Quick query re. an estimate I've had.
Quick query re. an estimate I've had.
Author
Discussion

gazchap

Original Poster:

1,546 posts

214 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
For those who browse the M Power forum, you'll perhaps know of my current woes with my E60 M5, requiring a clutch and flywheel replacement.

I've had an estimate for the repair, and there's a couple of labour items on the estimate that I'm not sure about. The BMW tech I spoke to yesterday at my local dealer suggested that this might be wrong, but just wondered if any of you guys would know...

First one is "Remove and install SMG gearbox", at £379.37 ex VAT. It has "44" in the AW column on the estimate, whatever that means.
Second one is "Remove and install or replace clutch disc", at £439.73 ex VAT. "51" in the AW column.

Now, the question is, is that first one necessary? Would that not be part of the second one anyway?

BMWTech

13 posts

170 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
1 AW is BMW 5 minutes. 12aw's = 1 hour (5x12=60). The 2 different times would be for 2 separate jobs. If they have the gearbox out in 44aw's (approx 4 hours) then they won't charge another 4 hours to replace the clutch as the 'box is already out.

Hope that helps wink

gazchap

Original Poster:

1,546 posts

214 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
BMWTech said:
1 AW is BMW 5 minutes. 12aw's = 1 hour (5x12=60). The 2 different times would be for 2 separate jobs. If they have the gearbox out in 44aw's (approx 4 hours) then they won't charge another 4 hours to replace the clutch as the 'box is already out.

Hope that helps wink
Cheers - so, essentially, the second item on the list, removing and replacing the clutch disc, includes the labour from the first item so the first item can be removed?

BMWTech

13 posts

170 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Correct. It's a nasty job that nobody likes, but it only around 5 hours MAX (60aw's) from car on ramp to car off ramp.

There may be a few problems, but they have quoted 51aw's which seems fair.

To give you an example, a binding calliper that has worn down the brake pad/disc is a 12aw job to remove/strip/clean etc and to replace a set of discs and pads on that axle is also 12aw's. Yet because the calliper has to be removed to replace the discs anyway, we would quote 18 aw's instead of 24 (if that makes sense to you?).

gazchap

Original Poster:

1,546 posts

214 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
BMWTech said:
Correct. It's a nasty job that nobody likes, but it only around 5 hours MAX (60aw's) from car on ramp to car off ramp.

There may be a few problems, but they have quoted 51aw's which seems fair.

To give you an example, a binding calliper that has worn down the brake pad/disc is a 12aw job to remove/strip/clean etc and to replace a set of discs and pads on that axle is also 12aw's. Yet because the calliper has to be removed to replace the discs anyway, we would quote 18 aw's instead of 24 (if that makes sense to you?).
Great, thanks. I'll give them a ring tomorrow and see if they can adjust.

Is sticking a new flywheel in similarly easy once you've got the box out? I notice that in my estimate, they've apparently not included any labour for replacing the flywheel, just the part. Is that easy to do within the 51aw job they've already quoted?

BMWTech

13 posts

170 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Yes, it slots in easily, but they may add a few AW's to the job or round it up to 60AW's (5hours) that I mentioned earlier ;-) Simples!

gazchap

Original Poster:

1,546 posts

214 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
BMWTech said:
Yes, it slots in easily, but they may add a few AW's to the job or round it up to 60AW's (5hours) that I mentioned earlier ;-) Simples!
Yeah, that's cool. Cheers for the help. Them adding 9 AWs to the main job is preferable to them charging me for an additional 44 that aren't technically needed wink

gazchap

Original Poster:

1,546 posts

214 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Cheers for that, BMWTech. Raised that with them this morning and they've now sent through a new estimate almost a grand cheaper...

... makes me wonder whether that was a genuine mistake or not.

BMWTech

13 posts

170 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
No worries mate, need anything else just give a PM