could still get the older 185hp engine even if you buy a facelift model. (I think you can tell by the manual gearbox - 5 speed = 185hp, and 6 speed = 205hp.)
philmots said:
Remap 260hp/400lbft
Sounds tasty!!Any idea where to get that done?? And is that a dyno'd result, or remappers exaggeration??
Oh, sorry for wandering off-topic OP, I have the coupe in M Sport flavour... because I love the shape. I really do think that E46 coupes are some of the best looking cars around, especially in Silver Grey (although mine is Sapphire Black :-(
Cheers,
Effortless.
to3m said:
The sport models have a bodykit, a fatter steering wheel, and firmer suspension and 18" wheels. The larger wheels and tighter suspension don't seem to be to all tastes, but I've come to like them on mine, even though the roads round my way are pretty poor. The ride is pleasingly firm, rather than bone-shattering, and certainly keeps the car very level compared to the normal suspension.
I'm not sure what changes came with the facelift, apart from the facelift bits of course, but unlike the 320d the engine didn't change straight away, so if you just go by appearance you could still get the older 185hp engine even if you buy a facelift model. (I think you can tell by the manual gearbox - 5 speed = 185hp, and 6 speed = 205hp.)
Nah, both were 6-speed, and to be a real pedant, they were 184 & 204 I'm not sure what changes came with the facelift, apart from the facelift bits of course, but unlike the 320d the engine didn't change straight away, so if you just go by appearance you could still get the older 185hp engine even if you buy a facelift model. (I think you can tell by the manual gearbox - 5 speed = 185hp, and 6 speed = 205hp.)

Jakg said:
And another quick question.
Theres the 5-speed 184HP version & the 6-speed 204HP version. How do you tell them apart?
Look at the gear stick.Theres the 5-speed 184HP version & the 6-speed 204HP version. How do you tell them apart?
If you can get the VIN, look it up in a decoder such as http://bmwvin.com/ - the 184hp one is 2,926cc, and the 204hp one is 2,993. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_3_Series_(E46)#Di...
I have a 330d SE Saloon and my mum has a 320Cd SE Coupé which I get to drive quite often. They do drive broadly similarly, if anything the Coupe is a bit more chuckable and a bit keener to respond, but I believe the E46's Coupés all came with Sport suspension, so this may explain it. I prefer the looks of the Saloon personally so went with that, but there isn't a huge difference. I'd just go with whichever one you fancy.
What differences are there in terms of long term ownership of the 184 or 204 BHP versions ?
I see various ominous warnings of "Large costs repairing the far more complex new high pressure Diesel engines" ... but not a lot of adverts mentioning £WXYZ bills for repairing the so and so.
Is the BMW 3.0D a good high mile runner, or a moneypit ?
I see various ominous warnings of "Large costs repairing the far more complex new high pressure Diesel engines" ... but not a lot of adverts mentioning £WXYZ bills for repairing the so and so.
Is the BMW 3.0D a good high mile runner, or a moneypit ?
to3m said:
Look at the gear stick.
If you can get the VIN, look it up in a decoder such as http://bmwvin.com/ - the 184hp one is 2,926cc, and the 204hp one is 2,993. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_3_Series_(E46)#Di...
I was thinking more about if I saw one on autotrader, where I wouldn't be able to see the gearstick / VINIf you can get the VIN, look it up in a decoder such as http://bmwvin.com/ - the 184hp one is 2,926cc, and the 204hp one is 2,993. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_3_Series_(E46)#Di...
Jakg said:
to3m said:
Look at the gear stick.
If you can get the VIN, look it up in a decoder such as http://bmwvin.com/ - the 184hp one is 2,926cc, and the 204hp one is 2,993. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_3_Series_(E46)#Di...
I was thinking more about if I saw one on autotrader, where I wouldn't be able to see the gearstick / VINIf you can get the VIN, look it up in a decoder such as http://bmwvin.com/ - the 184hp one is 2,926cc, and the 204hp one is 2,993. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_3_Series_(E46)#Di...
Pre-facelift ones are always 184hp. Facelift vs pre-facelift: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/BMW_E46
More differences: http://mukerji.co.uk/2011/05/22/e46-330d-compariso..., http://karalius.wordpress.com/2010/12/03/visual-di...
Hopefully you'll be able to find a suitable photo in each advert to check from - dashboard shots should be somewhat common I suppose, to show off the odometer. Though frankly I didn't find the photos very trustworthy when I was looking for my car - dealers tended not to bother with the dashboard and there were a number of people claiming climate control and cruise control, for example, when the photos appeared to suggest otherwise.
Edited by to3m on Saturday 20th October 18:01
Effortless said:
Sounds tasty!!
Any idea where to get that done?? And is that a dyno'd result, or remappers exaggeration??
Oh, sorry for wandering off-topic OP, I have the coupe in M Sport flavour... because I love the shape. I really do think that E46 coupes are some of the best looking cars around, especially in Silver Grey (although mine is Sapphire Black :-(
Cheers,
Effortless.
Mine just made 271bhp at surrey rolling road, I have tried a few maps on the car to see how it responds, the advantage of doing my own remap means I can change them as like. Any idea where to get that done?? And is that a dyno'd result, or remappers exaggeration??
Oh, sorry for wandering off-topic OP, I have the coupe in M Sport flavour... because I love the shape. I really do think that E46 coupes are some of the best looking cars around, especially in Silver Grey (although mine is Sapphire Black :-(
Cheers,
Effortless.
I bought the coupe because I like the look better, I think for me if I wanted it to be more practical I would have got a touring, but the seats still fold in the coupe giving it good carrying capacity for awkward shaped items.
998420 said:
What differences are there in terms of long term ownership of the 184 or 204 BHP versions ?
I see various ominous warnings of "Large costs repairing the far more complex new high pressure Diesel engines" ... but not a lot of adverts mentioning £WXYZ bills for repairing the so and so.
Is the BMW 3.0D a good high mile runner, or a moneypit ?
Most certainly, have had my 330d manual since new 2001, just turned 255k miles and still drives well every day.I see various ominous warnings of "Large costs repairing the far more complex new high pressure Diesel engines" ... but not a lot of adverts mentioning £WXYZ bills for repairing the so and so.
Is the BMW 3.0D a good high mile runner, or a moneypit ?
Clutch changed at 230k miles and just the normal wear and tear repairs apart from changing a cracked inlet manifold at 200k.
Give me another e46 330d manual before any of the newer models. (just cant find a good manual one)
Someone will no doubt correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the swirlflaps are only fitted to automatics? So if you're looking for a manual, it won't be an issue.
I'm sure you've already considered this, but do you definitely do enough miles to warrant a diesel?
There are plenty of E46 330i and 330Ci out there, both of which have 231 BHP stock. Although you need to keep on top of the cooling system, there's probably a lot less to go wrong with the M54 petrol engine.
Mine will be 11 years old in January, and will still manage between 35-40MPG on a motorway run, depending on how much of a rush I'm in. I know the 330d will manage a few more MPG than that, but how much more in the real world?
Fair enough if you love diesel power delivery etc, but I think people can often underestimate the fuel economy that the M54 petrol engine can deliver if driven sensibly.
In terms of the comparison between the saloon and Coupe. Bizarrely, in some ways the Coupe is more practical. For example, split folding rear seats were standard on Coupe, but an option on the saloon.
I'm sure you've already considered this, but do you definitely do enough miles to warrant a diesel?
There are plenty of E46 330i and 330Ci out there, both of which have 231 BHP stock. Although you need to keep on top of the cooling system, there's probably a lot less to go wrong with the M54 petrol engine.
Mine will be 11 years old in January, and will still manage between 35-40MPG on a motorway run, depending on how much of a rush I'm in. I know the 330d will manage a few more MPG than that, but how much more in the real world?
Fair enough if you love diesel power delivery etc, but I think people can often underestimate the fuel economy that the M54 petrol engine can deliver if driven sensibly.
In terms of the comparison between the saloon and Coupe. Bizarrely, in some ways the Coupe is more practical. For example, split folding rear seats were standard on Coupe, but an option on the saloon.
The swirl flaps were fitted to all the 3.0 diesels afaik.
When I was looking at 330/330d, the difference between the 184/204 can be seen if you look on the details on autotrader etc - the 184bhp engine is technically a 2.9, the 204 version nearly a 3.0. There are other minor differences on the engine cover but this depends on the photos available I guess.
When I was looking at 330/330d, the difference between the 184/204 can be seen if you look on the details on autotrader etc - the 184bhp engine is technically a 2.9, the 204 version nearly a 3.0. There are other minor differences on the engine cover but this depends on the photos available I guess.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


