2006 E92 335i - Coils and/or Injectors
Discussion
Hi guys
Just got the car back from BMW Specialists. They did a diagnostics for £54 and said the injectors had gone on cylinder 1 and 3. Recommended I replace all injectors and coils, or at the very least to replace the two faulty ones with injectors and coils. Quoted me £1,800 to replace all 6 including fitting, or £720 to replace just the two.
They did say that if I got my own parts, they could fit them for £102. I decided to ring up my friend who works for Eurocarparts and he said he could order me 2 and fit them for £520. I decided to look on eBay for some used ones instead, and there is a set of 6 going for £220. How reliable would these be? Is there any way to tell the condition? Or should I just bite the bullet and fork out the £520?
Furthermore, I was speaking to another friend who has a local indy. He told me that the symptoms suggest it is more likely that it is just the coils that are faulty, and that I should replace them first, which I can get 2 for £70. Do you guys think I should go the 'coils first then injectors' route? And if it is the injectors, should I trust buying used, or is it not worth it? And lastly, are those prices that the BMW Specialists quoted reasonable?
Just got the car back from BMW Specialists. They did a diagnostics for £54 and said the injectors had gone on cylinder 1 and 3. Recommended I replace all injectors and coils, or at the very least to replace the two faulty ones with injectors and coils. Quoted me £1,800 to replace all 6 including fitting, or £720 to replace just the two.
They did say that if I got my own parts, they could fit them for £102. I decided to ring up my friend who works for Eurocarparts and he said he could order me 2 and fit them for £520. I decided to look on eBay for some used ones instead, and there is a set of 6 going for £220. How reliable would these be? Is there any way to tell the condition? Or should I just bite the bullet and fork out the £520?
Furthermore, I was speaking to another friend who has a local indy. He told me that the symptoms suggest it is more likely that it is just the coils that are faulty, and that I should replace them first, which I can get 2 for £70. Do you guys think I should go the 'coils first then injectors' route? And if it is the injectors, should I trust buying used, or is it not worth it? And lastly, are those prices that the BMW Specialists quoted reasonable?
Those injectors for £100, are they new? If so, where can I get them at that price? If it does come down to the injectors, I wouldn't mind getting 2 for £200 and paying £100 for fitting. I've been checking out some videos on YouTube, and it seems like a small procedure to replace them. Would they not just work by taking out the faulty ones and putting in the new ones?
The symptoms are that the engine management light is on, it shakes quite a lot when idle (like at the lights or when waiting to turn), there's also black smoke coming out of the exhausts which I'm guessing is the unburnt fuel not going into the cylinders, and it also has been using a lot of fuel which I guess is because it's being wasted. I had a friend read the codes via the OBD which came up as misfire on cylinders 1 and 3 (also said misfire on multiple cylinders). I could feel it misfiring when I was driving as well.
Yes they recommended to replace both coils and injectors, but were adamant it was the injectors. It's kind of reassuring that they may be wrong, I really don't want to be spending so much money on it if I can avoid it. I'll go ahead with the coils first.
The symptoms are that the engine management light is on, it shakes quite a lot when idle (like at the lights or when waiting to turn), there's also black smoke coming out of the exhausts which I'm guessing is the unburnt fuel not going into the cylinders, and it also has been using a lot of fuel which I guess is because it's being wasted. I had a friend read the codes via the OBD which came up as misfire on cylinders 1 and 3 (also said misfire on multiple cylinders). I could feel it misfiring when I was driving as well.
Yes they recommended to replace both coils and injectors, but were adamant it was the injectors. It's kind of reassuring that they may be wrong, I really don't want to be spending so much money on it if I can avoid it. I'll go ahead with the coils first.
Replacing a coil pack in a 30 min job which you can do your self with minimal of tools (I did this my self recently for a misfire on cylinder 3).
To check if it's the coil packs just move the coil pack from 1-3 to cylinder 2-4, and if the misfire error codes move to cylinder 2-4 you know it's the coil packs. They are £50 from a dealer but can be sourced cheaper online.
Replacing the injectors aren't too hard either but your need some coding software to program them(INPA), if you simply google 'INPA injector coding' there's even a YouTube video to show you what to do
One thing is for sure spending nearly £2k to replace all the injectors/coils really isn't the best advice, remember the garge just wants to get the problem fixed, and am sure replacing all your injectors/coils will do it but it certainly isn't the cheapest option, and may not be necessary.
It could also be something as simple as spark plugs....again if you google 335i misfire diagnosis your quickly see there are plenty of cheaper ways to go before doing the replacing everything method
To check if it's the coil packs just move the coil pack from 1-3 to cylinder 2-4, and if the misfire error codes move to cylinder 2-4 you know it's the coil packs. They are £50 from a dealer but can be sourced cheaper online.
Replacing the injectors aren't too hard either but your need some coding software to program them(INPA), if you simply google 'INPA injector coding' there's even a YouTube video to show you what to do

One thing is for sure spending nearly £2k to replace all the injectors/coils really isn't the best advice, remember the garge just wants to get the problem fixed, and am sure replacing all your injectors/coils will do it but it certainly isn't the cheapest option, and may not be necessary.
It could also be something as simple as spark plugs....again if you google 335i misfire diagnosis your quickly see there are plenty of cheaper ways to go before doing the replacing everything method

Watch this and your find misfires are really not that much of a issue on 335s.,,
http://youtu.be/FsNK1ySAlSo
http://youtu.be/FsNK1ySAlSo
Injectors need to be replaced in 'banks' - so cylinders 1 to 3 or 4 to 6. There has also been an updated injector released. Injectors do need to be coded for precise fuel control but the engine does run without coding.
Coils are relatively cheap at £30 ish apiece, but injectors are around £250 each from BMW last time I checked.
Coils are relatively cheap at £30 ish apiece, but injectors are around £250 each from BMW last time I checked.
Thanks for the link to that video, seems like an easy enough job. Got to get some power tools as all I have is allen keys and spanners.
Question: would I *have* to change sparks when I change the coils or could I *just* change the coils? The guy at Eurocarparts seems to suggest so, but in that video, the guy only changed the coils. Would be a problem for the sparks since I don't have that BMW spark specific tool.
I'm picking up two coils tomorrow. £26.34 for Bosch on Eurocarparts so very good on price. Hopefully this will be it and no need for injectors. Or at least give me another year of of these.
Also, if it does happen to be the injectors after all, by replacing them in 'banks' does that mean I'd need to replace injectors for cylinders 1, 2 and 3?
Question: would I *have* to change sparks when I change the coils or could I *just* change the coils? The guy at Eurocarparts seems to suggest so, but in that video, the guy only changed the coils. Would be a problem for the sparks since I don't have that BMW spark specific tool.
I'm picking up two coils tomorrow. £26.34 for Bosch on Eurocarparts so very good on price. Hopefully this will be it and no need for injectors. Or at least give me another year of of these.
Also, if it does happen to be the injectors after all, by replacing them in 'banks' does that mean I'd need to replace injectors for cylinders 1, 2 and 3?
Edited by LaFuriaRoja on Friday 7th March 16:16
LaFuriaRoja said:
Also, if it does happen to be the injectors after all, by replacing them in 'banks' does that mean I'd need to replace injectors for cylinders 1, 2 and 3?
Unfortunately, it does mean replacing all three. There's quite a bit of info on this on 'e90 post' website. Check out the N54 section.Edited by LaFuriaRoja on Friday 7th March 16:16
If it is the injectors then don't hang around replacing them. I went from ropey start and engine warning light to catalytic converter meltdown within a couple of weeks. This was due to overfuelling of the cylinders apparently, the cats literally melted and fell apart. Almost cost me 5 grand. Neither Warranty Direct or a BMW warranty would have covered the cats irrespective of them being damaged by the injectors. Thankfully BMW UK stepped up and agreed to cover a big chunk of the parts (injectors and cats).
I only had one bank of injectors replaced but kind of wish I had the full set as I could do without that happening anytime soon!
Dan
I only had one bank of injectors replaced but kind of wish I had the full set as I could do without that happening anytime soon!
Dan
How can it cost nearly £5K to replace 1 bank of injectors and the cats?? Lots of people remove the primary cats anyways, so all you need is the secondary cats to pass the MOT, no idea how much they cost but cannot imagine it costing that much....For £5K you can afford to buy/import hybrid turbos from the states get them fitted, get it remapped for the new turbos, and have change left over. I really don't understand how BMW dealers sometimes come up with their repair cost??
gangzoom said:
How can it cost nearly £5K to replace 1 bank of injectors and the cats?? Lots of people remove the primary cats anyways, so all you need is the secondary cats to pass the MOT, no idea how much they cost but cannot imagine it costing that much....For £5K you can afford to buy/import hybrid turbos from the states get them fitted, get it remapped for the new turbos, and have change left over. I really don't understand how BMW dealers sometimes come up with their repair cost??
It's a long story! I should have mentioned the high pressure fuel pump failed again as well as the injectors. The primary cat overheated and fell to bits and subsequently damaged the secondary cats. The £5k would have included the diagnostics, cost of injectors, HPFP and the cats which are about £1k a piece. The labour was about £200/hr if my memory serves me correctly. It took BMW over a month to diagnose and fix from start to finish. Not their finest hour and seriously damaged my waning faith in the dealers. I almost did take it to Birds on the back of a flat bed lorry in bits to have the work done there with racing cat replacement and a tune to cure the depression it caused. This would have cost more than I had to pay with the BMW UK contribution and warranty contribution so I stuck with it.
Dan
I'm at 71K miles now, but have been the only driver. Did decide to do the plugs just in case that was the cause, but no luck in curing the overall problem, however, 3 of the sparks weren't completely burnt out.
Changed the coilspacks on cylinder 1 and 3, and sparks on all. Still misfiring, but not as much. Think I'll go with changing the rest of the coils on the weekend.
Kind of looking more and more likely it is the injectors. So far I've spent £54 on diagnostics, £60 on 2 coils, £60 on 6 spark plugs and £30 to fit the sparks since I didn't have that specialist tool.
I've not really been driving the car much since the problem occurred, which has been about a month now. Just gives me a reason to max out the missus' car.
Will change the rest of the coils over the weekend and report back. But first, I might just try checking out the coils that are installed, as it was suggested that the coilpack on cylinder 5 looked pretty bad, so may just have replaced a good one.
Changed the coilspacks on cylinder 1 and 3, and sparks on all. Still misfiring, but not as much. Think I'll go with changing the rest of the coils on the weekend.
Kind of looking more and more likely it is the injectors. So far I've spent £54 on diagnostics, £60 on 2 coils, £60 on 6 spark plugs and £30 to fit the sparks since I didn't have that specialist tool.
I've not really been driving the car much since the problem occurred, which has been about a month now. Just gives me a reason to max out the missus' car.
Will change the rest of the coils over the weekend and report back. But first, I might just try checking out the coils that are installed, as it was suggested that the coilpack on cylinder 5 looked pretty bad, so may just have replaced a good one.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


