e46 320cd stiff gear help.
e46 320cd stiff gear help.
Author
Discussion

wezzer-45's

Original Poster:

187 posts

234 months

Wednesday 31st October 2012
quotequote all
Evening all.

I have a 2005 320cd with 60k on it, and as the weather is getting colder, my gears are getting more difficult to select. Mainly 1st and reverse. I find that selecting 2nd then 1st makes it easier.

It gets a bit better when warm but still stiff.

I was going to replace the oil first (before the clutch)and was wondering if there are any other oils that will improve the shift quality, I read somewhere about Redline MTL being used in BMW boxes and was wondering if anyone else has had the same problems and what were the solutions.

Thanks in advance for your input.


nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Wednesday 31st October 2012
quotequote all
I had exactly the same problem with my last M3.
It was rusty splines which make it stick, the problem is you need to take the gearbox off to clean it and lubricate so you may aswell change the clutch while its off.
To prove its this, when you start in the morning depress clutch and try to select 1st, if it wont go in try 4th, but dont let the clutch out. Now try 1st and it should go in.
Changing the oil wont help if this is the problem.

Edited by nottyash on Wednesday 31st October 21:21

AlfaSpider

231 posts

229 months

Wednesday 31st October 2012
quotequote all
My 330D suffers in the same way when cold I guess its to do with the oil viscosity and the syncromesh. I had to fit a new clutch recently and its made no difference whatsoever. I did however change the gearbox oil for what opi oils recommended and noticed a slight improvement.

wezzer-45's

Original Poster:

187 posts

234 months

Thursday 1st November 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies guys.

I spoke to a chap from a company called JC Racing earlier today. I used them last year to rebuild my old M3 gearbox.

They told me that they have a 320d there with the same problem that I am having and that they are removing the box as they think there is a clutch issue.

I got a clutch on order today along with a spigot bearing. I plan to fit it next Saturday and ill post to let you know the outcome.

nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Thursday 1st November 2012
quotequote all
wezzer-45's said:
Thanks for the replies guys.

I spoke to a chap from a company called JC Racing earlier today. I used them last year to rebuild my old M3 gearbox.

They told me that they have a 320d there with the same problem that I am having and that they are removing the box as they think there is a clutch issue.

I got a clutch on order today along with a spigot bearing. I plan to fit it next Saturday and ill post to let you know the outcome.
As I said earlier its not actually the clutch, so just changing this will not sort it.
Its rusty splines, which will stick especially when cold.

I couldnt even select reverse or first withough first selecting a higher gear, then it would go in fine.

wezzer-45's

Original Poster:

187 posts

234 months

Saturday 10th November 2012
quotequote all
I replaced the clutch earlier today along with the oil

I noticed that there was very little wear evident on the friction plate but the reliese bearing and the tube that it moves along had slight corrosion on it.

The splines were clean and the plate moved freely on them.

So the new clutch is fitted and the box filled with red line MTL oil and what a difference there is.

The selection issue has now gone and goes into gear easier than ever. The pedal is also much lighter.

I think the oil may have helped the slickness of the box but the selection of 1st and reverse was down to the clutch in someway or another.

For the sake of £200 for the clutch and oil, it's transformed the car.

wezzer-45's

Original Poster:

187 posts

234 months

Saturday 10th November 2012
quotequote all
I replaced the clutch earlier today along with the oil

I noticed that there was very little wear evident on the friction plate but the reliese bearing and the tube that it moves along had slight corrosion on it.

The splines were clean and the plate moved freely on them.

So the new clutch is fitted and the box filled with red line MTL oil and what a difference there is.

The selection issue has now gone and goes into gear easier than ever. The pedal is also much lighter.

I think the oil may have helped the slickness of the box but the selection of 1st and reverse was down to the clutch in someway or another.

For the sake of £200 for the clutch and oil, it's transformed the car.


Edited by wezzer-45's on Saturday 10th November 18:30