Juddery start - clutch?
Juddery start - clutch?
Author
Discussion

Mk3Spitfire

Original Poster:

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 19th October 2013
quotequote all
Not having much luck with cars lately.
So, have noticed that recently, when pulling off, especially from cold my car judders slightly in 1st. Never any problems in any other gear, and normally after its warmed up I don't get the problem again except maybe when pulling out quickly on an uphill.

Is this a sign of the clutch going, or is something cheaper and easier?! I would love for it to be the second, but fear it may be the first.


Locknut

653 posts

168 months

Saturday 19th October 2013
quotequote all
The clutch in my E90 diesel has been doing that since about 5k miles. (I assume the judder comes as you release the clutch). I brought it back to the dealer but I could not get it to judder during the test drive. It has 42k miles on it now and it is still the same. I think it might be a feature of the dual mass flywheel.

Mk3Spitfire

Original Poster:

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 19th October 2013
quotequote all
Locknut said:
The clutch in my E90 diesel has been doing that since about 5k miles. (I assume the judder comes as you release the clutch). I brought it back to the dealer but I could not get it to judder during the test drive. It has 42k miles on it now and it is still the same. I think it might be a feature of the dual mass flywheel.
Ah ok. Interesting. Yes, it is at the very start of the clutch release when pulling off the first time. It hasnt been worrying me as it seems to stop after warming up and I haven't found any other signs of clutch failure yet. Maybe it isn't the big problem after all. Cheers mate.

Jayyylo

986 posts

178 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
I have the big problem quickly approaching and it scares me to go near the car now. Once it goes, I'm on my bike everyday.

MitchT

17,166 posts

240 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
What car do you have OP?

My July '99 E36 318is has had clutch judder all its life (I've had it from three months old) when cold, as has my OH's February '05 120d. Neither car has got any worse or needed the clutch changing so far. There's been a lot of talk on here about apparent clutch judder in BMWs but very little of anyone ever finding a solution other than to stop worrying and live with it.

M3greg

220 posts

157 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
I'll second the above - driven lots of manual BMWs at work (E60s and E90s) and they all had clutch judder, especially when cold and in 1st. Could not be anything to worry about.

RicksAlfas

14,607 posts

275 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
It's a fairly common problem. Lots of chat here:
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

My 60 plate 320ED juddered very badly until I had a new clutch fitted and it's been fine ever since.
I suspect the newer parts are modified, but BMW aren't shouting about it.

Geeman39

8 posts

157 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
Could it be due to the Clutch Delay Valve? My colleague has a 320ED (E90 LCi facelift) and his is caused by that. Same symptoms, goes away once warmed up. Apparently a common "feature" in 1 and 3 series at least...

ccr32

1,984 posts

249 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
M3greg said:
I'll second the above - driven lots of manual BMWs at work (E60s and E90s) and they all had clutch judder, especially when cold and in 1st. Could not be anything to worry about.
They all do that, sir...

Both my E85 Z4 and current E92 325i have done this, and have been informed by BMW tech's that it's nothing to worry about

(touch wood!)

ETA: I find that a few more revs when pulling away in 1st tends to eliminate it - probably won't help with the life of the clutch, but feels a lot nicer.

8Tech

2,221 posts

229 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
Whilst it may be nothing to worry about, it is still a fault.

A new dual mass flywheel and clutch would rectify it but BMW are hardly going to advertise that fact. Can you just imagine the cost of rectifying all those cars under warranty?

It's also not a feature. I cannot imagine the engineers discussing the design of the car and saying, "lets make this premium brand car have clutch judder, that will be a good selling point".

Its more likely to be the accounts dept deciding on either how to make the clutch cheaper, or how to engineer-in the requirement for a clutch and flywheel once the warranty has expired.

Geeman39

8 posts

157 months

Thursday 24th October 2013
quotequote all
8Tech said:
It's also not a feature. I cannot imagine the engineers discussing the design of the car and saying, "lets make this premium brand car have clutch judder, that will be a good selling point".
Sorry, I work in IT. A "feature" is a tongue in cheek way of saying there's a glitch or other issue, common in MS software that has lots of niggles/bugs etc that need fixing but probably never will be, so we call it a "feature!"

aussieal

583 posts

192 months

Thursday 24th October 2013
quotequote all
My 330i was the same when I first got it, all the reading I did seemed to point to the clutch delay valve.

After a couple of weeks, my driving style adjusted to it and it's not been an issue since.

Does seem strange though, surely people don't stall enough to justify building something in to reduce it.

JRBM5

161 posts

170 months

Friday 25th October 2013
quotequote all
Do you use V Power fuel? This has been known to cuase severe juddering / jerkiness when the car is cold and when moving off in 1st gear...

Just thought i'd offer it out as an alternative....

RicksAlfas

14,607 posts

275 months

Friday 25th October 2013
quotequote all
The juddering I experienced was so severe it was nothing but a transmission problem.
Fully loaded car, steep hill start and it was an absolute pig. Replacement clutch made it like a new car.

frag68

273 posts

175 months

Friday 25th October 2013
quotequote all
My E90 320d has done this since I got the car 2nd hand from a BMW dealer over 3 years ago. With 60,000 miles since then, it is no worse or better. The OH drives it mainly but it isnt that bad that we cant live with it. The car now has over 100K on it.

to3m

1,228 posts

201 months

Friday 25th October 2013
quotequote all
My E46 330d has juddered ever since I got it. If lifting the clutch at low revs, the car judders. The solution in my case is just to rev the engine a bit as you lift the clutch. 1200rpm is enough. This has never got worse or better, and doesn't seem to actually be causing any particular problem, so I've put up with it - but I do note that I never had to do this with my E46 320d! When I drove that, I was in the habit of lifting the clutch fully before pressing the accelerator...

(The 330d also goes clonk when accelerating after changing gear, particularly from neutral to 1st or 1st to 2nd. That's supposed to be a common fault, too. I probably just got one that's a bit poorly put together.)

Mk3Spitfire

Original Poster:

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 26th October 2013
quotequote all
Hi, not been on in a few days, so thanks for your replies guys.

You all seem to have exactly the same as me then. A few extra revs when pulling off seems to sort it. Its not unbearable by any means, just a bit annoying/unnerving when you don't know what it is. I will put up with it, as the bd is already costing me a fortune recently! It is a 59 plate 320d btw. I will keep an eye on it and hope it doesn't get any worse.

Thanks again.

Court_S

14,830 posts

208 months

Saturday 26th October 2013
quotequote all
My E46 325ti used to do the same too. Quite a lot of people blame the clutch delay valve.

Mk3Spitfire

Original Poster:

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 26th October 2013
quotequote all
Court_S said:
My E46 325ti used to do the same too. Quite a lot of people blame the clutch delay valve.
Whatever that is/does, I can live with it! As long as it isn't the big C itself, I will struggle on.

Court_S

14,830 posts

208 months

Saturday 26th October 2013
quotequote all
Mk3Spitfire said:
Whatever that is/does, I can live with it! As long as it isn't the big C itself, I will struggle on.
I'm not an expert, but my understanding is that it was fitted to help the American market, although this could just be internet heresy.