BMW Z3- why so much hate?
BMW Z3- why so much hate?
Author
Discussion

Bladefist

Original Poster:

61 posts

172 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Why the Z3 is so hated on the PH? I remember watching old TG where he (Tiff) totally loved the car. SO why so much hate on here?

mini1380cc

2,949 posts

202 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Because they are blinded so much by the mx5.

TommyL

75 posts

181 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
I had a Z3 2.2S for a weekend, just with delivery mileage on it and loved it to bits. Great and fun car to drive. I guess it's hate by insecure guys who are afraid people will think they're hair dressers or gay. It's a fun to drive car with classic car looks from the 507.

ChasW

2,163 posts

233 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
I have a Z3 3.0 and MX5 owners I know seem to be envious. I think it's the sound of the 6 cylinder engine. There is only one major drawback with the car in my opinion which is its boot size.

motco

17,674 posts

277 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
My main gripe, as with most modern cars, on my 2.2 Sport (made in the last week of production in 2002) is the fly-by-wire throttle. There seems to be a cotton wool wad between the pedal and the engine. The Z4 (certain models) has a 'sport' button which removes most of the wooliness, but sadly the Z3 does not. It sounds beautiful and handles quite well even on a track. The reason I don't take it to the track more than I have is two-fold: I have a westfield and that is more appropriate if the weather suits, and the Z's brakes aren't up to the punishment as standard. A lot of ill-informed prejudicial rubbish is spouted about certain cars; the Z3 is one. The 1.9 was a bit under powered, admittedly, but no-one can say the Z3M isn't a pretty decent car even by the standards of 2012. Don't tar all with one brush, and try it before you knock it.

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Right now I am hankering after getting a 1.9 and sinking some wedge into stroking it out to 2.1 along with the usual breathing mods and mapping in order to up the HP but keep the weight low and handling light. Can't afford such a thing right now but it's good to have relatively attainable goals to aspire to smile

ChasW

2,163 posts

233 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Whilst the subject is topical a friend of mine who is a bit of a mechanic and has had some decent cars in his time drove my Z3 3.0 litre and suggested a re-map may add more zip. Looking at the mapping sites it seem you get about another 17bhp. Any experience of re-maps/

OldSkoolRS

7,300 posts

210 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Vsonix: To be honest, as prices seem to have nose dived (since I bought one this year of course they would rolleyes) ) you might as well buy one of the various bigger engined cars to start with IMHO. Unless it's the lighter weight of the 4 cylinder that you want, but the Z3 isn't the last word in handling finesse anyway, so a 2.8/3.0 with a strut brace and ploybushes, maybe lowered too, is about all you can do anyway. It has made a difference to mine (apart from lowering as I haven't done that - yet).

I know I paid over the odds for mine, even allowing for the prices that have further dropped since I got it, but I've really enjoyed having it this summer. I've spent more time tinkering about with it than I have in the last 10 years on other cars, so it's helped reignite my interest in cars.

I do sometimes read the 'Z3 hate' threads and I am reminded that there are other alternatives that I could have spent my 5k on. However, I also have to remind myself that one criteria was for a car that could sit outside on my drive and not draw unwanted attention to itself. Perhaps a Porsche Boxster might have been a better option (sticking with the 6 cylinder requirement I had), but it could well have been a 'bork' waiting to happen and DIY servicing would probably decimate the value far more than the same on a Z3. I also think it would have been more likely to get keyed or vandalised for being a bit 'flash' (even though the same price range).

Chas: I'd be interested to hear how you get on if you have a remap. Even though it's the fastest car I've ever owned (sheltered life, I know wink ) a little more power/sharper throttle response wouldn't be a bad thing.

Edited by OldSkoolRS on Sunday 18th November 17:42

ChasW

2,163 posts

233 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
OldSkool

I quite like the "lazy" response on mine but my previous car was a 2008 130i M Sport which was lively in comparison to the Z3. I doubt that I'll opt for the re-map as I'll probably sell and get a 2.9 Boxster. Luggage space is an issue as we cannot use it for long weekends away.

OldSkoolRS

7,300 posts

210 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Ah well, I'll have to think about taking the jump myself then Chas. Good luck with the Porsche. smile

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
OldSkoolRS said:
Vsonix: To be honest, as prices seem to have nose dived (since I bought one this year of course they would rolleyes) ) you might as well buy one of the various bigger engined cars to start with IMHO. Unless it's the lighter weight of the 4 cylinder that you want, but the Z3 isn't the last word in handling finesse anyway, so a 2.8/3.0 with a strut brace and ploybushes, maybe lowered too, is about all you can do anyway. It has made a difference to mine (apart from lowering as I haven't done that - yet).

Edited by OldSkoolRS on Sunday 18th November 17:42
Well, I went from a 318ti Sport to a 328i Sport and really what I miss most about the 318ti was the nimble feeling. Yes, the 328i is definitely faster, and maintains more performance under load (i.e. a passenger and some luggage) as well as being more refined & less tiring on long trips. The thing is, I'd started to do some engine mods on the M44 and was starting to appreciate the flat spots in the torque curve were starting to disappear and the whole car felt eager and sporty - and yet I was still only putting £5-10 into the tank instead of £10-20 which made it feel like cheap fun whenever I fancied popping out for a blat round the lanes. I'm assuming a standard 1.9 Z3 would have a fairly similar feel to the 318ti as they have the same suspension and wheelbase except of course the Z3 would bring the whole wind-in-hair thing. I've never felt quite as comfortable hustling along NSL country lanes in either of my coupés as in my Compact.