Estate E60 or E90?
Estate E60 or E90?
Author
Discussion

Herbs

Original Poster:

5,132 posts

260 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Budget of 6-10k, small petrol or diesel for SWMBO - anyone with experience of both?

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Super pedantry BMWness but you can't get an estate E60/E90.

What you want is either an E61/E91...blah.

Depends how much room she needs really? Is it for ferrying kids/dogs around or extra space for something else???

kenno78

323 posts

186 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Have you asked her yet?

Herbs

Original Poster:

5,132 posts

260 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Of course I have asked her and awaiting to test drive both.

Will be used for kids and general load lugging.

kenno78

323 posts

186 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
When we were looking, SWMBO said the E61 was too big and preferred the E91. The E91 was also a lot more frugal which was a bonus.

The 330d we have is well suited to the auto box. Smooth, quiet and certainly picks up speed well. 30mpg around town, 45mpg on the motorway.

You should be able to pick up one for your price bracket if you don't mind a few miles on the clock.

Edited by kenno78 on Wednesday 7th November 17:37

Herbs

Original Poster:

5,132 posts

260 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Thank you.

Without seeing them side by side they seem very similar in size although the 5 series looks slightly wider.

I'm assuming as with all BMW's, most things will be options rather than standard spec?

Herbs

Original Poster:

5,132 posts

260 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Forgot to add what is the boot size & access like on a saloon?

kenno78

323 posts

186 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Herbs said:
Forgot to add what is the boot size & access like on a saloon?
Very good. A friend of mine has a E90 (saloon) and they have a baby. All of the baby bits (read travel system) fit in the boot. The saloon is also appealing over the estate from a price perspective. I think it's because there are more to choose from.

cerb4.5lee

45,371 posts

211 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
We had a e90 330d and tbh the boot size isn't that great but it's an awesome car as a allrounder, now got a e61 520d & apart from the diabolical engine it's a really good car, really comfy & very spacious with the seats down & practical with the split tailgate opening & quite a nice looking estate car.

I think the e90/91 doesn't look that great from the rear,charisma anyone?! But whichever you choose I don't think you will be disappointed, good luck with your search smile

Chr1sch

2,592 posts

224 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
I went e90 to e60(2011 320d to a Nov 06 530d msport) I also have a baby and all the stuff that goes with it...

They were both saloons and it's like chalk and cheese, I would have the 5 series without a shadow of s doubt.

Loads of room, far better creature comforts (stereo etc) much more refined, just as well built, and the 3.0d is a peach of an engine....

We coped with a saloon 5 but wish I'd bought a touring, I have since ended up with an A4 avant to save money but I miss my 5 series massively.

Try and avoid one with run flats, tyres are hugely expensive...

sp222

203 posts

180 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
I've had both - a '55 320d Msport E91, and a '57 525d E61. My wife preferred the 525 - i think she found the steering a little lighter, and the front and rear parking sensors probably helped too, and it was auto.

the 3 series will be a bit cheaper to run, mainly on fuel, although you said the smaller engined versions.. I know that there are loads of 520d's around, but a 4 cylinder in a 5er always seems a bit small IMHO.

There's a fair bit more space in the 5 series, but most of it is in the boot - it feels a bit wider and the rear is fine for 2 kids in seats/boosters, but as with most cars, when you have 3 you may struggle in both.

I've not looked for a while but you can probably get some fairly decent E61's for similar cost to the E91 - my 525 was an LCI model, and I traded it back in June for £10k with 92k miles and I saw it at a dealer for £12k. You can probably get some decent value for petrol models too..

let me know if you have any more specific questions on the two - and for reference, if I had to pick for me, i'd probably go for a 3 if I didn't need the space for 2 dogs..

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
If you need proper load lugging capability then E61. The E91 isn't that much more spacious than the saloon variant.

Timbo_S2

692 posts

294 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
I went from a E46 convertable, to an E91 320d when I had my first child, to a LCI E61 525d when I had my second...

5 series is much bigger, nicer in just about every way, though only slightly more costly to run. Lovely on long journys and tows my bikes well too. Average about 40mpg, get high 40's / early 50's on a run. E91 averaged 46mpg over 60k, but don't know if I would like to go back to a 4 cylinder not. Drove a 520d pre-lci auto and hated the engine, post lci was better. Felt that 520d's were better as a manual. Auto bos in the 3l diesel is pretty decent - when I change I have no idea if I'd go back to a manual now...

Herbs

Original Poster:

5,132 posts

260 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Thanks all. I currently have a Q7 for load lugging duties which this will replace allowing me to get another Z4M. My other half is expecting so need a good sized boot but access just as important.

Appreciate all thoughts so far.

KrazyIvan

4,341 posts

206 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Herbs said:
Thanks all. I currently have a Q7 for load lugging duties which this will replace allowing me to get another Z4M. My other half is expecting so need a good sized boot but access just as important.

Appreciate all thoughts so far.
I'd get the E61 then, we looked at both when we bought our E61 and it pretty much came down to the extra room (both in the boot and for the passengers), if your going from a Q7 you may miss the space you had if you buy the E91.

I am not sure on the mpg of the E91, but on a run in our E61 (177 520D) I can get 55mpg running at about 75mph, and about 45 round town, (Mrs Ivan is a little heavy footed and gets low 40's round town)

Only other thing I will add is that the 520D M-Sport on run flats has a pretty hard/harsh ride, we have just changed the tyres to non-run-flats and it does seem a lot better. But if like us you live around a lot of speed bumps and potholes you might want to get the none M-Sport version of whichever you buy.

And as others have said if you get a small petrol or diesel, get it with a manual.

Good luck with the pending arival.