5 Series with 3 kids, budget around £8k
Discussion
I really like the look of the E60 BMW 5 series, and wanted to find out whether anyone else runs one of these and has 3 kids. We would have 2 kiddie seats (Recaro, quite wide with the side bolsters etc) either side of the back seat, and a booster on the front passenger seat, so the gap between the two rear child seats would need to be big enough to accomodate an adult in relative comfort.
Anyone else have 3 kids and a 5 series? have an MPV currently and would much prefer a nice saloon, if the Beemer would be wide enough then it'd be perfect, although I do appreciate with only £8k as a budget Id be looking at high milers (avoid?)
The 3 series would be an alternative in touring form, but having looked inside (though not actually tried the seats in etc) I doubt it'd offer enough space between the seats to be practicle, although if anyone has made it work it would mean the budget would get us a slightly younger car.
Cheers
Anyone else have 3 kids and a 5 series? have an MPV currently and would much prefer a nice saloon, if the Beemer would be wide enough then it'd be perfect, although I do appreciate with only £8k as a budget Id be looking at high milers (avoid?)
The 3 series would be an alternative in touring form, but having looked inside (though not actually tried the seats in etc) I doubt it'd offer enough space between the seats to be practicle, although if anyone has made it work it would mean the budget would get us a slightly younger car.
Cheers
admittedly mine is an E39 so probably a little smaller between the doors but we have one rear facing seat, one full forward facing seat much like a recaro jobbie but had to find a slimmer booster seat for the 7 year old as his original one with side bolsters was too wide to fit in the centre spot
30 - 40cm is certainly not a lot, in fact I dont imagine that the 3 series would be much narrower in that regard at all (we had a Golf previously and that must've been about 30cm between seats).
We bought a slim booster seat (with sides, but narrow sides), about 43cm wide, but without smaller Recaros (we have the young sport too) I dont see it fitting in safely.
It's frustrating as we dont really use the car much with all 5 of us on board, so that little extra space in the MPV, although vital when you need it, is hardly ever used. We will be doing a few longish trips at some point though, so by the same token I dont want to end up with someone suffering in the middle.
Ive tried to find narrower child seats but they all seem to be around the same width, so might be worth me waiting until number 2 can go into a booster, that's a good few years off though.
We bought a slim booster seat (with sides, but narrow sides), about 43cm wide, but without smaller Recaros (we have the young sport too) I dont see it fitting in safely.
It's frustrating as we dont really use the car much with all 5 of us on board, so that little extra space in the MPV, although vital when you need it, is hardly ever used. We will be doing a few longish trips at some point though, so by the same token I dont want to end up with someone suffering in the middle.
Ive tried to find narrower child seats but they all seem to be around the same width, so might be worth me waiting until number 2 can go into a booster, that's a good few years off though.
I think you might struggle.
We have an E61 with a seat for my 1yr old and a booster for the 3yr old. They are both isofix mounts which seem to position the seat a few inches away from the door. My Mrs really struggled to squeeze into the middle seat recently, managed it but not good for a long journey.
Recently has use of an Audi A6 - they are much bigger inside, not a patch on the BMW to drive though.
We have an E61 with a seat for my 1yr old and a booster for the 3yr old. They are both isofix mounts which seem to position the seat a few inches away from the door. My Mrs really struggled to squeeze into the middle seat recently, managed it but not good for a long journey.
Recently has use of an Audi A6 - they are much bigger inside, not a patch on the BMW to drive though.
Zod said:
It won't work. I had an E60 M5 and it had to go when the third child arrived. There is not room for an adult to sit between two child seats in the rear. Even a six year old child would find it tight.
Thanks all, that is what I suspected, but hoped wouldnt be the case. Ill take a look at some A6's and see if they give a few cm's more room, but do prefer the Beemer.BananaBok said:
Zod said:
It won't work. I had an E60 M5 and it had to go when the third child arrived. There is not room for an adult to sit between two child seats in the rear. Even a six year old child would find it tight.
Thanks all, that is what I suspected, but hoped wouldnt be the case. Ill take a look at some A6's and see if they give a few cm's more room, but do prefer the Beemer.I've always wondered why people needed such big cars to carry little people - now I know. Child seats that are too big, and mounting points in the wrong place.
Back in the day, my dad had a succession of old-style Minis. We used to go on holiday 5-up, carrying 2 weeks luggage. 10 hour trip from London to Cornwall. Nowadays, you need a people carrier to get to the shops with 3 kids.
Back in the day, my dad had a succession of old-style Minis. We used to go on holiday 5-up, carrying 2 weeks luggage. 10 hour trip from London to Cornwall. Nowadays, you need a people carrier to get to the shops with 3 kids.
clockworks said:
I've always wondered why people needed such big cars to carry little people - now I know. Child seats that are too big, and mounting points in the wrong place.
Back in the day, my dad had a succession of old-style Minis. We used to go on holiday 5-up, carrying 2 weeks luggage. 10 hour trip from London to Cornwall. Nowadays, you need a people carrier to get to the shops with 3 kids.
There are laws dealing with these things now that were not in place then.Back in the day, my dad had a succession of old-style Minis. We used to go on holiday 5-up, carrying 2 weeks luggage. 10 hour trip from London to Cornwall. Nowadays, you need a people carrier to get to the shops with 3 kids.
Hi OP.
I recalled some time back seeing a bench that could be hooked up in the back of the car to increase capacity. Not sure it will help with your situation but it might be worth a quick look. I seem to remember we're pretty costly.
http://www.multimac.co.uk/home
Good luck.
I recalled some time back seeing a bench that could be hooked up in the back of the car to increase capacity. Not sure it will help with your situation but it might be worth a quick look. I seem to remember we're pretty costly.
http://www.multimac.co.uk/home
Good luck.
clockworks said:
I've always wondered why people needed such big cars to carry little people - now I know. Child seats that are too big, and mounting points in the wrong place.
Back in the day, my dad had a succession of old-style Minis. We used to go on holiday 5-up, carrying 2 weeks luggage. 10 hour trip from London to Cornwall. Nowadays, you need a people carrier to get to the shops with 3 kids.
My recaro young sport seats are belt in, but there still isnt enough room in the middle - the seats are awesomely comfortable and adjustable plus very robust - they are very good bits of kit.Back in the day, my dad had a succession of old-style Minis. We used to go on holiday 5-up, carrying 2 weeks luggage. 10 hour trip from London to Cornwall. Nowadays, you need a people carrier to get to the shops with 3 kids.
If you had a serious incident 5 up in an old style mini you'd come out a lot worse than 5 up in an e60!!
Theres a lot more traffic out there now, and people still cant drive properly so the odds are getting worse for a prang.
Interestingly I saw a slo mo of a mocked up crash with the child being held on a lap in the front of the car & no seat belts, the mum crushed the baby against the dash and then broke the wind screen with her head. not good.
I was being serious, and I realise that kids have to be carried in child seats or have booster cushions. I've always poo-poohed people who post how they need a really big car to carry kids. I didn't realise that a child seat took up so much room. To me, a car like the 5 series that can seat 5 adults should be capable of carrying 2 adults and 3 kids. The fact that it can't means there is something wrong with the design of the car, the seats, or both.
I wasn't suggesting that people should cram their car full of kids illegally, just pointing out that things were different back in the day. Safety is taken a lot more seriously now, but some aspects of car design haven't kept pace.
I wasn't suggesting that people should cram their car full of kids illegally, just pointing out that things were different back in the day. Safety is taken a lot more seriously now, but some aspects of car design haven't kept pace.
It's amazing how much space you really need to carry three kids in safety and in recognition of the legalities. The child seats have massive side impact bolsters on them, which are also good for the kids head to rest against when asleep (ie any car journey over 3 minutes). I must admit I feel happier knowing they have that extra protection, but the seats themselves take up more space than most adults!!
The 7 series is definitely going onto the list, have posted similar in the Audi forum and the general conscensus is that the A6 would be too small as well, so an A8 was suggested, so will take a look at both. Im thinking if Im going that route I will need to get a bigger budget together, think Id want to be looking at about £14k. Plus no doubt they carry higher insurance and running costs, and the price of paying a limo driver
The 7 series is definitely going onto the list, have posted similar in the Audi forum and the general conscensus is that the A6 would be too small as well, so an A8 was suggested, so will take a look at both. Im thinking if Im going that route I will need to get a bigger budget together, think Id want to be looking at about £14k. Plus no doubt they carry higher insurance and running costs, and the price of paying a limo driver

clockworks said:
I was being serious, and I realise that kids have to be carried in child seats or have booster cushions. I've always poo-poohed people who post how they need a really big car to carry kids. I didn't realise that a child seat took up so much room. To me, a car like the 5 series that can seat 5 adults should be capable of carrying 2 adults and 3 kids. The fact that it can't means there is something wrong with the design of the car, the seats, or both.
I wasn't suggesting that people should cram their car full of kids illegally, just pointing out that things were different back in the day. Safety is taken a lot more seriously now, but some aspects of car design haven't kept pace.
The space taken by childseats was one of the things I really hadn't expected when I became a father. Rear-facing baby seats are the worst - the smallest person takes the most space.I wasn't suggesting that people should cram their car full of kids illegally, just pointing out that things were different back in the day. Safety is taken a lot more seriously now, but some aspects of car design haven't kept pace.
BananaBok said:
It's amazing how much space you really need to carry three kids in safety and in recognition of the legalities. The child seats have massive side impact bolsters on them, which are also good for the kids head to rest against when asleep (ie any car journey over 3 minutes). I must admit I feel happier knowing they have that extra protection, but the seats themselves take up more space than most adults!!
The 7 series is definitely going onto the list, have posted similar in the Audi forum and the general conscensus is that the A6 would be too small as well, so an A8 was suggested, so will take a look at both. Im thinking if Im going that route I will need to get a bigger budget together, think Id want to be looking at about £14k. Plus no doubt they carry higher insurance and running costs, and the price of paying a limo driver
I thought about the 7 Series, but determined that too was too narrow across the rear bench (in retrospect, it woudl have been quite an odd school run car).The 7 series is definitely going onto the list, have posted similar in the Audi forum and the general conscensus is that the A6 would be too small as well, so an A8 was suggested, so will take a look at both. Im thinking if Im going that route I will need to get a bigger budget together, think Id want to be looking at about £14k. Plus no doubt they carry higher insurance and running costs, and the price of paying a limo driver

AS a result, my wife reluctantly became the cliche North London school run Mum in an SUV.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


