Escort RS Cosworth to BMW 535D M sport or E90 330D MS.....?
Discussion
Guys and girls.
I currently own a 1995 Escort RS Cosworth, RWD, 400 bhp, ash black, really good spec and lovely condition.
Now its a hardcore car, fully polly bushed, hard suspension, strut braces etc... and I am getting a little tierd of planning my jorneys and trying to dodge speed bumps, thiefs, bad weather, rubbish roads etc.
We currently have a E46 330i Sport saloon which does all our donkey work... nice and safe for the kids, nice toys etc and it has been 100% brilliant so I am thinking of moving into another M Sport
Now I have pretty much struck a deal subject to vehical inspection on either a 2006 E90 33D M Sport saloon in an alright spec with a manual box or a 2005 E60 535D M Sport with some nice toys, nav, xenons, electric leather black etc..
Both around the 100,000 mile and both with full history.
Which would you go for?
It would be a straight swop for my car for one of these...?
I love my Escort and think it would be hard to part with her so need to get this right...
Thanks
Mark
I currently own a 1995 Escort RS Cosworth, RWD, 400 bhp, ash black, really good spec and lovely condition.
Now its a hardcore car, fully polly bushed, hard suspension, strut braces etc... and I am getting a little tierd of planning my jorneys and trying to dodge speed bumps, thiefs, bad weather, rubbish roads etc.
We currently have a E46 330i Sport saloon which does all our donkey work... nice and safe for the kids, nice toys etc and it has been 100% brilliant so I am thinking of moving into another M Sport
Now I have pretty much struck a deal subject to vehical inspection on either a 2006 E90 33D M Sport saloon in an alright spec with a manual box or a 2005 E60 535D M Sport with some nice toys, nav, xenons, electric leather black etc..
Both around the 100,000 mile and both with full history.
Which would you go for?
It would be a straight swop for my car for one of these...?
I love my Escort and think it would be hard to part with her so need to get this right...
Thanks
Mark
a4cabrio said:
As has been said, I'd value your RS at more than an 100k BMW 330d/530d. Sell the RS on its own and then look for a car if you really want rid of it. If someone has said they will do a straight swap for your car, for either BMW, they are having you over IMO
This, I'd sell the RS then find a replacement, are you sure you want to do this?Car in question

I have been told on a few forums now that the BMW's are not worth the kind of money he is asking... a quick look around shows a few others with simular spec and miles etc at the same kind of money, obviously this is what they are advertised for and not what they sell for.
hummmm, tricky one

I have been told on a few forums now that the BMW's are not worth the kind of money he is asking... a quick look around shows a few others with simular spec and miles etc at the same kind of money, obviously this is what they are advertised for and not what they sell for.
hummmm, tricky one
I could stretch to maybe a 325i M Sport E46 and use as a daily and take this off the road, but then I would incure storage costs etc and still have to insure her on laid up.
We have a 330i Sport at the moment E46, great car and I wish I could use that for 99% of my driving but the Mrs will not drive the Escort (which is fair enough)
Looking at it now, I do think the BMW's are over priced, I was getting the money I wanted for mine but when you weigh up the over priced cars then it puts my car value down.
Back to the drawing board I think, will leave it now until after Christmas, advertise the Escort for what I want and just stick to my guns on the price. Not like I am asking silly money for her
We have a 330i Sport at the moment E46, great car and I wish I could use that for 99% of my driving but the Mrs will not drive the Escort (which is fair enough)
Looking at it now, I do think the BMW's are over priced, I was getting the money I wanted for mine but when you weigh up the over priced cars then it puts my car value down.
Back to the drawing board I think, will leave it now until after Christmas, advertise the Escort for what I want and just stick to my guns on the price. Not like I am asking silly money for her
Good idea - then if you get proper money for it, you won't be upset. You can then look around for the perfect replacement. I paid ~17.5k for mine, with a few upgrades and tyres it was near 20k, and it only had 21k miles when I got it, almost brand new. If you do the same, you'll get a really nice BMW with less than 40k miles, rather than 100k - which is potentially big repair bill time (turbos, etc etc).
mboon said:
This is what scares me with all BMW Dervs, turbo failer 
I understand the older E9X used Mitsubishi turbo's (my series at least), and the later ones switched to Garrett which as you know (probably have one on your Escort), they are pretty bullet proof. But any Turbo might need refurbishment at 100k+. Mine is running 23+ PSI, so it's not a small amount of pressure on the turbo either.
Definitely try and aim for less than 40k miles.
Cheers guys...
I have thought about toning down the suspension but if I am honest it needs it to keep her in check with the rwd and the power, I think making it not so taught would make it a pig to handle
Thought about the E46 idea as well. Will keep this until after christmas and see how it goes. It is one of them cars that you can fall in love with one drive, but fall out of love with one bill
I have thought about toning down the suspension but if I am honest it needs it to keep her in check with the rwd and the power, I think making it not so taught would make it a pig to handle

Thought about the E46 idea as well. Will keep this until after christmas and see how it goes. It is one of them cars that you can fall in love with one drive, but fall out of love with one bill

Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




