E36 or E39 (what car thread, *groan*)
Discussion
Do you prefer or sporty or bargey driving experience?
Do you want an auto or manual? Manual E39s are fairly rare!
E39s will be better specified but I suspect a touch more to maintain (they are harder on suspension components etc).
E39s will ride better and be smoother.
E36s will be sharper and more fun to drive (esp in 328i Sport guise).
Both are susceptible to rust, early E36s especially.
I'd say the E39 has a nicer (slightly more modern) interior.
E36 328s will only be available with the M52 2.8 (single vanos). Later E39s will have the M52TU with double vanos. The earlier engine has tuning potential (BBTB/M50 inlet manifold), the later will be more punchy out of the box.
E36 tourings are nice (just bought one) and very practical. E39 tourings have autolevel rear suspension which I hear can be ££££ if it fails.
At 1.5k I think you can get a decent E36. E39s at the price range might be a touch on the ropey side.
I wanted a winter car and had a similar dilemma - ended up going for the E36. Had them in the past, as such know my way around them quite well, plus I think they'll be slightly cheaper to maintain than the E39. I'm only 29, 5er is a touch old man for me at the mo.
328i Touring (bought from PH calssifieds)

Do you want an auto or manual? Manual E39s are fairly rare!
E39s will be better specified but I suspect a touch more to maintain (they are harder on suspension components etc).
E39s will ride better and be smoother.
E36s will be sharper and more fun to drive (esp in 328i Sport guise).
Both are susceptible to rust, early E36s especially.
I'd say the E39 has a nicer (slightly more modern) interior.
E36 328s will only be available with the M52 2.8 (single vanos). Later E39s will have the M52TU with double vanos. The earlier engine has tuning potential (BBTB/M50 inlet manifold), the later will be more punchy out of the box.
E36 tourings are nice (just bought one) and very practical. E39 tourings have autolevel rear suspension which I hear can be ££££ if it fails.
At 1.5k I think you can get a decent E36. E39s at the price range might be a touch on the ropey side.
I wanted a winter car and had a similar dilemma - ended up going for the E36. Had them in the past, as such know my way around them quite well, plus I think they'll be slightly cheaper to maintain than the E39. I'm only 29, 5er is a touch old man for me at the mo.
328i Touring (bought from PH calssifieds)

Edited by g3org3y on Wednesday 31st October 19:28
Fox- said:
rumple said:
E36 328 Sport, or a E39 530 Sport, I'd have the best example of which one I found first, that is if I couldn't find a decent M3 EVO.
You could hear a 1500 quid 530 Sport barking from miles away. This money is best spent on a earlier 528i SE.A good E39 is a (properly) wonderful thing. A bad one is a costly nightmare.
E36 328 or E39 528 is the toss up imo.
g3org3y said:
Fox- said:
rumple said:
E36 328 Sport, or a E39 530 Sport, I'd have the best example of which one I found first, that is if I couldn't find a decent M3 EVO.
You could hear a 1500 quid 530 Sport barking from miles away. This money is best spent on a earlier 528i SE.A good E39 is a (properly) wonderful thing. A bad one is a costly nightmare.
E36 328 or E39 528 is the toss up imo.
Have had a 328 Sport in the past and now wafting around in an auto E39 528. All in all the E39 is a substantially better car IMO. Everything feels far more polished and of a higher quality. The ride is much better, it's quieter and obviously interior and boot space is a lot better too. Only upside for the E36, and it's a biggy, is that they can be a really good fun car to drive. The E39 is for pure wafting.
Ren Esis said:
Thanks for the great replys, especially Georgey - you've made up my mind 
I've decided on the E36 preferably in a Manual Coupe guise. I know for £1500 I shouldn't expect a top of the range 328 Sport (although that's what I'm really after), and would be happy with a boggo standard looking one. It's the engine I'm more interested in.
I've read all of the topics I can find on the E36, but just wondering if there's any specific I should look out for when I go view the car. I know the basics such as checking the tyre tread, oil, filters etc but I'm not mechanically minded so would appricate any insight into specifics I should be checking. I also read about the engine recall so will be looking out for that first.
Also if anyone knows of anyone selling a 328 sport with no hidden gremlins, please let me know :P
In terms of what to look for specific to the E36.
I've decided on the E36 preferably in a Manual Coupe guise. I know for £1500 I shouldn't expect a top of the range 328 Sport (although that's what I'm really after), and would be happy with a boggo standard looking one. It's the engine I'm more interested in.
I've read all of the topics I can find on the E36, but just wondering if there's any specific I should look out for when I go view the car. I know the basics such as checking the tyre tread, oil, filters etc but I'm not mechanically minded so would appricate any insight into specifics I should be checking. I also read about the engine recall so will be looking out for that first.
Also if anyone knows of anyone selling a 328 sport with no hidden gremlins, please let me know :P
Rust is the first thing, particularly but not limited to: rear arches, bottom of doors and boot lid. Check inside the filler cap too.
Check all the electrical stuff works as it should, particularly the air con as compressor failures are common.
The cooling system is made of chocolate. Check the history to see what has been replaced and when. By 100k, I'd expect the waterpump, rad, thermostat and most of the pipework to have been changed or it'll likely need doing at some point.
Otherwise, just the usual checks.
Ren Esis said:
Thanks for the great replys, especially Georgey - you've made up my mind 
I've decided on the E36 preferably in a Manual Coupe guise. I know for £1500 I shouldn't expect a top of the range 328 Sport (although that's what I'm really after), and would be happy with a boggo standard looking one. It's the engine I'm more interested in.
I've read all of the topics I can find on the E36, but just wondering if there's any specific I should look out for when I go view the car. I know the basics such as checking the tyre tread, oil, filters etc but I'm not mechanically minded so would appricate any insight into specifics I should be checking. I also read about the engine recall so will be looking out for that first.
Also if anyone knows of anyone selling a 328 sport with no hidden gremlins, please let me know :P
M52 2.8 engine is a peach. I prefer the character of the earlier M50 2.5 you find in the 325i, but there's no denying the 2.8 is the better lump. It feels a little more lazy in its power and especially torque delivery but that makes the car deceptively fast.
I've decided on the E36 preferably in a Manual Coupe guise. I know for £1500 I shouldn't expect a top of the range 328 Sport (although that's what I'm really after), and would be happy with a boggo standard looking one. It's the engine I'm more interested in.
I've read all of the topics I can find on the E36, but just wondering if there's any specific I should look out for when I go view the car. I know the basics such as checking the tyre tread, oil, filters etc but I'm not mechanically minded so would appricate any insight into specifics I should be checking. I also read about the engine recall so will be looking out for that first.
Also if anyone knows of anyone selling a 328 sport with no hidden gremlins, please let me know :P
Things to look out for:
- Rust: All E36s do it, earlier ones are worse. Rear arches are the main culprits. If caught early can be dealt with superficially. Otherwise may need a new arch cut/welded in.
- Waterpumps: E36 waterpumps typically came with a plastic impeller. These have a habit of failing spectacularly and cooking the engine. As such, replacement with a metal impellered version is essential. Worth also doing the belts (a/c & fan)at the same time.
- Nikasil. Issue up until the 10th week (I think of 1998). Tbh, if it hasn't failed by now, it's unlikely to. My touring above is a Nikasil engined car.
- Rear top mounts can fail. Iirc, you can get the later E46 convertible top mounts as replacements as they are stronger.

(When one of mine failed on a grand scale!)
- Fan motor: If it is only blowing on setting 3-4, likely to need a new hedgehog resistor.
- E36s ime (esp on 17s) have a habit of wearing the inner edge of their tyres on the rear. Worth checking.
- Buy a car with the full 18 button OBC. Anything else looks rubbish owing to the blank areas.
- Otherwise imo the E36 is a very decent car that you can run quite cheaply and work on it yourself. Oil changes are straightforward as the filter is at the top of the engine (unlike the older M20 on the E30). Spark plug changes take a little longer as each coil pack needs to be removed individually.
I have such faith in my E36 that I'm driving it to Berlin next week. I've only owned it 2 months!
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


