D3 with over 100 miles - Bad idea?
D3 with over 100 miles - Bad idea?
Author
Discussion

jabriel

Original Poster:

322 posts

272 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
Hi folks,

I'm looking to replace my wife's car in the near future. I need something economical and have found an Alpina D3 (2007) with over 100k miles recorded.

Does anyone know or can anyone advise what these would be like to own from 100k miles upwards? I'm looking to buy something family friendly and something I don't need to change for another 4-5 years.

Annual mileage would not be more than 5-7k.



ETA - The title should D3 with over 100k miles...




Edited by jabriel on Wednesday 14th November 14:41

Sir_Dave

1,506 posts

241 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
Personally, if you're only doing 5k miles a year, i see absolutely no point in buying a derv Alpina over a petrol BMW. You are opening yourself up for a whole of more trouble if/when things break imho.

jabriel

Original Poster:

322 posts

272 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
You make a good point.

I could buy a Prius (and I actually don't mind them!) but on the odd occasion when I would need to drive it, I though it would be something I can enjoy. Perhaps I may even end up driving it more than I expect.

What I'm keen to know is if a D3 (even one with a FSH) is likely to be troublesome after 100k miles?



terry tibbs

2,423 posts

252 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
no its engineered for a lot more but service history will be important

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
Concensus seems to be that diesel engines don't like short journeys. Not a problem if that 5-7k is done in bigger chunks but it might cause problems if it's all short trips with no time to warm up.

If it's a good car though, personally, I'd chance it.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
jabriel said:
I could buy a Prius (and I actually don't mind them!) but on the odd occasion when I would need to drive it, I though it would be something I can enjoy.
His point wasn't that you should buy a Prius though, he was more getting at the fact there are plenty of 330i's around for less than the Alpina D3 which is surely a better place to spend 5k a year.

Nattyboy888

260 posts

188 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
In general you'll be fine. I've owned two with decent mileages and they haven't missed a beat..

Philrose

481 posts

273 months

Friday 16th November 2012
quotequote all
Alpinas are special, exclusive, rare and the D3 is full of character.

Kong

1,503 posts

202 months

Friday 16th November 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
jabriel said:
I could buy a Prius (and I actually don't mind them!) but on the odd occasion when I would need to drive it, I though it would be something I can enjoy.
His point wasn't that you should buy a Prius though, he was more getting at the fact there are plenty of 330i's around for less than the Alpina D3 which is surely a better place to spend 5k a year.
Exactly, at that mileage you're going to save about £5 a week by buying a diesel!

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Friday 16th November 2012
quotequote all
Much better to buy a 330i sport.
As much as I love the Alpina, it will have a crap interior, it will be a manual diesel (horrid) and it will be more than a nice 330i.

Why bother?

330i
260bhp
6.1 seconds to 60
Sweetest BMW engine ever imho, and a real drivers car.
£26 week in fuel doing 7,000 miles a year.

D3
197bhp
7.4 seconds to 60
Still a gruff 4cyl diesel even if it is tweaked.
£20 a week in fuel doing 7,000 miles a year.

As I said, why would you??

jabriel

Original Poster:

322 posts

272 months

Saturday 17th November 2012
quotequote all
When you put it like that, the 330 is the obvious choice...

The alpine does have the better suspension though. And possibly nicer wheels.

But these 2 factors don't outweigh the benefits you highlight. (IMO anyway...)

gizlaroc said:
Much better to buy a 330i sport.
As much as I love the Alpina, it will have a crap interior, it will be a manual diesel (horrid) and it will be more than a nice 330i.

Why bother?

330i
260bhp
6.1 seconds to 60
Sweetest BMW engine ever imho, and a real drivers car.
£26 week in fuel doing 7,000 miles a year.

D3
197bhp
7.4 seconds to 60
Still a gruff 4cyl diesel even if it is tweaked.
£20 a week in fuel doing 7,000 miles a year.

As I said, why would you??

4rephill

5,172 posts

209 months

Saturday 17th November 2012
quotequote all
jabriel said:
When you put it like that, the 330 is the obvious choice...

The Alpina does have the better suspension though. And possibly nicer wheels....
That's not a logical reason to chose the Alpina though as you can change the suspension and wheels on any BMW to whatever you like.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Saturday 17th November 2012
quotequote all
The D3 uses the m-sport struts and the springs off a 330xd.

The wheels if classics are nice, if dynamincs they look a bit ....meh.



terry tibbs

2,423 posts

252 months

Saturday 17th November 2012
quotequote all
alpina B3 then, if they are in budget

jabriel

Original Poster:

322 posts

272 months

Saturday 17th November 2012
quotequote all
4rephill said:
That's not a logical reason to chose the Alpina though as you can change the suspension and wheels on any BMW to whatever you like.
True but at an additional cost.